Tuesday is the day for two down ballot yet important races on the primary ballot in some areas of Allegheny County — one where elected office holders have control over a budget of over $3 billion, and a say over matters like operations at the county jail, property reassessments, and how to help city officials address homelessness.
Many of the Allegheny County Council primary races on Tuesday are unopposed.
But in two districts — District 1, covering the western side of Allegheny County, and District 9, covering many Mon Valley communities — Democrats Jack Betkowski and Bob Macey are stepping down. Those are the only competitive council races where multiple Democratic candidates are vying to replace them.
District 9
District 9 has three Democrats running — Aaron Adams, Duquesne resident and mechanical designer at AE Works, a Sewickley-based architecture and planning firm; Dylan Altemara, an Elizabeth resident and educator at Community College of Beaver County; and Kellianne Frketic, an Elizabeth resident who manages inventory control at the Greater Pittsburgh Community Food Bank.
Mr. Adams declined to comment, and Mr. Atlemara and Ms. Frketic could not be reached for comment.
Daniel Davis, a West Mifflin resident and manager at an architecture and planning firm based in Columbus, told the Post-Gazette this week he withdrew from the race in order to focus on his role as a West Mifflin council member, and focus on issues like the future of the Century III Mall site and Mon-Fayette Expressway, among others.
Read More
Mr. Davis said he’s throwing his support behind Aaron Adams. Mr. Adams also is endorsed by Mr. Macey.
District 9, in the southeastern part of the county, includes West Mifflin, Munhall, and Duquesne and includes other Mon Valley communities like McKeesport, Lincoln, White Oak and Elizabeth.
Mr. Macey has been in that seat since 2006. Whoever wins the Democratic primary will likely face Patrick Provines, director of field operations for a private ambulance service and vice chair of Elizabeth’s Republican Committee, in November.
Mr. Macey said whoever replaces him needs to focus on economic development — he said the Mon Valley has gone roughly 30 years without what he considers major improvement or projects in that area.
“I want to see housing. I want to see the first responders better-educated. I'd like to see businesses come to the community, and we need to, especially take some of the blighted areas and start putting homes there like single-family [ones],” Mr. Macey said.
An Lewis, executive director of the Steel Rivers Council of Governments, has been working for that organization and in the Mon Valley for more than two decades. Economic development and revitalization of District 9’s communities should be a focus of whoever replaces Mr. Macey, she said.
And while being an advocate for the region is important, it’s only one part of the job, she said.
“Allegheny County has a lot of money funneling through its coffers from higher levels of government and [it’s] making sure that the deployment of that money is happening where the need is,” Ms. Lewis said.
District 1
In District 1, Mr. Betkowski has backed Kathleen Madonna-Emmerling, a Moon resident who works in alumni engagement at the University of Pittsburgh. Ms. Madonna-Emmerling declined to comment, citing an ongoing labor dispute involving some Post-Gazette workers.
Her campaign website shows she wants more public transportation services in the district, tax incentives for businesses and developers to invest there, and a fair system when it comes to property reassessments statewide. She’ll face Carl Villella, president of a local financial brokerage who helps local governments with financing for construction equipment. District 1 includes Moon and Findlay townships, and snakes across the Ohio River through Haysville, Neville, Avalon, West View and Ross and Ohio townships.
Mr. Villella said in a brief interview this week that his first priority would be holding the line on property tax increases, adding he opposed the nearly 40% bump approved by County Council last year.
He added that funding public safety and creating more affordable housing are important issues in the district, and touted endorsements from multiple local labor unions.
“My experience as a small business owner has made me uniquely qualified to address those issues,” he said.
Mr. Villella or Ms. Madonna-Emmerling will likely face Republican Mary Jo Wise, a special assistant to the CEO and community liaison of the Forbes Funds, in November.
Outside of those two races, four other districts — 3, 4, 8, and 12 — are seeing uncontested elections in the Democratic primary. Council President Patrick Catena in District 4, Michelle Naccrati-Chapkis in District 8, and Bob Palmosina are all incumbents running unopposed.
In the other race, Anita Prizio is stepping down from District 3 this year, and only Lissa Geiger Shulman, a Hampton resident and self-employed policy consultant, remains on the Democratic ballot. Kenneth Aquiline, who resides in Sharpsburg and is a co-founder of a local nonprofit, Semper Fi Mission, withdrew weeks ago.
Ms. Shulman will face W. Christopher Lochner, the only Republican running in District 3.
Uncontested primary races like in District 3 or elsewhere are not ideal for voters, Mr. Villella said.
“It’s important to have competitive races and have the voters decide,” he said.
Update, posted 2:25 p.m. May 19, 2025: This story was updated to include the Republican running in District 3.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.