The Allegheny County Jail appears to be breaking solitary-confinement limits that voters approved, according to a legal interpretation sought by County Councilwoman and jail critic Bethany Hallam.
Ms. Hallam disclosed the Feb. 15 interpretation during a tense meeting Thursday of the Jail Oversight Board, claiming the board faces a liability risk. But the panel had already received legal guidance on the matter from former county Solicitor Andy Szefi, said county Judge Elliot Howsie, who chairs the board.
Ms. Hallam raised no questions in an earlier closed-door session addressing the confinement matter and other legal questions around the jail, Judge Howsie said. Ms. Hallam rejected that, saying she had asked repeatedly for a legal opinion from the county and never received one.
“I would just like to warn the board and the jail that this is opening us up to a lawsuit — not just the warden himself, not just the county, but the members of this board who refuse to enforce this law that was passed,” said Ms. Hallam, who sits on the oversight board.
Solicitor Frederick N. Frank, who represents County Council, wrote the seven-page interpretation that Hallam shared Thursday. Citing “facts as [Ms. Hallam] described them,” Mr. Frank wrote that the jail appears to be breaking the restriction on solitary confinement approved through a May 2021 ballot question. The rule holds that the jail generally should not hold inmates in solitary confinement for more than 20 hours a day.
Although the jail claims an exception when multiple inmates are confined together, that’s not valid under county code, Mr. Frank wrote. Last January, board members cited a monthly report showing almost 300 inmates had been confined alone to their cells beyond the limit. Warden Orlando Harper pointed to “safety” as the reason.
Read More
Among Mr. Frank’s opinions, he advised Ms. Hallam that partial lockdowns alone do not afford exceptions to solitary-confinement restrictions and that the county executive cannot appoint a designee to the oversight board, as County Executive Rich Fitzgerald has.
A county spokesperson declined comment Friday on Mr. Frank’s interpretation. It wasn’t clear how Mr. Szefi, now a county judge, advised the oversight board on the legal matters. He did not immediately respond to requests for comment Friday. Judge Howsie did not immediately return a call.
At Thursday’s meeting, Judge Howsie urged Ms. Hallam to gather more information about past practices and how those relate to Mr. Fitzgerald’s longtime practice of appointing a designee. Judge Howsie said she only recently raised objections after serving more than a year as Mr. Fitzgerald and other county officials sent designees to the board.
“That was before I was in law school and knew how to interpret the law and canons of construction,” Ms. Hallam said. She began objecting “as soon as I was made aware that that was something I could object to.”
Ms. Hallam, who is seeking reelection this year to her at-large seat on County Council, has clashed repeatedly with Judge Howsie. In January, Ms. Hallam faced a censure effort after she called him a “prick” at a jail board meeting. Council declined to rebuke her formally in a 10-3 vote.
Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.