Allegheny County Council on Tuesday overrode County Executive Rich Fitzgerald’s veto of a bill increasing the minimum wage for county employees.

The vote was 10-5 in overriding the veto.

Mr. Fitzgerald vetoed the legislation last week, and has said it violates the county charter. He believes the council does not have the authority to enact such a change and he has also argued it would cost the county tens of millions of dollars, resulting in a likely property tax increase for residents.

But At-large Council Member Bethany Hallam, Council President Patrick Catena, and eight others disagreed with Mr. Fitzgerald, arguing that the increased wages are needed to recognize the work of county employees as the cost of living rises.

Advertise with us

The bill will increase the minimum wage for all county employees to $18 an hour in 2024, $19 in 2025 and $20 in 2026.

Ms. Hallam and Mr. Catena, along with Council Members Olivia Bennett, Jack Betkowski, Tom Duerr, Paul Klein, Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis, John Palmiere, Robert Palmosina, and Anita Prizio voted to override. Council members Sam DeMarco, Suzanne Filiaggi, Nicholas Futules, Bob Macey and DeWitt Walton voted against the override.

Broadly speaking, those who supported the override said that the pay increases were needed to order to pay all county workers a salary that was closer to a living wage in Allegheny County. Opponents said that part-time and seasonal workers should not be paid as much as full-time workers with more skills. They added that the bill might not survive legal challenges, and that finding the money — Mr. Fitzgerald said it could cost around $30 million — would need to come from somewhere in the county budget.

Ms. Hallam, the bill’s lead sponsor, said that even after the hourly wage increases to $20 an hour by 2026 —  $41,600 annually — still not a living wage for a single parent with one child, according to multiple cost-of-living calculators.

“We are talking about people who have worked at the county for decades and still aren't making $41,600 per year. That is a shame. And I will never support anything or anyone who advocates against paying somebody a wage that they can survive off of,” Ms. Hallam said.

Advertise with us

Multiple council members gave lengthy statements explaining their position. One of them was Ms. Filiaggi, who missed the initial vote for personal reasons. She said that the process for debating the legislation was rushed, and that she was concerned it wouldn’t survive a lawsuit.

“I'm fairly certain that one or more of these provisions will not pass muster with the courts, and we will be spending more taxpayer dollars defending the inevitable lawsuits, despite the sponsors’ assertion that it's unclear who would bear the financial burden,” Mr. Filiaggi said.

Mr. Macey said an increase in wages would usher in additional costs, like benefits for full-time employees.

“There's an additional cost and going back to just business 101, if you need money to pay this, where do you get it from? You raise your product, or you lay off people ... or we could just go after the taxpayers and go OK, they’ll pay, so what?” Mr. Macey said.

Council President Catena, however, said that overriding the bill acknowledges the “reality” that the cost of living is getting higher for working families. He mentioned the Living Wage Calculator from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, which states that a single parent raising one child in Pittsburgh needs to make $33.49 hourly to make a living wage.

Advertise with us

Mr. Catena said that county employees — the ones who answer the calls from county residents and respond to concerns — deserve the increase.

“Our residents, our taxpayers, our visitors, and our voters may have opinions about those of us who are up here as individuals,” Mr. Catena said of county council members. “But their opinions of county government overall are far more often a result of their interactions with county employees than they have with us.”

The veto was at least the fourth for Mr. Fitzgerald since he took office in January 2012. His first veto was in February 2014 for legislation that would have given tax breaks to residents who purchase newly constructed homes, or make home improvements. The county executive said at the time that if county officials gave that group of residents a tax break, “then everyone has to pay for it.”

That veto stood. Mr. Fitzgerald then vetoed a bill in March 2021 that would have required many employers in the county to provide one hour of sick time for every 35 hours an employee works, and it would be capped at 40 hours per year — unless the employer agrees to more. Mr. Fitzgerald agreed with the intent, but said the regulation should be implemented by the county’s Department of Health, not the council. Otherwise, it could be legally challenged, he said.

The bill was passed by council in a 10-4 vote. Shortly after, the override vote was 9-5-1, one vote shy of the two-thirds required by the county charter to override a county executive veto. Mr. Fitzgerald worked with council members to tweak the bill, which then passed in September 2021.

In July 2022, the County Council passed a bill that banned fracking in county parks. Mr. Fitzgerald vetoed that bill, which was followed by a successful 12-3 override vote later that month.