Ed Gainey had a tough time getting things rolling for much of his first two years as Pittsburgh’s mayor.

Steps to shore up a shortage of police officers were slow in coming, and no appointments were made to an infrastructure committee for 16 months after the Fern Hollow Bridge collapsed in early 2022. Despite campaign promises to make the city safer, violent crime rose.

But now, as the mayor enters his third year, there are signs that progress is being made. A police recruit class is in training; federal, state and local money is being directed to bridge repairs; crime has started to come down.

Mr. Gainey took office in 2022, after being elected Pittsburgh’s first Black mayor.

Advertise with us

“He’s always been very passionate about wanting to do well, whether it be for the constituents of his legislative district, and now for the City of Pittsburgh,” said state Sen. Jay Costa, a Democrat from Forest Hills whose district includes part of the city and who worked with Mr. Gainey when the mayor was a state representative. “He’s putting forth a very good, passionate and thoughtful [administration].”

That passion is on display when Mr. Gainey gets a chance to speak directly to his constituents, who – at times – are also his neighbors.

Just months into his administration Mr. Gainey, shovel in hand, took to the streets of Homewood to help plant trees as part of a community cleanup. He urged the volunteers to connect with the youth of the community in an effort to steer them away from crime.

“I don’t want to wake up to our kids dying in these streets,” Mr. Gainey said at the time. “It hurts.”

“He obviously has a personality and orientation toward people,” said Tim Stevens, president and CEO of the Black Political Empowerment Project. “If you watch him, he really interacts with people in a very personal way. He makes people feel like they’re important.”

Advertise with us
Mayor Ed Gainey makes remarks during Sara Innamorato’s County Executive swearing-in ceremony at Byham Theater on Tuesday, Jan. 2, 2024, in Downtown. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Safest city

The mayor has often repeated that he wants to make Pittsburgh the “safest city in America.” The idea behind the message may be more important than meeting that statistical goal; residents “knew that wasn’t going to happen,” Mr. Stevens said, but it gives people something to strive for.

“In his statements about the end of violence and ending death in our Black neighborhoods, he is trying to speak a vision of a future that may never happen … but for people to hopefully buy into and support in their own ways,” Mr. Stevens said.

In Mr. Gainey’s first year in office, Pittsburgh was in the midst of one of its deadliest years. Between 2007 and 2021, Pittsburgh averaged about 53 homicides a year. In 2022 there were 71 – a 39% increase from 2021 – at a time when the police force was shrinking at a concerning rate.

Though the city budgets for 900 officers, there were just 817 on duty at the end of this past November. When Mr. Gainey took office, there had been 912 officers.

Advertise with us

During the early years of the pandemic, the city put a hold on police recruit classes. Pittsburgh, like other cities nationwide, also had difficulty find candidates in the aftermath of the death of George Floyd and the protests that followed.

At the same time, Pittsburgh continued to lose officers to retirement and to suburban departments, even after Mr. Gainey’s administration reached a contract agreement with the police union last year that included a sizable pay raise.

Efforts to bring in hire more officers should have been a priority, said Beth Pittinger, executive director of the Citizens Police Review Board.

“When [the Gainey administration] came in, they were probably just trying to figure it out,” and establish their “own administrative priorities,” Ms. Pittinger said. But in that process, she said, it seemed that some public safety components – such as ensuring there were enough officers on the streets – fell by the wayside.

Despite an announcement in September 2022 that a new police recruit class soon would begin, followed by another in spring 2023, no classes were held until July 2023. The city hadn’t had a recruit class since January 2021, when 32 recruits graduated.

Advertise with us

“I think they should have recognized, and the public safety leadership should have recognized, and really pursued a recruitment class [earlier],” Ms. Pittinger said.

What has helped to attract more recruits in recent months, Ms. Pititinger said, was the new union contract. New officers now receive base pay of $65,000, about a 9% increase from the previous contract. Fraternal Order of Police President Rob Swartzwelder, however, has expressed doubt it will do anything to stem the tide of officers leaving.

“Pittsburgh is just a farm club right now,” Mr. Swartzwelder said in May, when the contract was approved. “You come here, you get good experience, and then you go somewhere else where you can make more.”

In the midst of the recruitment crisis, Mr. Gainey also was dealing with a major gap in public safety leadership. Six months into the mayor’s term, longtime Police Chief Scott Schubert announced his retirement. It took a year to find his replacement.

But in this case, Mr. Gainey had the luxury of time, Ms. Pittinger said. Deputy Chief Tom Stangrecki stepped in as acting chief, and, “In that sense, the operational side of it was consistent,” she said.

Advertise with us

The secrecy and the lengthy process by which new Chief Larry Scirotto was named “left a bad taste in a lot of people’s mouths,” Ms. Pittinger said, despite the “fine job” that the new chief has been doing since being sworn in. She said Mr. Scirotto understands what modern policing should look like and has successfully brought in contemporary practices including increased community engagement by officers.

During Mr. Gainey’s second year in office, the city experienced a decrease in homicides for the first time since the pandemic. But killings were not the only issue city residents were paying attention to. They were talking about panhandling and disorderly youth, problems that don’t always show up in crime statistics.

“When he first took office, Downtown was a mess,” said John Valentine, of the Downtown Neighbors Alliance. At the end of 2022, business owners voiced frustration about violence and open drug dealing in the city center.

At the time, Mr. Valentine said, he had suggested the mayor gather stakeholders to discuss the difference in the perception of Downtown being dangerous against the reality and how to bring the two sides closer together.

He said the mayor was “getting crushed public relations-wise” about Downtown and that he “needed to do something quickly.”

Advertise with us

The mayor didn’t see it that way. Mr. Valentine said Mr. Gainey told him the perception would change if he did his job right. “If I don’t produce results, then I deserve whatever I get,” Mr. Gainey told Mr. Valentine.

“I remember sitting in that meeting and I said to myself, 'This is a breath of fresh air,’” he said. “Two years later, I can honestly say he’s really made the improvements that his plan [promised].”

In December 2022, Heath Johnson, who manages the police bureau’s crime analysis unit, said crime Downtown had returned to pre-pandemic levels, which in 2019 were at a 10-year low.

Last year Mr. Gainey promised to triple the number of officers patrolling Downtown. With the help of groups such as the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership and the Allegheny Conference on Community Development, public restrooms were installed in the city center and staff was added to clean the streets and sidewalks.

Another team was formed to interact with city visitors. The Downtown Ambassadors, employees of the PDP, work from 7 a.m. to 11 p.m. every day as friendly faces while also looking out for problems.

Advertise with us

Mr. Valentine said he started to see a shift last summer. After some high-profile business exits from the city center, by the end of the year 38 businesses had either opened or were in the process of opening Downtown, he said.

“Now do we have more work? I don’t think anybody, including the mayor, would tell you that there’s not more work to do,” Mr. Valentine said. “But if you look at where we are now compared to where we were when he came into office, the improvement is tremendous.”

Mayor Ed Gainey speaks at an event unveiling artwork on the Fern Hollow bridge on Friday, Nov. 3, 2023, in Squirrel Hill. (Benjamin B. Braun / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

City of Bridges

Aside from public safety, another issue that likely will be part of Mr. Gainey’s legacy is the aftermath of the Fern Hollow Bridge collapse in the East End just weeks after he was sworn in.

The collapse on a snowy Friday morning in late January 2022 injured several people and set off a string of events the mayor is still dealing with.

Advertise with us

An emergency disaster declaration allowed Mr. Gainey to get access to state and federal funding to help build a replacement in less than a year. But it also prompted a $1.5 million analysis of all city-owned bridges that found 32 of them were in poor condition. A poor rating doesn't necessarily mean the bridge is dangerous, but that there is significant deterioration on a structural component.

But for a year after the collapse, little to no work was done on any of the poorly rated bridges, a Post-Gazette investigation found.

A Commission on Infrastructure Asset Reporting and Investment created in the days after the collapse to pinpoint short- and long-term problems didn’t get its first members until July 2023.

Mr. Gainey’s 2024 budget shows a renewed motivation to improve bridges. The Bridge Preservation and Restoration Fund is slated to receive about $1.2 million. And the Charles Anderson Bridge in Oakland, which was closed in early 2023, will get $27 million for rehabilitation and restoration, most of which comes from state funding sources.

“It’s never enough, but it’s a beginning,” Mr. Gainey said in a December appearance on the City Cast podcast. “We’re going to invest in the [bridges] that need to be invested in right now in order to ensure that we’re developing a city where our bridges are safe …”

Advertise with us

In February 2022, he made good on one of his campaign promises by nixing the Mon-Oakland Connector project, a shuttle connection that would have run from Oakland through Schenley Park to Four Mile Run. Residents of the affected neighborhoods strongly opposed the project and celebrated its cancellation.

The University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University, though, supported the project. Some have raised concerns that Mr. Gainey seems to focus on the interests of small pockets of the city, rather than the nearly 303,000 residents as a whole.

“I think that he needs to focus more on the general community,” said University of Pittsburgh professor of political communications Jerry Shuster. “He meets with his constituents in limited groups. They’re very neighborhood-oriented. I think he’s too concerned about following the focus of [smaller groups] than trying to look at the overall community.”

Mr. Gainey, the city’s first Black mayor, was part of a progressive movement in Western Pennsylvania that sent Summer Lee to Washington, D.C., as a member of the U.S. House and elected Sara Innamorato as the new county executive. Mr. Shuster said he is concerned that movement is too nearsighted for the city.

“I think [Mr. Gainey] looks at the progressive movement, and he considers that almost a biblical orientation as to how he should plan his programs,” Mr. Shuster said. “But it’s not working for the overall community.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Stevens is more optimistic.

“He’s still new to the position, relatively speaking, and I think he has a huge commitment to be successful,” Mr. Stevens said. “Hopefully, people will give him the room and the space and time to be that.”

The mayor’s office did not respond to multiple requests for comment for this story.

During his budget address in November, Mr. Gainey said he was proud of what his administration had accomplished.

“I would put this record up against any administration,” he said.

Advertise with us

The next two years

But challenges still loom.

All $335 million of the city’s federal COVID-19 relief funding must be under contract by the end of this year and spent entirely by the end of 2026. Mr. Gainey’s administration seems confident that those deadlines will be met, but there are other budgetary concerns coming.

That  money soon won’t be available to prop up the city’s savings account, and with fixed debt-service payments scheduled to increase in 2025, there could be lean years ahead.

“I know that nobody wants to hear this, but over the next few years we’re going to have to take a hard look at raising taxes to get more revenue in,” city council’s budget director, Pete McDevitt, said in November. “Running a city is expensive, and we need to make sure we have enough money to pay for [it].”

Advertise with us

Members of Mr. Gainey’s administration have said they are prepared to deal with any upcoming budgetary shortfalls.

With two years left in his term, the mayor has time to prove those projections are on target.

“I think he’s making every effort to be successful,” Mr. Costa said. “Given the opportunity to give him time, he will be very successful as mayor of Pittsburgh.”

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com