With his team trailing New Castle by three points in the fourth quarter of the WPIAL Class 4A championship game, Montour quarterback Brandon Bennett gathered his teammates around him just before the Spartans offense took the field.
“I said, ‘Boys, this is it right here. Do you want to be remembered or do you want to be a “what if” team?’ ” Bennett said while standing on the turf at Pine-Richland High School.
“And they said they want to be remembered.”
Bennett capped a memorable championship game by leading Montour on a long touchdown drive highlighted by his 10-yard scoring run with 42 seconds left to give the Spartans a thrilling 31-27 win and their first WPIAL title since 2011.
“It’s an emotional day. Our kids played great and our coaches coached their butts off,” Montour coach Lou Cerro said. “When you play a team like New Castle who just keeps on going and keeps on going and keeps on going — that’s the type of people they are. Hats off to them, but hats off to my team for never quitting.”
It’s the sixth title overall for Montour (10-2), which got big performances from Bennett, a junior, and sophomore running back Archie Collins. Collins (169 yards, one touchdown) and Bennett (99 yards, two touchdowns) headlined a Montour rushing attack that racked up 276 yards on 50 carries. Bennett also completed 6 of 10 passes for 69 yards and a touchdown.
The game included a huge rally from New Castle (8-4), which came all the way back from a two-touchdown deficit as it tried to win its first title since 1998.
Montour led 24-21 after three quarters, and began the fourth with a first down at the New Castle 46. But on the next play, Collins fumbled and the ball was recovered by New Castle’s Ashton Clark.
New Castle has a young star quarterback of its own in sophomore Marino Graham, and Graham used his legs to fuel a scoring drive that gave the Red Hurricanes their first lead via Jermaine Walker’s 2-yard touchdown run with 7:14 left in the game. The extra point attempt failed, but the Red Hurricanes held a 27-24 lead.
Graham ran for 125 yards and a touchdown on 15 carries and was 4-of-6 passing for 30 yards and an interception.
Facing its first deficit, Montour sent its offense onto the field with 7:10 left and the ball at its own 30. What followed was a 13-play, 70-yard drive that saw Bennett and Collins accounting for all of the yardage. Bennett finished it off when he took the snap, took off, shook a defender, and ran into the end zone for a 10-yard touchdown to put the Spartans ahead 31-27 with just 42 seconds left. Montour threw only one pass on the drive.
“We were very fortunate to run the ball well tonight,” Cerro said. “It seemed like they didn’t stop it much, so we said let’s do it, and that’s what we did.”
New Castle still had some time to work with. Starting at its own 20, it took the Red Hurricanes just five plays and a pass interference penalty to move the ball to the Montour 40.
Down to one play with the clock showing five seconds, Graham looked to find a receiver downfield but was sacked by Montour’s Dyllen Liddell on the game’s final play.
Montour’s win came a week after the Spartans got a touchdown pass from Bennett with 21 seconds left to slip past McKeesport 37-33 in the semifinals.
“We don’t want it to happen like that,” Collins said with a smile, “but we still came out on top, and that’s what matters.”
With the win, Montour got some revenge after New Castle ended the Spartans’ season in last year’s quarterfinals. The Parkway Conference rivals also played on Oct. 9, when Montour rallied from two touchdowns behind to claim a 26-21 win.
For a while in the first half, it looked like Montour might be on its way to a comfortable win. Collins scored on a 40-yard touchdown run and Bennett connected with Zander Stern for a 17-yard touchdown to give the Spartans a 14-0 advantage.
But New Castle used a big defensive play early in the second quarter to get right back into the game.
Montour had moved the ball to the New Castle 25 and appeared to be headed for a three-touchdown lead when Swayzee Reighert sacked Bennett, stripped the ball, and returned it 57 yards for a touchdown to put the Red Hurricanes on the board with 10:06 left in the half.
“They had two turnovers on us and they were able to capitalize,” Cerro said. “You can’t turn the ball over against New Castle.”
Bennett would stretch the Montour advantage to 21-6 with a 4-yard touchdown run with 5:21 remaining in the half, but New Castle answered with a Walker 2-yard scoring run and a 2-point pass to pull within 21-14 late in the first half.
Montour extended its lead midway through the third quarter on Dalton Young’s 22-yard field goal. That’s when Graham and Walker followed with their touchdown runs to put the Red Hurricanes ahead 27-24 in the fourth quarter.
As Bennett suggested, Montour will be remembered for winning a WPIAL title in 2026.
And before the Spartans take on District 10 champion General McLane in next weekend’s PIAA quarterfinals, Bennett said there will be some celebrating.
“I’m going to take my boys out to eat,” he said. “We’re going to go have fun. Probably going to have a little party. But we’re not going to get too crazy because the job ain’t done.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.