As he approached the lectern in the Gold Room of the Allegheny County Courthouse, Raymond — a frequent guest of the Smithfield shelter — echoed a sentiment shared by many people in County Council chambers.
Other Smithfield guests had already criticized the county’s decision to close the shelter, with its last day of operations being June 20. Raymond, however, spoke with a directness of why so many people appreciate the atmosphere and staff at Smithfield — and don’t want to move to other shelters in the city.
That included Second Avenue Commons, which hasn’t been accommodating with trying to get him services, and isn’t as well-run, he said.
“You need to keep [Smithfield] open, the other one [Second Avenue Commons] is running off the chain … it’s turmoil up in there,” Raymond said during a County Council public hearing Thursday.
County Council President Pat Catena read a lengthy statement before the meeting, stating that the decision to close Smithfield has already been made, and that County Council didn’t have the authority to reverse it.
Still, those who use the shelter, along with numerous advocates, have been vocally opposed to its closure, criticizing county officials and county Executive Rich Fitzgerald, for weeks. That continued Thursday.
Chase Archer Evans, a member of the county’s Homeless Advisory Board, criticized the county’s Department of Human Services.
“Homelessness is life and death every day … people seem to forget that people go hungry while DHS buys doughnuts for all of their meetings … the way that Smithfield handled is no different than the way homelessness has been dealt with for years,” Mr. Evans said.
Earlier this year, the county’s Department of Human Services had announced that the shelter — which typically doesn’t remain open past the winter months — would stay in service through the summer. But in May, DHS officials announced that the shelter would close in June, and they recently announced its final day would be open through June 20.
In a fact sheet posted to its website, DHS officials wrote that Smithfield shelter “was never designed as a year-round shelter or long-term living space.” Of the roughly 125 people who use the shelter regularly, DHS officials have found alternative shelter plans for over 30 of them, they said.
But advocates and community organizers said Thursday that county officials have not done enough to provide support for those that regularly use the shelter.
Aubrey Plesh, director of the shelter, said there are no concrete plans for all of the 125 people who have been identified by the county, or the 600 unique people who used the shelter in May.
Ms. Plesh then declared: “I believe the direction for the closure of this shelter came from [county Executive Rich] Fitzgerald.” County officials have maintained that the Department of Human Services took the lead in the decision.
Earlier in the meeting, Allegheny County Manager Jennifer Liptak, Andy Halfill, administrator of homeless services for the county’s Department of Human Services, and Erin Dalton, director of the department, fielded questions from council members.
At-large County Council member Bethany Hallam said that with the closure of the shelter, homeless people will sleep in over and underpasses, in tents in parks, and other places in Downtown, which elicited applause from those in the Gold Room. She pressed Ms. Liptak and others multiple times about why the “arbitrary” date of June 20 was picked.
Ms. Liptak said that DHS officials have made the decision to shift those in Smithfield to other shelters in order to provide them with better wraparound services and a better atmosphere. When Ms. Hallam pressed again, Ms. Liptak said: “I’m trying to be respectful, but I’m not going to get into a back-and-forth” about the shelter.
Some were supportive of the closure, including Jerad Bechar, president and CEO of VisitPittsburgh, and Jeremy Waldrup, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. Mr. Bechar emphasized it’s not about just the closure of Smithfield, but about all of Downtown.
“There is a strong uptick [with] aggressive panhandling, disturbances, violence, [and] concerns about safety and security among the Downtown [area],” Mr. Bechar said.
But many who spoke at the public hearing said that homelessness is a public policy issue, not one of character.
Lisa Frank, chief operating and administrative officer for Pittsburgh, said the problem is solvable with the city’s resources.
“We’re not San Francisco … the size of the problem is not so immense relative to our resources,” Ms. Frank said. “We’re a rich society, and some of it is about our priorities.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.