Last Friday, New York Times executive editor Dean Baquet made a statement to the Financial Times that I disagreed with strongly. In the broadest of terms, Mr. Baquet disparaged the election coverage of both CNN and Fox as “ridiculous” and “bad for democracy.”
Though Mr. Baquet didn’t mention MSNBC, I couldn’t imagine a scenario in which he would find that cable news network a more sober purveyor of journalism’s best practices than its higher-rated rivals.
I took umbrage mostly because consuming a lot of CNN lately has forced me to revise my once low opinion of anchor Don Lemon; his sudden mastery of the crazy panel interview format has put him at the same level as his colleague Anderson Cooper. They’re a great one-two punch on CNN now.
So I complained to several of my colleagues about Mr. Baquet’s singling out cable news for being “bad for democracy” when the threat was far more complicated than CNN’s hiring of Trump campaign shill Corey Lewandowski as an on-air contributor or “Fox & Friends” complicity in creating the Trump phenomena.
Within an hour I was eating my words and doubling down on Mr. Baquet’s critique of CNN and Fox. The news about FBI Director James Comey’s letter to congressional Republicans updating them about thousands of new emails that could be pertinent to the Clinton investigation broke in the early afternoon.
What followed next were hours of hysteria, shameless speculation based on nothing and some of the most misleading news coverage Americans have ever been witness to in the sprint to Election Day.
Read More
The laptop at the center of the renewed investigation of Ms. Clinton’s emails belongs to former New York congressman Anthony Weiner, the estranged husband of Huma Abedin, the candidate’s closest aide.
Mr. Weiner is being investigated for suspicion of engaging in inappropriate texting with a 15-year-old across state lines. After Mr. Weiner’s laptop was confiscated, the FBI became aware of thousands of emails connected to Ms. Abedin that may — or may not — have some bearing on the Clinton investigation.
Contrary to all precedent and common sense so close to Election Day, Mr. Comey sent a letter filled with just enough ambiguities for Donald Trump to seize upon as evidence of Ms. Clinton’s rank criminality. He lost no time in calling the emails on the laptop “the biggest political scandal since Watergate.”
Such a claim would be hilarious if not for the fact most Americans have no idea what Watergate is and have no frame of reference to know how ridiculous a comparison it is.
Mr. Comey’s superiors and colleagues in the Justice Department warned him not to send the letter to Republican leaders because it would be tantamount to interfering with the election’s outcome. Former DOJ officials from both the Obama and Bush administrations have denounced Mr. Comey’s actions as not only premature but blatantly partisan and stupid.
Republican officials and even conservative talk show hosts have decried Mr. Comey’s stunt because they know it could just as easily be their next presidential standard-bearer compromised by an “October Surprise” from the DOJ. Consequently, there are serious questions about Mr. Comey’s intentions in doing what he did as well as his fitness to serve as FBI director. It is doubly infuriating to learn that he hasn’t read any of the emails.
Meanwhile, a foreigner would be forgiven for assuming that the level of manic giddiness on display during those early hours of the “scandal” on Friday was consistent with the almost unbearable weight of the story’s constituent parts — a narrative that is equal parts “Mr. Robot,” C-SPAN and “To Catch a Predator.”
It wouldn’t be a surprise to anyone if Ms. Clinton, her head shaved like Cersei Lannister’s on “Game of Thrones,” was forced to march naked to her next congressional inquisition. That way, the ranking Republicans could pelt her with garbage the way the angry peasants of King’s Landing showered their queen with rotten vegetables in the finale of the fifth season.
Realistically, Ms. Clinton isn’t likely to see many defections because of Mr. Comey’s folly, but that doesn’t mean an increasingly demoralized Trump campaign won’t exploit it for all it is worth. If anything, folks in states that don’t have early voting are eager to go to the polls if only to put this interminable nightmare of an election behind us.
Hillary Clinton will be elected the 45th president of the United States next week. Donald Trump will be humiliated and rendered irrelevant. Mr. Comey will find a gracious way to resign in a year because the president doesn’t trust him. Sounds like justice to me.
Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631. Twitter TonyNormanPG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.