Voters in Allegheny County faced critical choices in the 2025 primary that could shape their courts, the county’s legislature and the future of Pittsburgh for years to come.
Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor defeated incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey in the Democratic primary, all but guaranteeing he will become Pittsburgh’s next mayor. In the Republican primary, former Pittsburgh police detective Tony Moreno defeated local businessman Thomas West.
Voters in the city of Pittsburgh are also voting on three ballot measures that would amend the Home Rule Charter, the document that lays out what the government can and can’t do. Three seats are also up for grabs on Allegheny County Council.
Numerous seats for Superior Court and Commonwealth Court are also up for votes, in addition to a high-profile race for Philadelphia district attorney.
LIVE UPDATES
——————————
Read More
11:52 p.m.
Newcomers elected to Pittsburgh Public School Board
The Pittsburgh Public School Board will likely see several new faces following Tuesday’s primary election, a heated race that came as the district is considering a controversial school closure plan.
In all, newcomer Tawana Cook Purnell, District 1; Erikka Grayson, District 3, incumbent Tracey Reed, District 5; and newcomer Eva Diodati, District 7, are moving forward in the race, unofficial results posted shortly after 11 p.m. Tuesday show.
The District 9 race had not yet been called as of 11:30 p.m. That race, which pitted incumbent Gene Walker against newcomer Allie Petonic, remained close throughout the night. Shortly after 11 p.m., the two were neck-and-neck, having both secured 50% of the votes.
The heated race came as the district is considering a school closure plan that would shutter 14 schools across the city and change grade structures at 12 others — a key point in this year’s primary. Now, a new set of school directors will take over the plan. The district will present an updated feasibility report following Wednesday’s agenda review meeting.
— Megan Tomasic
Read more: Newcomers elected to Pittsburgh Public School Board, one race yet to be called
——————————
11:45 p.m.
Winners emerge in contested County Council races
Kathleen Madonna-Emmerling and Aaron Adams were the likely winners of the only contested Democratic primaries Tuesday for Allegheny County Council seats.
With about 84% of precincts reporting, Ms. Madonna-Emmerling, of Moon, was leading in the District 1 race with 76% of the votes, besting Carl Villella, also of Moon. District 1 covers many communities in the western side of the county; its incumbent, Jack Betkowski, a Democrat, did not seek re-election.
Mr. Adams, of Duquesne, with about 54% of the vote and roughly 78% of precincts reporting, appeared poised to defeat Dylan Altemara, of Elizabeth Township, and Kellianne Frketic, also of Elizabeth Township. Democrat Bob Macey, the District 9 council member since 2006, is stepping down after this year. That district covers southeastern Allegheny County and covers much of the Mon Valley.
District 9 had a fourth Democrat running, Daniel Davis. But he withdrew to focus on his duties as a West Mifflin Borough Council member, and supported Mr. Adams in the primary.
— Steve Bohnel
Read more: Kathleen Madonna-Emmerling, Aaron Adams poised to win contested Allegheny County Council primaries
——————————
11:37 p.m.
Pittsburgh voters approve 3 ballot referendums
Pittsburgh voters appeared poised to approve all three referendums on the ballot Tuesday, including preventing the city’s water and sewer authority from being sold to private operators amid a national trend of some local systems doing so under financial pressure.
That issue was Question 2 on Pittsburghers’ ballots. It was passing with about 78% of the vote as late Tuesday.
Pittsburgh Water has stated in recent years that it had no intention to privatize, but city voters made it official Tuesday, pending a certification of election results by the Allegheny County elections board.
The other two questions on the ballot had to do with the city’s Home Rule Charter.
Question 1, which was approved with about 69% of the vote, asked whether anti-discrimination policies that already are fixtures of the city code should be included in the Home Rule Charter.
The policies concern “the basis of race, religion, ancestry, sex, sexual orientation, age, gender identity or expression, disability, place of birth, national origin or association or affiliation with any nation or foreign state in conducting business of the city,” according to the official language.
In other words, the city can’t do business with organizations that discriminate.
All City Council members supported this question, along with the one preventing the privatization of the water and sewer system.
Question 3 concerned prohibiting any Home Rule Charter amendments that go beyond Pittsburgh’s legal abilities. It appeared to be passing, with about 57% of the vote, late Tuesday.
— Steve Bohnel
Read more: Pittsburgh voters approve 3 ballot referendums on Home Rule Charter, water and sewer system
——————————
11:20 p.m.
Gainey in concession speech: ‘Be glad of the progress that we made’
With the loss, Mr. Gainey has become the first Pittsburgh mayor in modern history to run for re-election and only serve one term. His win in 2021 made him the first Black mayor of Pittsburgh, elected amid a series of social justice protests sparked by the murder of George Floyd.
“It ain’t over, it’s called a continuation,” Mr. Gainey said during his concession speech, where he called his administration up to the stage and thanked them.
He congratulated Mr. O'Connor on his victory, gently scolding the crowd who booed at the mention of his candidate.
"There's one thing we're not gonna do. We're not gonna spread hate. We got enough hate in this city ... of course we'll congratulate Corey," Mr. Gainey said.
Much of Mr. Gainey's speech was a plea to his teary-eyed supporters to remain vigilant in their activism amid a volatile political climate.
"You showed this whole city what it means to be a city for all," he said amid cheers. "Young, old, Black, white, Latino, Palestinian, Jew, Christian, Islamic — they're all right in this room," he said.
He continued, "Be glad of the progress that we made. It would've been easy for me to bow down to power. But it was more exhilarating to fight it for you."
He gained the support of city residents through his sermon-like speeches at union events, news conferences, rallies and community events, often weaving his personal life experiences in with his goals for the city.
— Laura Esposito

——————————
10:38 p.m.
O’Connor addresses supporters
Addressing supporters at Nova Place on the North Side shortly after 10:30 p.m., with his wife, Katie, on stage with him, Corey O’Connor expressed his thanks to his family, supporters and campaign team as he celebrated his victory over incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey.
“Thank you to everyone in this room and the voters of the city of Pittsburgh,” he said.
Mr. O’Connor said Mr. Gainey called him shortly before he took the stage.
“No matter who you support in this primary, we must now stand together as Democrats because we’ve only started this journey,” Mr. O’Connor said. “Pittsburgh should be every family’s first choice, and we’re going to do that.”
— Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
——————
10:08 p.m.
Corey O’Connor wins Democratic primary for Pittsburgh mayor, unseating Ed Gainey
Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor pulled off a rare political feat Tuesday night, unseating incumbent Mayor Ed Gainey in an intense, competitive primary that at times appeared to be a proxy for the national battles between the progressive and moderate wings of the weakened Democratic party.
Mr. O’Connor had received 54% of the vote against Mr. Gainey, who received about 45% as of about 10:10 p.m. Tuesday. Although rare for a challenger to unseat an incumbent, particularly in a dark blue area like Pittsburgh, this marks the second time in a row that voters have decided to make a change in city hall.
The Associated Press called the race just after 10 p.m.
With this loss, Mr. Gainey has become the first Pittsburgh mayor in modern history to run for re-election and only serve one term. His win in 2021 made him the first Black mayor of Pittsburgh, elected amid a series of social justice protests sparked by the murder of George Floyd.
He gained the support of city residents through his sermon-like speeches at union events, press conferences, rallies and community events, often weaving his personal life experiences in with his goals for the city.
For months, Mr. O’Connor had a significant momentum advantage over Mr. Gainey. He outraised the incumbent in fundraising for months; aired commercials earlier and earned the support of the majority of city council members.
— Hallie Lauer
——————————
9:49 p.m.
Tony Moreno wins GOP primary for Pittsburgh mayor
After a previously unsuccessful bid for mayor, retired police officer Tony Moreno will once again appear on the ballot in November after beating small business owner Thomas West in the primary election.
Mr. Moreno received 61.9% of the votes to Mr. West’s 26.4% as of 9:50 p.m. Tuesday night with 66% of expected votes counted, in the first competitive Republican primary in about two decades.
The Associated Press called the race about 9:45 p.m.
Mr. Moreno ran as a Democrat in the 2021 primary election, where he didn’t win but garnered enough write-in votes to appear as a Republican on the November ballot that year. Current Mayor Ed Gainey defeated Mr. Moreno handily in the general election.
Mr. Moreno faces an uphill climb — Pittsburgh hasn’t elected a Republican mayor since the 1930s and Democrats hold a significant voter registration advantage over Republicans.
The retired police officer focused much of his campaign on bettering the city’s public safety and increasing transparency.
— Hallie Lauer
——————————
9:03 p.m.
Gainey, O’Connor supporters start to gather
After the polls closed, supporters from both Democratic mayoral campaigns gathered to wait for results.
About 50 of Mr. O’Connor’s supporters were at Nova Place on Tuesday evening shortly after the polls closed.
Mr. O’Connor took an early lead after the mail-in ballots were announced, though many at the event hadn’t even checked yet.
Of the more than 17,000 mail-in ballots cast in the city, Mr. O’Connor had received about 65% of the votes – which some supporters took as a good sign early in the night.
“If he can keep that lead up, we’ll be in good shape,” one attendee who declined to be named said.
Televisions stationed around the room played Mr. O’Connor’s campaign ads, while guests sipped beer and wine and listened to music ranging from Taylor Swift to the Jackson 5.
Supporters and volunteers from Mr. Gainey’s campaign trickled into the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers in the South Side, where Mr. Gainey is expected to wait for voting results.
About 8:30 p.m., jazz music sounded from a large DJ booth as about two dozen supporters and volunteers conversed animatedly and sipped soft drinks.
— Hallie Lauer and Laura Esposito
——————————
8 p.m.
Polls close across Pa. as race for Pittsburgh mayor takes center stage
Polls have closed across the state, and election officials are beginning to tabulate the results of key primary races for mayor, judgeships and County Council.
The first results are likely to be posted to the Allegheny County elections website soon, as workers count nearly 78,000 mail-in ballots that they have been scanning into tabulation machines throughout the day.
More than 19,000 of those were cast in Pittsburgh, where Mayor Ed Gainey has been battling for months to win a second term against a well-funded, well-known challenger, Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor.
The race has attracted national attention, and outside groups have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars attacking the candidates in what some have called a proxy war among progressive and moderate factions of a deeply divided Democratic Party.
For Republicans, Allegheny County could play a pivotal role in primary races for Superior and Commonwealth court seats. More Republicans live in the county — 264,000 in all — than any other in Pennsylvania.
But in an off-year election, voter turnout is typically just a fraction of what it is when higher-profile races like presidential or senate contests are on the ballot. Four years ago, less than a third of the county’s voters cast ballots, and only about 34% of the city’s voters weighed in on the mayor’s race.
— Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
——————————
O’Connor voter wants more options for homeless people
Marci Lane, 41, and her husband, Michael Iskoe, 40, of Mount Washington each voted for Corey O'Connor on Tuesday.
"Honestly, my primary reason was I thought that he was more electable and he was more likely to win the general election than Gainey, in my opinion," Mr. Iskoe said. "I also just thought that Gainey has had a shot. I haven't seen the level of results that I wanted to see, and I think that Corey should get a shot as well."
Mrs. Lane believes keeping the city clean should be one of Pittsburgh's priorities, and she would love to see homeless people have access to shelter.
Phil Bohn, 34, who works at BNY Mellon, agreed.
"Trying to revitalize our streets, make this place fun to walk around and stuff, I'd like to be able to exist in Pittsburgh without really needing a car, ever," Mr. Bohn said.
"I think if we're going to try to get this place ready for the [NFL] draft that Gainey's been yapping about for a while, the best way to do that is going to be to get these places so that people want to go to them again."
Still, Ms. Lane also wants Democrats to be unified.
"One of the things that I was very interested in is getting someone that all of the left and the Democrats can really agree on," Ms. Lane said. "I really think we need to be united, and I feel like Corey might be able to bring that back together."
Mr. Iskoe also believes Pittsburgh should be focused on the future.
"What's going to make [Pittsburgh] a hub five years from now?" he said.
— Samuel Long
——————————
These voters opt for Gainey over his record and trans rights
Choosing a mayoral candidate was difficult for Nicole Sanna.
Both candidates seemed to share many of the same positions and focused on rhetoric over policy, Ms. Sanna said. But Ms. Sanna, a graduate student at Carnegie Mellon University, ultimately landed on Mr. Gainey.
She said she believes the mayor has done “a good job doing what he can so far” during his time leading the city. And she felt Mr. O’Connor was part of the so-called Democratic establishment.
“Ed Gainey seems to have a better sense of what minorities in the city need,” Ms. Sanna, 22, said outside of the Soldier and Sailors Memorial Hall & Museum polling place in Oakland.
Top issues for Ms. Sanna included affordable housing and immigration. Mr. Gainey has been strong on both issues, she believes.
“I think what Gainey has done so far in limiting ICE’s ability to enforce warrants in Pittsburgh added brownie points for him,” she said.
Audrey Flynn, a registered Democrat, voted for Dan Miller for judge and Ed Gainey in the mayor's race, with priorities of trans rights, public transportation and environmental conservation.
Initially, Flynn was "unsure for the mayor's race going into voting today" but talked with and was swayed by a volunteer for Mr. Gainey.
Flynn decided to vote for Mr. Miller because they believe in "trans people having access to medical care and having judges support what people want."
Flynn's concerns while voting centered around public transportation and street narrowing that would provide "safety in neighborhoods."
— Maddie Aiken and Katie Hovan
——————————
What’s up with the ‘I Voted’ stickers n’at?
As voters cast their ballots Tuesday in Allegheny County, new “I Voted” stickers greeted them.
The circular sticker is split horizontally by a filled-in Pittsburgh skyline. The top is outlined by a blue and red line with the words “I voted.” The bottom pays homage to Pittsburgh with black and gold strips outlined on the bottom, three gold stars on the outline and the words “N’at!”
That sticker was designed by Molly Bozick, a 10th grader at Mount Lebanon High School. Molly won a contest held by the Allegheny County Elections Division in the fall amongst high school students to design a new sticker for the primary.
More than three dozen designs were submitted, and the public was invited to vote for the winning sticker.
— Katie Hovan

——————————
Democratic mayoral candidates vote Tuesday
The Democratic Pittsburgh mayoral candidates were both at the polls Tuesday morning to vote.
Mayor Ed Gainey said he felt good right after he voted at the Paulson Recreation Center at roughly 10:10 a.m. Tuesday.
The mayor said he was proud of the campaign his team ran, and rattled off his work on building affordable housing, reducing violent crime, particularly among city youth, and expanding recreation center hours, among other initiatives.
"This really comes down to two candidates, one for the people, and one for corporate interests," the mayor said.
Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor voted at Pittsburgh Linden K-5 just after 8 a.m. With his wife, Katie, daughter, Molly and son, Emmett, he entered the location’s polling place with a smile.
“I want to thank all the volunteers that got us to this point. Obviously, my family, we couldn’t have done it without them — especially my wife Katie, who was in charge of these two monsters for a couple of days,” Mr. O’Connor said of his son and daughter after voting.
He said that voters have a choice during this election.
“We can take our city in a different direction where we’re more transparent,” he said. “We talk about growth and opportunity in all areas and, standing here with my family, I think Pittsburgh should be every family’s first choice. And I think that’s the type of administration we would build.”
— Samuel Long and Jacob Geanous
——————————
Spending in the race for mayor
The high-stakes Democratic primary between Mayor Ed Gainey and Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor has drawn an unprecedented amount of spending — including from wealthy outside groups — at a time when the city faces dire challenges to its finances and a housing crisis that has put homeownership out of reach for many young families.
For months, the candidates have clashed sharply over Mr. Gainey’s stewardship during the three years since he beat former Mayor Bill Peduto during a time of national political upheaval and massive protests over racial justice across the country.
The battle has split City Council — with five members backing Mr. O’Connor and four supporting the mayor — and exposed deep rifts in the local Democratic Party as the progressive wing tries to hold onto a key position of power it won during its years-long ascendancy in Western Pennsylvania.
— Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Read more: Pittsburgh at a tipping point in high-stakes race for mayor
——————————
Pittsburgh Home Rule Charter
The city’s voters will also be given three chances to amend the Home Rule Charter, the document that lays out what the government can and can’t do.
Two of the questions were added to the ballot in reaction to a campaign to force the city to stop doing business with any companies affiliated with Israel. The activists who wanted to bar the city from doing business with Israeli-linked companies — a response to the war in Gaza — had tried to get their own amendment on the ballot but fell short.
One of the measures before voters today would add language to the charter saying the city can’t refuse to do business with a person or company based on “race, religion, ancestry, sex, sexual orientation, age, gender identity or expression, disability, place of birth, national origin, real or perceived, or connection, association or affiliation with any nation or foreign state.”
The second would bar future ballot questions that could force the city to do something that’s against the law.
Yet another choice Pittsburgh voters will have to make is whether they want to bar the city from selling its water and sewer systems to a private company.
Ballot referendums like those are open to any voters who want to weigh in. But in races between candidates, Pennsylvania’s election laws only allow people to vote in a party primary if they’re registered with that party.
— Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Read more: City residents voting on three ballot measures
——————————
Competitive races for Allegheny County Council
Two down-ballot yet important races are on the primary ballot in some areas of Allegheny County — one where elected office holders have control over a budget of over $3 billion, and a say over matters like operations at the county jail, property reassessments, and how to help city officials address homelessness.
Many of the Allegheny County Council primary races on Tuesday are unopposed.
But in two districts — District 1, covering the western side of Allegheny County, and District 9, covering many Mon Valley communities — Democrats Jack Betkowski and Bob Macey are stepping down. Those are the only competitive council races where multiple Democratic candidates are vying to replace them.
— Steve Bohnel
Read more: Two competitive races could shape Allegheny County Council’s future





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.