A judge ruled this week that legislation raising the minimum wage for Allegheny County employees is “legally invalid,” a victory for outgoing Executive Rich Fitzgerald in his fight with lawmakers over the bill.

County Council passed legislation in June setting the minimum wage for county government workers at $18 per hour in 2024, $19 in 2025, and $20 in 2026. In challenging the measure that same month, Mr. Fitzgerald argued that it violated the county charter, as well as the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches. His administration also said it violated collective bargaining agreements with unionized county employees.

Common Pleas Court Judge Daniel D. Regan sided with Mr. Fitzgerald. In his ruling dated Tuesday, Judge Regan said Council acted outside its purview under both the county charter and Pennsylvania labor law when it passed the bill.

“Budgetary authority does not encompass wage-setting authority, which rests with the Executive Branch,” Judge wrote. “Furthermore, passing the Wage Ordinance was not County Council exercising its budgetary authority.”

Advertise with us

It remains to be seen if Council will appeal the ruling. Council President Pat Catena declined to comment Wednesday.

In a statement  from his office late Wednesday afternoon, Mr. Fitzgerald said:

“We thank the judge for today’s decision that settles the question about authority within the county’s Home Rule Charter. As I noted when we filed, this is an important legal question that would have a lasting impact upon future executives and councils. We’re glad to have the question resolved and to make it clear that the will of the voters can’t be circumvented by ordinance when the Home Rule Charter addresses an issue like this one.”

Judge Regan also cited provisions within the county code that give the county manager and county executive the power to set wages. And he ruled that the bill violated the state’s Public Employee Relations Act (PERA), a labor law.

The wage ordinance “was passed without negotiation with the County’s PERA bargaining units,” Judge Regan wrote in his ruling. Lawmakers had argued that they were simply setting a “floor” from which unions could bargain. But Judge Regan wrote that the “Legislative Branch’s setting of ‘floors’ for wages in their Ordinance is setting the wage nonetheless.”

Advertise with us

Councilwoman Bethany Hallam had led efforts on the legislation, which passed in a 10-4 vote in June. Mr. Fitzgerald then vetoed the bill, drawing criticism from both Ms. Hallam and Mr. Catena. The Council president said Mr. Fitzgerald had “flip-flopped” on the issue, citing a 2001 vote by Mr. Fitzgerald, when he was on Council, to establish a minimum wage for county workers.

Lawmakers overrode the veto in a 10-5 vote, just meeting the two-thirds majority needed to do so, per the county charter. Mr. Fitzgerald took the matter to court in late June.

It’s one of multiple recent disputes between lawmakers and Mr. Fitzgerald, a term-limited Democrat leaving office after this month. Council voted to file suit against his administration and local court officials in September over a contract for an outside nonprofit to operate the Shuman Juvenile Detention Center.