Pittsburgh City Council members — many dissatisfied with the return on investment so far from a multimillion-dollar comprehensive plan — voted this week to cancel those contracts in an attempt to reclaim whatever remains of the initial $6 million deal.

But outgoing Mayor Ed Gainey has said council doesn’t have the authority to force him to terminate the contracts, and he won’t abide by the legislation.

“A majority of council — from very different parts of the city, from very different ideologies — all agree that this process is not working, has not been valuable, is not creating an output that we want to support,” Councilman Bob Charland said ahead of the Monday vote. “For something that’s supposed to be driving where the city goes until 2050, a majority of council members say the directions are bad.”

Proponents of the plan say it would lay out a vision for city public policy for much of the next three decades, addressing issues such as land-use regulations and zoning restrictions.

Advertise with us

But specific results seem to be few: Residents have complained that the comprehensive plan seemed to be vague on issues such as “housing,” “clean water” and “economic opportunity.” Council members have questioned how those overarching ideas would translate into specific strategies and policies.

A spokesperson for Mr. Gainey did not immediately return a request for comment Friday, but the mayor has made it clear since the bills were introduced that he does not support the termination and will not cancel the contracts.

In a statement Dec. 17, Mr. Gainey said council’s proposals to cancel the contracts amounted to “legislative overreach,” maintaining that he has the sole authority to terminate contracts and council cannot compel him to do so.

City Council moved forward with the legislation and passed the two measures Monday.

“The reason there is a city council is, we are in control of the budget and purse strings,” Councilwoman Deb Gross said. “We’ve already paid an enormous amount of these consulting contracts. If we can claw back $2 million, I’m fully supportive and I think it’s the right vote to do today.”

Advertise with us

Some members continued to express concerns about the legality of their actions.

Councilman Anthony Coghill, who introduced the measure to pull out of the contracts Nov. 18, said that when he asked the city’s law department to weigh in, officials there told him to ask the mayor’s administration. That, he said, seemed moot considering the mayor’s stance.

“I guess it’s going to be like this,” he said. “If the mayor doesn’t sign off, it will expire and it will be in the lap of the next administration whether to resubmit the same papers and do exactly what we did through here or to continue on and go back into the contract with the existing company.”

Mr. Charland said the legislation sends a message and whether the administration wants to continue paying the contracts “will be for a legal fight to decide.”

Council President R. Daniel Lavelle, who ultimately voted against canceling the contracts, said it’s legal for council to pass the bill but “the ramifications of that are a different question.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Coghill introduced the legislation to cancel the contracts a week after a contentious post-agenda meeting with Jamil Bey, the director of city planning, and Sharonda Whatley, the assistant director of strategic planning who is shepherding the project.

Council members at that meeting with Mr. Bey on Nov. 11 questioned what the city has actually gotten from the contracts — a joint contract worth about $3.4 million with HR&A Advisors and Urban AC for technical work on the plan, and another worth $2.6 million with Common Cause Consulting to engage the community in the planning process.

“I think what you’re hearing is a lot of buyer’s remorse,” outgoing Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith told Mr. Bey and Ms. Whatley. “I think there’s a lot of frustration — the city’s not doing well financially.”

That meeting marked the first time several council members began floating the idea of trying to scale back the work that remains to be done in order to save the city money in light of its financial straits. Council earlier this week passed the city’s 2026 budget, which includes a 20% property tax hike.

Mr. Bey said Nov. 11 that money left over from the initial $6 million remains under contract. Beyond that, he said, “I believe this is a necessary tool for the city to grow.”

Advertise with us

Council was split when it initially approved the comprehensive plan contracts in early 2024.

When Mr. Coghill introduced legislation to terminate the contracts, he wrote in the legislation that the city is “facing serious financial constraints” and council members and the mayor were obligated to “responsibly steward the [city’s] finances.”

Mr. Lavelle and Councilwoman Erika Strassburger voted against killing the contracts, though Ms. Strassburger noted that her vote hinged on her belief that council didn’t have the authority to do so. Councilman Khari Mosely voted against canceling one contract but abstained from voting on the other because of his affiliation with groups involved.

Some council members took particular issue with what they viewed as a serious lack of community engagement — despite the $2.6 million contract meant to do just that. Councilwoman Barb Warwick said ahead of the vote Monday that there hadn’t been any type of engagement meetings in any of the neighborhoods in her district, which covers most of the southwest corner of the city.

“It’s really bad form on the part of the city planning team for council to have such grave concerns over a project they are overseeing that we expressed loud and clear … to the point where we have this vote to cancel the contract and then be told, ‘No, we’re not going to do it’ — it’s not a great look,” she said.

Advertise with us

Councilman Bobby Wilson went so far as to apologize to those council members he’d lobbied to vote in favor of the initial contracts.

“I think if I’d have listened to council members [who were against the contracts] then, we could have probably gotten a cheaper deal — a better deal,” he said, saying it’s a position he now regrets. “I think the will wasn’t really there originally, and we could have avoided this if I didn’t push as hard.”