After an “arduous journey through the Pennsylvania courts,” some Wilkinsburg residents and elected officials are celebrating a recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling that effectively ended the annexation process.
“This worthwhile journey was an impassioned battle to maintain Wilkinsburg independence,” Wilkinsburg Borough Council Vice President Renee Haynes-Johnson said Monday afternoon. Ms. Haynes-Johnson was joined by other council members along with some Pittsburgh and Wilkinsburg residents outside the borough building.
In early 2022, the Wilkinsburg Community Development Corporation began a process to make Wilkinsburg part of the city of Pittsburgh based on a 1903 state law. The law would have allowed Wilkinsburg residents to vote on the annexation, but not Pittsburgh residents.
Pittsburgh City Council voted down the annexation in a 7-2 vote against the measure, though most of the members said they would like to further explore the possibility.
The WCDC attempted again in fall 2022 to restart the process, but a group of Wilkinsburg residents sued to stop the annexation. Attorney Cliff Levine, who represented the WCDC, argued that the 1903 law was still valid because repealed sections weren’t released according to proper procedure. A Common Pleas judge ruled that the 1903 law had been repealed in the 1960s. That ruling was upheld last July by the Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court.
The WCDC appealed the decision to the state Supreme Court last August, and last week the superior court denied the appeal.
Read More
“The final nail in the coffin of annexation has been placed,” Ms. Haynes-Johnson said.
If the community group wants to continue to pursue annexation, it would essentially have to start from scratch. It would have to get residents from both sides to sign petitions and the question of annexation would appear as a ballot referendum in both neighborhoods.
Representatives from the WCDC could not be reached for comment.
Those in favor of annexation previously argued that it would benefit people on both sides. Property owners in Wilkinsburg could have seen lower property taxes and Pittsburgh would have benefitted from the boost in population.
However, opponents argued that it would increase the burden on the already overtaxed city services and that the people of Wilkinsburg would be forgotten.
“We did not believe that Wilkinsburg would have been given a fair shake if it became part of Pittsburgh,” Ms. Haynes-Johnson said. “Pittsburgh has communities that it’s not able to handle right now. Our taxes, our properties are different things that would have been great assets for Pittsburgh, but it would have been a dishonor to the residents to become part of that.”
At a news conference Monday afternoon, Ms. Haynes-Johnson touted some of the new developments coming to Wilkinsburg, like an Aldi grocery store expected to open next year and a nearly completed four-story affordable housing development.
There are also plans to create eight to 10 mixed-income townhomes that will be for sale, she said.
“We believe that Wilkinsburg deserves its independence, to be given the opportunity to make its own decisions to rebuild itself,” Ms. Haynes-Johnson said.
Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.