The fight over raising the minimum wage for Allegheny County employees has been presented as a legal, political and most of all personal dispute between County Executive Rich Fitzgerald and County Council.

But that’s a smokescreen. Council’s attempt to set executive branch wages isn’t a dispute with Mr. Fitzgerald, but an attempt to reshape the balance of power in county government. If successful, council will break the bounds set by the Home Rule Charter, leaving itself much stronger — and the county executive much weaker — than before, for as long as the charter remains in its current form.

That means the person with the most at stake in Mr. Fitzgerald’s lawsuit challenging council’s ordinance isn’t the lame duck plaintiff, but his likely successor: Sara Innamorato.

House rules

Advertise with us

The Home Rule Charter is, in effect, the constitution of Allegheny County. It lays out the organization of county government, and is the last word on matters internal to that government. Along with technological Armageddon, its coming into force was one of the most anticipated events of January 1, 2000.

On that day, the charter replaced the state’s Second Class County Code as the fundamental law of county government. It streamlined a system of three commissioners and numerous row offices into a single county executive, four other elected offices (district attorney, controller, treasurer and sheriff), a professional manager and a 15-member council.

There’s no question that, in design and in practice, Allegheny County has a “strong executive” form of government. Nearly all authority over the county’s more than 6,000 employees rests in the 101 suite in the courthouse: The executive is to “control and be accountable for the administration of all departments and agencies,” except those placed under other officials, such as the controller and treasurer.

For the first several years of County Council’s existence, being elected to that body was mostly about pursuing pet projects and establishing political bona fides to run for higher office. Most councilors washed out of the system, but others became established in local politics, such as state Sen. Wayne Fontana, D-Brookline, and Mr. Fitzgerald himself.

That’s changed in recent years, with a new class of progressive councilors, led at least publicly by at-large member Bethany Hallam, who have sought to unlock what they believe to be the latent power of the county’s legislature.

Advertise with us

Breaking free

Until now, council has tested its boundaries by exercising powers clearly granted to it, such as rejecting the chief executive’s appointees to county boards, that had laid dormant. But the minimum wage play is something different entirely.

A supermajority of council believes it has the power to set executive branch wages by way of the “administrative code,” which mostly establishes a set of procedures, as opposed to policies, for running county government. If that’s so, then the county executive’s control over his (or her) own bureaucracy is pierced, and the language in the charter establishing that power would be essentially moot.

Allegheny County’s home rule government is young in juridical terms, and so it’s unsurprising that ambiguities are still being worked out. For instance, it took 16 years after ratification for Marbury v. Madison to settle (more or less) the question of final authority in constitutional interpretation in favor of the judiciary. Americans now take that for granted in the same way that, decades from now, county residents may take for granted the resolution of this case, which could massively shift the balance of power between the executive and the legislature.

Despite the vituperation aimed at Mr. Fitzgerald by some members of council, his lawsuit defending the rights and authority of the executive is essential to establish the limitations — if any — of the administrative code. It will also define the relative authority of the executive and the council for the foreseeable future.

Advertise with us

Which is why the person who should be most interested in the case’s outcome is the person most likely to be the next Allegheny County Executive.

Looking ahead

If the courts ultimately side with County Council, Sara Innamorato would inherit a much weaker office than the one she initially sought. If council can use the administrative code to micromanage the bureaucracy, the chief executive becomes the chief negotiator, who must hash out many of the details of the job with 15 legislators.

The conventional wisdom around town is that a County Council run (in practice) by Bethany Hallam would work hand-in-glove with an executive’s office run by her close friend Sara Innamorato. It’s notable, however, that council launched its minimum wage stratagem in June, after the primary elections had concluded. If it were just about honorable wages for county employees, council could have seen the results and waited until a more compliant executive took office.

But instead, the progressive majority moved to kneecap the executive, knowing full well that one of their own was likely to ascend to that office.

Advertise with us

It’s a stark reminder that, even among ideological comrades, power is the first rule of politics. Being a member of the winning team is great, but there’s no substitute for being in charge.

Within the local progressive movement, as within any ascendant political coalition, there are disagreements about priorities. For instance, while Ms. Hallam has emphasized the conditions at the county jail, Ms. Innamorato’s chief accomplishments are in housing policy. Other elected officials and activists, not to mention well-heeled advocacy groups, have their own views about which issues are most important. The human limitations of time and energy and focus ensure that only so much can be done at once, and that some reforms will never get done at all.

The minimum wage fight may look like another episode in the war between County Council and Rich Fitzgerald, but it’s much more interesting than that: It’s jockeying for power and priority in a movement that sees total control of government on the horizon. And the only remaining enemy is itself.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.