School closures, federal changes to education and inequities between schools dominated the discussion Tuesday during a forum where candidates vying for a seat on the Pittsburgh Public Schools Board took a stance on major issues facing the district.

The forum, held at the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers building on the South Side, drew all nine Democratic candidates seeking one of five open seats on the board.

District 1 has two candidates, Carlos Thomas and Tawana Cook Purnell. The seat is currently held by Sylvia Wilson who is not seeking re-election. In District 3, currently held by Sala Udin, who is not running, Tonya Fores is facing Erikka Grayson.

Incumbent Tracey Reed is running unopposed to keep her District 5 seat.

Advertise with us

Both District 7 and District 9 have two candidates. In District 7, a seat held by Jamie Piotrowski, who is not seeking re-election, Mahdi Bey will face Eva Diodati. And in District 9, incumbent Gene Walker is facing Allie Petonic.

Here’s where the candidates stand on key issues:

School closures

As incumbents, Ms. Reed and Mr. Walker defended the need to close schools.

School directors for more than a year have been considering school closures and consolidations in response to declining enrollments and a growing budget deficit. They are currently working on a plan that would shutter 14 schools and change grade structures at 12 others.

“As leaders we are under constant pressure to not make the decision that is so obvious that we have to make,” Mr. Walker said. “And we don’t live in a city that can support 54 school buildings. We don’t have the teaching capacity and the administration to support schools that have 120, 150 kids and so we have to think strategically about how we manage that problem.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Reed agreed, adding that she “would be the first person in the front of the line saying, ‘Do not close a single school’ if we were really doing a great job by the kids in our district. But we’re not.”

But newcomers to the race, including Ms. Petonic, took issue with the process the board has followed throughout the process, citing a lack of data and community input. The process, Ms. Petonic said, has “broken trust.” Ms. Fores said she simply would not close schools.

Mr. Bey added that schools “are the centers of communities and should be treated as such.” He questioned where people would find work if the vital buildings are closed.

Diodati has looked through both the district plan and one presented by community members.

“Going forward my plan, focus on community, make sure we’re doing the best we can but let’s be realistic about it, too,” Diodati said. “We’ve got to do something. We can’t stay still.”

Advertise with us

School inequities

A key issue for several candidates was inequities between district schools based on an annual teaching and learning environment survey.

The problem, many candidates said, boils down to teacher support.

“We need to make our schools places that students and staff want to be in,” Ms. Petonic said. “It makes me think about how student learning conditions are teacher and staff working conditions. When you improve one you improve the other.”

Teachers, Ms. Grayson said, often hold multiple roles such as helping students get ready for the day or filling vacant spots in the cafeteria line.

“If we give teachers the capability to be able to not just be a teacher and meet the kids where they are before they even get to the classroom, that could really stop a lot of the issues the kids are having in the classroom to be able to succeed in school,” Ms. Grayson said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Thomas added that opening lines of communication will create better school environments.

“The communication barrier’s broken,” Mr. Thomas said, pointing to four areas — administrations, teachers, students and parents.

“A lot of times from a parent perspective I don’t know what’s going on in the classroom until something amazing happens or something terrible happens,” Mr. Thomas said. “I don’t hear from the administration unless something amazing happens or something terrible happens. … I think putting that in perspective will help the environment be a lot better.”

Federal directives

In addition to local issues, questions also focused on the Trump administration, which has taken aim at K-12 education through diversity, equity and inclusion orders and its efforts to dismantle the U.S. Department of Education. Given those topics, questions touched on the district’s AP African American Studies and a new ethnic studies course.

“I feel we cannot take away the history of us,” Ms. Grayson said, noting that she is a Black woman raising three Black children in the city. “If we don’t learn and understand our history we are doomed to repeat it. This is not the time to sit idle.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Purnell added that no matter what “we continue to number one tell the truth. Just because we hide the truth doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. We must treat every single student in our school system and his or her or they family with respect, period. It’s that basic.

Ms. Petonic called Trump a “tyrant,” and said the district cannot comply with his orders, something Ms. Reed heavily leaned into.

“One of the things that frightens me is to the extent in which people are complying beforehand, unnecessarily complying with ideas from the federal government,” Ms. Reed said. “That’s one thing that I have been a staunch opponent of. There’s no reason for us to start removing ethnic studies and reversing our stance with regard to African American history.”

Those changes, Ms. Reed said, are “a slippery slope.”

In addition to those issues, candidates also touched on charter schools, the need for community schools in the district and declining populations across the city.

The primary election is May 20.