On Jan. 6, 2021, former Vice President Mike Pence found himself at the center of a constitutional firestorm on what became one of the most harrowing days of political violence in the country's history.
His president — and, he says, a friend with whom he would “never had a cross word” until that day — wanted him to ignore more than two centuries of precedent and the peaceful transfer of power by sending some certified electors’ votes back to the states instead of presiding over their counting.
Outside the U.S. Capitol, President Donald Trump’s supporters called for Mr. Pence’s hanging.
“I believe by God’s grace I did my duty that day,” Mr. Pence said Thursday during a panel on faith, civility, and public service at Duquesne University.
The former vice president said his decision to defy the president in that moment — and part of the solution to moving forward in what he called the most politically divided era of his lifetime — came down to honoring the founding principles of the country and sticking to the teachings of his deeply held Christian faith.
“January 2021 was ultimately grounded in a promise I made in January 2017: I put my hand on Ronald Reagan’s Bible … and I took an oath to support and defend the Constitution of the United States, and it ended with a prayer, ‘So help me God,’ ” he told Duquesne President Ken Gormley. “I always thought that was a promise I made to the American people and a promise I made to almighty God. My duty was clear.”
He added that he dismissed “out of hand … early on” the theory among Trump and some Republican allies that a vice president had the authority to choose which Electoral College votes to count.
“The American presidency belongs to the American people,” he said. “There’s maybe no idea more un-American that the notion that any one person could choose the American presidency.”
Mr. Pence said he had difficult conversations with Trump on the issue that effectively ended their previously strong relationship.
But he urged the hundreds of students and guests gathered at the Duquesne Power Center ballroom to stand their ground and embrace challenging conversations about integrity when duty and faith require them.
“Adversity doesn’t create character,” he said. “Adversity reveals character.”
The panel, which also featured retired Rear Admiral Alan Baker, the 16th Chaplain of the United States Marine Corps, and Paul McNulty, president emeritus of Grove City College and a former U.S. deputy attorney general, was one of a series at the private Catholic university on civil discourse.
Without directly addressing political violence, panelists often spoke of the need to combat polarization. The country has faced two assassination attempts on Trump last year, including one at a Butler County campaign rally, an arson attack against Gov. Josh Shapiro in April, shootings of Minnesota lawmakers and their spouses in June, and the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk in September, among other incidents of violence and an increase in threats to lawmakers, their staffs and families.
Political and election experts tell the Post-Gazette that concerns over isolation, radicalization over social media, and extremism have impacted politics dramatically in recent years, from increased security measures to worries that many citizens who would want to serve in office will simply choose not to run at all.
Mr. Pence said polarization and political divides are at odds with not only the tenets of the Christian faith but also with progress and the rule of law.
He acknowledged that he didn’t always live up to his faith and American ideals. He said that during a congressional campaign long before he became vice president, a friend told him that a nasty political ad targeting an opponent hurt him as a candidate and belied his values.
While his faith had taught him, "do unto others as you would have them do unto you," he had bought into the political game of “do unto others before they do unto us.”
“In those campaigns I didn’t just lose an election, I lost my way,” he said. “I had a very deep sense of regret.”
After some soul searching, he wrote an essay called “Confessions of a Negative Campaigner,” and he told himself that if he ever ran again he’d stick to his ideals that he had failed to live up to in the public square.
“Democracy depends on heavy doses of civility,” he told Mr. Gormley. “The American people long for us to restore a threshold of civility in public life.”
Mr. McNulty said that while the Constitution made clear the country would never establish any religion, that doesn’t mean there’s a total separation between faith and politics.
“Religious values were just taken as a given and a necessary component of what it meant to ensure civility and virtue … [which] was necessary for freedom,” he said, speaking of the Founders.
He cited faith leaders’ efforts to help spur “the greatest reforms in American history — think about the abolitionist movement … workplace reforms in the progressive era, and, of course, the Civil Rights movement and the explicit religious language of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.”
Mr. Pence emphasized that as a congressman he built a strong friendship with the late Rep. John Lewis, the Georgia civil rights icon who, along with former President John F. Kennedy, inspired Mr. Pence to start his political career as a Democrat. His relationship with Mr. Lewis — built in large part by their shared public faith — did yield some bipartisan agreement on a few issues even though they disagreed on almost everything, he said.
Mr. Pence defended Congress when Mr. Gormley pointed out that most Americans believe Capitol Hill, particularly the House of Representatives, “is a place of partisan divide and rancor.”
“One of the best kept secrets in America is that most of the people serving in office in Washington, D.C. are sincere, hardworking people,” he said. “Now, in the age of the internet and social media and before that, cable television, the attention tends to go to a certain type of person on the left and on the right. But … an overwhelming majority of folks … are really there to get a job done and to create a record that will improve the quality of life in the district and state they represent.”
He added that he doesn’t think “this business of civility is a casual idea at all.”
Mr. Pence cited congressional rules of decorum that require opponents to reference even fierce opponents as “my good friend from Pennsylvania” or “gentlelady from Indiana.”
“I love a debate, I love to joust on the issues, I enjoy telling liberals they are wrong,” Mr. Pence said, adding that he’s working on a book highlighting partisans taking his own party in a far-right populist direction. “But … I can say your ideas are bad without saying you’re a bad person. The people that I have admired most, on both sides of the aisle, are the people who understand where that line is. And if you respect that line … it makes a possibility [for] principled compromise to happen.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.