About 24 hours before Pittsburgh City Council approved Mayor Ed Gainey’s budget for 2025 on Tuesday, City Controller Rachael Heisler distributed a letter to members expressing her concerns over the projected spending for overtime.
Eight of the nine council members voted to approve the budget, despite many concerns raised over the past few months, including those outlined in Ms. Heisler’s letter.
Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith was the only vote against the budget on Tuesday, citing Ms. Heisler’s letter as one of the reasons. She said hearing the concerns and not having adequate time to properly look into them made her “uncomfortable” with approving the budget Tuesday. All other council members approved the budget.
In her letter, the controller warned that “overtime expenditures for 2024 have already exceeded the amounts allocated in the 2025 budget.”
It was distributed Monday in advance of Tuesday’s vote.
The concern is primarily concentrated in overtime spending related to public safety bureaus and the Department of Public Works, which handles things like snow removal and street sweeping.
Read More
So far this year, the fire bureau has spent about $20 million in overtime and is budgeted for $16.5 million for next year. Police have spent $18.6 million and are budgeted for $15 million in 2025, and EMS has spent about $6.7 million and is allocated $3.6 million next year.
The Department of Public Works has spent about $3.5 million and is budgeted for $2.3 million next year.
“Those discrepancies raise concerns about the city’s ability to meet its financial obligations,” Ms. Heisler’s letter states.
Both the police and EMS bureaus are severely understaffed. As of early December there were 718 officers and about 62 scheduled to be sworn in next year. The 2024 budget calls for 850 officers, but the administration has decreased that number in 2025 to 800.
Emergency medical services has 141 paramedics, which is 31 fewer than the budget allocates for.
Previously, Mr. Gainey’s press secretary Olga George has said that the overtime spending will become less urgent for police, fire and EMS as staffing levels “are all increasing as a result of robust recruitment and training pipelines.”
The mayor’s office did not respond to a request for comment Tuesday morning.
During Tuesday morning’s council meeting, Council President Dan Lavelle noted that the city anticipates reductions in the police spending because of restructuring in the department.
Previously it was senior officers working the majority of the overtime. Next year, the bureau anticipates newer officers working the bulk of the overtime. Because they work at a lower pay rate than the senior officers, the bureau is anticipating a reduction in overtime pay, he said.
Ms. Heisler’s letter laid out the best- and worst- case scenarios for next year, as well as what she sees as the most likely outcome.
In the best-case scenario, the city departments implement strict overtime controls and manage to stay in line with the budget allocations.
“Achieving this scenario would require significant structural changes,” the letter said. “Including rapid hiring, training, and optimized scheduling. This may not be feasible with adequate time to see expenditure changes in 2025.”
The worst-case scenario estimated that if the overtime needs of the city increase “due to unforeseen emergencies or staff shortages,” the city could see a shortfall of about $15 to $18 million, the letter said.
“This scenario could undermine public confidence in the city’s fiscal management and create operational disruptions,” the letter said.
What is most likely to happen though, according to Ms. Heisler, is that next year’s overtime expenses are consistent with 2024’s, which would mean the budget allocations are short about $12 to $15 million. This would require “mid-year reallocations and potentially delaying other planned expenditures,” according to the letter.
To stay on top of these potential shortfalls, Ms. Heisler recommended that the city implement monthly tracking to monitor expenditures and make adjustments in a timely manner. She also recommended, among other things, that the city develop a contingency plan by identifying “non-essential expenditures that can be reallocated if necessary.”
Ms. Heisler’s concerns regarding the overtime have been shared by council members, including finance committee chair Erika Strassburger. In a letter she sent to other members in October, she warned that the overtime projections were well below what the city had spent in 2024.
Throughout the year, multiple city officials have raised concerns about the city’s financial health, as federal COVID-19 relief funding expires, revenue projections for things like real estate taxes continue to decline and the fate of the city’s facility usage fee — sometimes called the jock tax — remains in limbo.
Ahead of the final vote to approve the budget later Tuesday, Ms. Heisler in her letter, urged council members to “consider these scenarios carefully” and take steps to ensure the budget “reflects the city’s operational realities.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.