Allegheny County Council on Tuesday rejected an effort to formally rebuke Democratic Councilwoman Bethany Hallam for a remark she made this month during a Jail Oversight Board meeting.
The motion, introduced by Republican Councilman Sam DeMarco, failed in a 10-3 vote, with council members Tom Duerr and DeWitt Walton abstaining.
The vote came after almost 30 minutes of discussion about Ms. Hallam’s actions during a Jan. 5 Jail Oversight Board meeting. During that meeting, an exchange took place between Ms. Hallam and Court of Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie, a fellow oversight board member and frequent adversary.
After their exchange, Ms. Hallam called the judge a name under her breath.
“Pardon me,” Judge Howsie said. “Did you just call me a prick?”
Ms. Hallam replied, “I think that’s the nicest word I could say the way you talk to me.”
Read More
The exchange followed Ms. Hallam’s questions regarding why the board wasn’t told about an ongoing investigation into an Allegheny County Jail corrections officer. The officer was ultimately charged for allegedly bringing contraband into the jail.
The spat led Mr. DeMarco, who also chairs the county GOP, to sponsor the censure motion against Ms. Hallam, a progressive firebrand first elected to council in 2019. Mr. DeMarco said Tuesday that Ms. Hallam’s actions were “detrimental” to county council.
“We all have our First Amendment rights; however in this particular case I just think that behavior is beneath the dignity of someone on county council,” Mr. DeMarco said. “I don’t understand why it persists.”
Ms. Hallam, who has pledged not to speak with the Post-Gazette during an ongoing strike by some PG employees and a pressure campaign not to engage with the newspaper, declined to comment.
Councilman Bob Macey, who co-sponsored the motion, said there’s a clear difference between someone using vulgar or profane language in a heated situation, as opposed to verbally attacking somebody.
“It has to stop somewhere,” Mr. Macey said. “We do have our rights, our freedom of speech, but my goodness we also should act like professionals. … People are looking at us because of our actions in professional surroundings and public meetings as a joke because we’re not using respect and decorum and council rules.”
Mr. DeMarco and Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi, both Republicans, voted in favor of the motion. Mr. Macey, a Democrat, also supported it.
Ms. Filiaggi said she was “not happy” with Ms. Hallam’s behavior because she was acting as a representative of the entire county council. Ms. Filiaggi said she wants to take a broader look at council members’ behavior, because of “attitudes that don’t belong in a public office.”
Councilman Nicholas Futules was an original co-sponsor on the motion but withdrew his name after deciding county council shouldn’t pursue it because the incident didn’t take place during a council meeting.
“It was a poor choice of words but her convictions and her steadiness to save the people in the jail, I applaud that,” Mr. Futurles said. “So yes, I think you did a good thing but your use of words should be reversed and apologize to the judge.”
Others pointed out that council members in the past have cursed and not faced disciplinary measures. Councilwoman Olivia Bennett questioned why members would try to censure Ms. Hallam for something she said outside council chambers, “when we haven’t even done that for the disrespect, if you will, that’s happened in this body.”
Councilwoman Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis agreed, adding, “There’s no consistency and we can’t just certainly pick and choose when this issue comes up.”
Mr. Duerr, who abstained from the vote, said the motion should have been discussed further before a vote.
Amidst the back and forth between members, Council President Pat Catena voiced some support for Ms. Hallam. He suggested that jail oversight board meetings are frustrating and questions often go unanswered. He voted against censuring her.
“Calling someone a prick, unfortunately, at those meetings I understand,” Mr. Catena said. “Things get heated and things can get out of hand very quickly.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.