Add a Lawrenceville resident as the latest person arguing that a countywide property reassessment is needed — but, in this case, an outside party could be called in to complete one.

In a lawsuit filed earlier this month, Leo Quigley and his attorney, John Silvestri, state that a reassessment is needed because of the history of how Allegheny County officials have handled the process. The last time the county completed one was in 2011 and 2012, when a judge ordered it to be completed.

The suit names county Executive Sara Innamorato, Chief Assessment Officer Lou Fabian, Senior Deputy Allegheny County Manager Stephen Pilarski and county Manager John Fournier as defendants.

In recent years, there have been multiple lawsuits aiming to force the county to do a reassessment. One of them, which was dismissed by an Armstrong County judge, was filed in part because Pittsburgh Public Schools felt the current system was inequitable and unconstitutional. But Kenneth Valasek, who retired as a judge years ago but presided over the case, said the school district did not have the legal right to file suit.

Advertise with us

Ira Weiss, the district’s solicitor, has said he is appealing that decision. The school district has lost millions of dollars in revenue as property owners of high-rise buildings in Downtown has successfully appealed their property assessments in recent years.

Mr. Quigley’s lawsuit is similar in many ways, but it also calls for a “master” — or outside party — to complete the lawsuit because of the history of how county officials have handled property reassessments.

“The appointment of a master to supervise the [countywide] reassessment is an appropriate and necessary equitable remedy where a department of local government is as broken as the Allegheny County Office of Property Assessments,” the suit reads in part.

Reassessments were one hot issue during the county executive’s race in 2023, with Ms. Innamorato and Republican candidate Joe Rockey both stating that changes to Allegheny County’s system were needed. Since entering the office, Ms. Innamorato has said that state officials need to pass legislation to require regularly scheduled property reassessments across Pennsylvania.

State Sen. Wayne Fontana has told the Post-Gazette in recent months he will introduce legislation to do that. It’s uncertain if the state Legislature will act on it this year.

Advertise with us

County officials declined comment on Mr. Quigley’s suit. Mr. Silvestri said, given the history of property reassessment cases across the state, he is confident he and his client will win in court because the current system in unconstitutional.

“The key reason for my optimism is that legally, what’s going on is wrong,” Mr. Silvestri said. “And when I read the history of cases of reassessment, not only in Allegheny County but also the most recent one in Beaver County, if the judges follow law that is precedent, the only conclusion is we should be reassessed.”