Stephen A. Zappala Jr. was sworn in as Allegheny County district attorney for a seventh time on Thursday in a ceremony attended by Democrats but also by many Republicans — a representation of the coalition of voters the Democrat needed to hang onto his job as the county’s top prosecutor for four more years.

Former Republican Gov. Tom Corbett, Pennsylvania Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland, and At-Large County Councilman Sam DeMarco, chair of the county’s Republican committee, joined several judges and high-ranking officials at the event, held in the Supreme Court chambers of the City-County Building in Downtown Pittsburgh.

The gathering followed Mr. Zappala’s toughest re-election effort in his tenure. Last year, Matt Dugan, former chief public defender in the county, defeated Mr. Zappala in the Democratic primary in the spring by more than 10 percentage points.

But local Republicans, led by Mr. DeMarco and Mr. Corbett, launched a primary write-in campaign, and more than 9,000 county Republicans wrote in Mr. Zappala, helping him qualify for the November election. After a contentious campaign that mirrored recent races for district attorney offices in Philadelphia and across the country, Mr. Zappala won the rematch as a Republican candidate against Mr. Dugan by just under three percentage points.

Advertise with us

After being sworn in Thursday, Mr. Zappala, 66, noted that when he first got into office in 1997, he envisioned widening the scope of what the top prosecutor does — a mission he continues today.

“I wanted to transform the district attorney’s office from an office that simply processes cases to an institution that advocates [for] positive growth,” Mr. Zappala said.

Ms. Ward and Mr. Corbett rattled off a list of Mr. Zappala’s achievements before he was sworn in — the creation of diversionary courts (drug court, DUI court, and others), encouraging local police forces to use body-worn cameras and dash cameras in their patrol cars, installing thousands of cameras at high-activity intersections to help with criminal investigations, and using license plate reading technology to assist in high-speed pursuits.

But the longtime Democrat also faces several challenges. In his speech, he referenced a Monroeville police sergeant who had been shot Wednesday night, saying that violence in Pittsburgh and throughout the county is still of concern.

He also has been at odds with Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey’s administration, investigating a contract for a police staffing study where city officials waived a competitive bid process. And he’s said he’ll sue the city in federal court to take control of the city’s police department if criminal activity remains a concern.

Advertise with us

During last year’s campaign, many Democrats opposed Mr. Zappala, saying that there have been drastic racial disparities in the criminal justice system under his leadership.

Mr. Zappala has denied any racial disparities in prosecutions within his office, and said his office has always tried cases thoroughly.

That topic is likely to continue to be under debate. A study released by former Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and the University of Pittsburgh’s Institute of Politics in December showed that Black individuals were five times more likely to have criminal charges filed against them than white individuals in a period from 2017 to 2019.

Community activists have criticized Mr. Zappala for his handling of police shootings during his tenure, including the fatal shooting in 2018 of Antwon Rose II, an unarmed Black 17-year-old who was shot by an East Pittsburgh police officer. The officer was acquitted of multiple murder charges and a manslaughter charge.

Mr. Zappala’s new term starts as County Executive Sara Innamorato, a Democrat, begins her tenure — the latter of whom political observers view as more progressive than the longtime district attorney.

Advertise with us

The two were scheduled to meet last week, but Mr. Zappala said he was sick with a cough. Mr. Zappala thinks there are areas of agreement on how the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center should be handled, along with the potential for decentralization of some county services with regards to public safety.

Shuman was closed in September 2021 due to issues with state licensing. County officials and court leadership announced in September that they would be reopening the facility with 12 beds in 2024, with more beds added as renovations were completed. The county and courts have entered a contract with Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based social services provider, to run the facility.

Many County Councilmembers objected to the contract, and voted to sue Mr. Fitzgerald’s administration and court officials last year. A majority of members argued that because they were not included in a decision about the contract, provisions of the county charter were violated.

Mr. Zappala said he wants to work with Ms. Innamorato on public safety matters.

“I think she has an agenda that is decent, from my perspective, and the criminal justice perspective,” Mr. Zappala said of Ms. Innamorato to reporters after the ceremony. “I think we’re gonna be able to do a lot of things.”

Advertise with us

As that relationship takes shape, Mr. Zappala also finds himself in a position where he’ll need to appeal to not just Democrats, but to the Republicans and independent voters who helped keep him in office last year, said Mr. Corbett.

During his speech, the former governor said he expects to see Mr. Zappala at the Lincoln Day Dinner later this year, an annual gathering of prominent Republicans and headlining GOP candidates for state offices, U.S. Senate and other national races.

After the ceremony, Mr. Corbett credited Mr. DeMarco for the idea of having Mr. Zappala run as a write-in candidate, but admitted he was surprised at the number of Republicans who wrote in the longtime district attorney’s name in the primary election.

Mr. Corbett wrote to the county’s Republican Party urging them to do so — and he said his influence and reputation in this county likely helped Mr. Zappala.

The former governor still believes that there are a lot of Democrats and Republicans in Allegheny County who are “middle of the road” voters, especially on criminal justice issues.

“I’m all for opening all the primaries [elections] to independents to vote, because so many people have left the extremes … and gone to the middle, including some family members that I know,” he said. “And I understand that.”