Allegheny County Council on Tuesday approved an increase in the minimum wage for county employees, beginning in 2024 — but county Executive Rich Fitzgerald has threatened to veto the proposal.

Council members voted 10-4 to increase the minimum wage for county employees to $18 an hour in 2024, $19 in 2025 and $20 in 2026. Sam DeMarco, Nicholas Futules, Bob Macey and DeWitt Walton voted against the proposal. Council member Suzanne Filiaggi was absent.

Bethany Hallam, lead sponsor of the proposal, said before Tuesday’s vote that the increase was long overdue. She also disagreed with Mr. Fitzgerald’s assessment that the bill would cost Allegheny County taxpayers $30 million and that County Council didn’t have legal authority to enact such a change. Mr. Fitzgerald’s office could not immediately be reached for comment Tuesday evening.

The legislation had been before the council for just under a year, Ms. Hallam said.

Advertise with us

Tom Duerr, another supporter, said the increase recognizes that the county is valuing its workers for how they serve the public. He compared it to what he does in his day job: working on campaigns throughout southwestern Pennsylvania.

“I've seen firsthand in this industry, what happens when you overwork and underpay employees,” Mr. Duerr said. “We will hemorrhage talent in this region.”

Paul Klein said enacting the law would be a small step forward in supporting county workers. He referenced a book published in 2001 by Barbara Ehrenreich, titled “Nickeled and Dimed.” The book described how many Americans were working full-time jobs and another part-time job, and were still struggling to pay bills.

Ms. Ehrenreich wrote that these individuals are often referred to as the “middle class,” Mr. Klein said. But a more accurate classification would be the “working poor,” Mr. Klein recalled in his take from the book.

“There's this expectation that when you serve the public, you at the same time decide to take a vow of poverty,” Mr. Klein said.

Advertise with us

Not everyone agreed. Mr. DeMarco said he agreed with Mr. Fitzgerald’s concerns that the bill would lead to a tax increase for county residents, and that it was outside the legal authority of the council. He noted that county employees receive good health care benefits and also receive a pension — both of which are not guaranteed in the private sector.

In the aftermath of the pandemic, with a uncertain financial picture looming, the proposal didn’t make financial or legal sense to pass, Mr. DeMarco said. County employees can develop the skill sets to allow them to gain employment through higher-paying jobs, he said.

“We can't just wave a wand and say, ‘Hey, we're going to give you this, but we have to take it away from someone else.’ And that's what separates us from the private sector,” Mr. DeMarco said.

In some of the closing remarks before the vote, Council President Patrick Catena called out Mr. Fitzgerald, who used to serve as council president. Mr. Catena noted the former council president supported a bill in 2001 that included a provision with increases for county employees.

“It is my sincerest hope tonight that the chief executive sincerely remembers the day he sat in this very chair and supported living wages and realizes the importance of paying our own employees competitive and fair wages,” Mr. Catena said.

Mr. Fitzgerald has seven days to veto the bill. The council can override his veto with a two-thirds majority, or 10 out of 15 members, within 30 days.