Members of Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration assured city residents Thursday morning that the city’s financial health is in good shape — but revenue projections for the next five years closely align with “worst case scenario” projections done by the city controller this spring.

On Wednesday evening, the mayor’s office released revenue projections for 2025-2029 that show a more than $38.4 million dip in revenues for 2025, followed by a slight rebound in the years to follow.

The newest projections for 2024 show a decrease in nearly $15 million from what the city had projected at the beginning of the year, mostly due to an almost $12 million decrease in deed tax revenue.

In a new “fireside chat” format for a news conference, Mr. Gainey and Jake Pawlak, director of the Office of Management and Budget, lounged in armchairs in front of a bookcase and offered assurances to residents.

Advertise with us

“This forecast gives me a great deal of confidence that the city is in great financial shape and there is no cause for alarm,” Mr. Pawlak said.

“Our fiscal management is strong and solid,” Mr. Gainey said, emphasizing that the mayor’s office wanted to be transparent about the budgetary process.

"We do have some difficult days ahead," he said.

Internal documents from city Controller Rachael Heisler’s office obtained by the Post-Gazette in the spring showed two variations of revenue projections for the next five years: one labeled the “likely scenario,” the other labeled the “worst case scenario.”

In the worst case scenario version for 2025-2027, the mayor’s current projections differ from the controller’s by between $2.7 million and $4.2 million. For 2028, the controller anticipated receiving about $85,000 more than the city’s current totals.

Advertise with us

“While we are still analyzing the initial figures, we are grateful that the Gainey administration heeded our concerns,” Ms. Heisler said in a statement released Thursday afternoon.

“The administration’s figures appear to be responsive to the revenue projections my office made earlier this year and shared with the task force. In fact, their numbers are more conservative than the likely scenario we shared at the first Task Force meeting.”

During the fireside chat, Mr. Pawlak explained that when the city is determining future revenue projections, the goal is to do so “conservatively.”

“It's a very conservative calculation. We try and err on the side of calculating less revenue,” he said.

The projections don’t include the city’s expenditures, which won’t be detailed until the end of September when the first draft of the 2025 budget is due. Ms. Heisler is required to certify the revenue projections in the next 30 days.

Advertise with us

The mayor’s office is also projecting that the city will come in $25 million under budget in terms of spending this year “thanks to … achieving our objectives less expensively than we had originally thought,” he said.

Neither Mr. Gainey nor Mr. Pawlak seemed particularly concerned about the dip in revenues for 2025 or the fact that some revenues for this year are coming in lower than originally expected.

“That’s not a surprise,” Mr. Pawlak said Thursday.

Officials have been predicting the 2025 decrease for a number of years, with the expiration of  COVID-19 relief funding and the increase to scheduled debt service payments. Earlier this year, as more property assessment appeals for large Downtown buildings were filed, many city officials started predicting that property taxes would be lower this year.

“We’ve known this for several years, but as we’ve gotten closer and closer to January 2025, we have more and more data to tell us exactly what the impacts would be,” Mr. Pawlak said.

Advertise with us

As a number of major buildings have won appeals of their assessments, the city has been able to cover the cost of the refunds by moving tax payments in-house — rather than using a third-party system, Mr. Pawlak said.

“The finance department has been better able to collect [back] taxes,” he said.

Previously, any late fees were paid to the third-party system, and the city only received the money it was owed for the taxes themselves. Now the city can collect the taxes and the late interest payments.

Last week, the mayor’s administration released the financial report for the second quarter of 2024 that showed the city will end the year with about a $4 million surplus.

In 2023, the city ended the year with a $31.9 million surplus, Mr. Pawlak said in response to the 2023 finance report that was released in May.

Advertise with us

Following the second quarter financial report, Ms. Heisler noted that her concerns raised earlier this year were not necessarily with 2024, but with the following years when the city will have to grapple with the loss of federal relief funding and increased debt service payments along with a stagnant housing market and decreased property values in Downtown.

Mr. Pawlak also said he’s optimistic about the future of the city’s finances.

Some of the city’s major debts that were taken on years ago are scheduled to be paid in full in 2026, which means there will be less due in interest payments for 2027.

“After that, we’re in great shape,” he said.

Ms. Heisler has been vocal about her concerns for the city’s financial health. In March, she urged City Council and the mayor’s office to reopen the budget to adjust revenue expectations for the year as the property assessments dipped. Also, the city at the time was unable to collect the so-called “jock tax.”

Advertise with us

Now that the lawsuit surrounding the fee collected from out-of-town athletes is being heard by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, the city has resumed collecting it until a ruling is made, Mr. Pawlak said Thursday.

She also warned that the decrease in property taxes could mean the city would make about $5.32 million less in property taxes. The newest projections from the city estimate Pittsburgh will likely see $7 million less in real estate taxes than initially expected.

Mr. Pawlak said during the fireside chat that “some of the concerns that we heard earlier are uninformed” and “based off where people assume the city is because of the past financial challenges.”

“But those days are behind us,” he said.

Mr. Gainey repeatedly stated that his goal was to be transparent with city residents about the budget and the city’s financial health.

Advertise with us

“We’ve never tried to come out and say things that were not true about the budget. I believe that when people start trying to make different conversations and have people living in fear because of the way they see the budget, I don’t think that’s quality management,” he said.

That’s a sentiment Ms. Heisler agreed with.

“We’re going to face real challenges in the coming years, but as long as we’re providing residents with an honest outlook, the City of Pittsburgh will be able to respond with appropriate fiscal discipline,” she said in a statement released Thursday afternoon.

“I look forward to continuing the dialogue about revenue projections and the City’s fiscal health with Mayor Gainey and City Council.”