An attempt to censure Allegheny County Council member Bethany Hallam for a remark she made at a different board meeting last week failed to make it onto county council’s agenda Tuesday night.

The motion to add a censure vote to council’s agenda was introduced by Sam DeMarco, Ms. Hallam’s counterpart as a county council member-at-large. Mr. DeMarco is a Republican and Ms. Hallam is a Democrat. The motion failed with a vote of 6-9.

Council members Suzanne Filiaggi, Tom Duerr, Nicholas Futules, Robert Macey, DeWitt Walton and DeMarco voted in favor of the motion.

Neither Mr. DeMarco nor Ms. Hallam could immediately be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

The move was in response to a remarks Ms. Hallam made at a Jail Oversight Board meeting Thursday night. After a back and forth with Court of Common Pleas Judge Elliot Howsie, a fellow oversight board member and frequent adversary, Ms. Hallam called the judge a name under her breath.

“Pardon me,” Judge Howsie said. “Did you just call me a prick?”

Ms. Hallam replied, confirming that’s what she said: “I think that’s the nicest word I could say the way you talk to me.”

“Hope everyone heard that,” Judge Howsie said.

In a release announcing his intent to propose the censure, Mr. DeMarco said he was “embarrassed and offended” by Ms. Hallam’s remark, noting that “as the council president’s appointment to the Jail Oversight Board, Ms. Hallam’s actions reflect on all members of council.”

Advertise with us

The spat followed Ms. Hallam’s questions regarding why the board was not made aware of an ongoing investigation into an Allegheny County Jail corrections officer. The officer was ultimately charged for allegedly bringing contraband into the jail.

“I’m asking why we were not being made aware of such a serious issue until much after the fact,” she asked.

Warden Orlando Harper called it a personnel matter, saying jail officials don’t report on ongoing law enforcement investigations.

Judge Howsie posed to Ms. Hallam the question of what the benefit would be of publicizing an ongoing investigation.

“I don’t know, I’m not a cop,” Ms. Hallam said.

Advertise with us

The exchange in question followed as Judge Howsie attempted to keep the meeting moving.

Mr. DeMarco called on Ms. Hallam to apologize to Judge Howsie and “refrain from this type of behavior in the future.”