Emotions ran high during Thursday’s Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board meeting when the mother of Gerald Thomas Jr., a man who died in the facility, took the stand for public comment.
“I ask if you are running a jail or a cemetery,” said Juana Saunders, Mr. Thomas’ mother, as she stood before Warden Orlando Harper and members of the jail staff. “It is clear you are attempting to do both.”
Thomas was 26 when he collapsed in the jail on March 8. He later died in UPMC Mercy hospital and the cause was ruled by the county medical examiner to be from a bilateral pulmonary embolism.
A jail spokesman responded that staff members called a medical emergency upon finding Thomas, and attempted lifesaving measures until medics arrived on the unit.
But Ms. Saunders argued that her son asked the jail three days prior to his collapse for medical care, and she cast doubt on whether the jail would have been able to provide the care.
At the time, Thomas was the second jail inmate to die in 2022. Since the beginning of the pandemic, 13 inmates have died — 10 inside the jail and 3 in nearby hospitals on medical release.
Read More
County Councilwoman Bethany Hallam, a member of the jail board, later advocated on behalf of the board for access to jail medical records, specifically for inmates who have died.
“We hear continuously, month after month, we have loved ones who lost their family members in the jail,” Ms. Hallam said. “Often times we are told there was no foul play, it was a natural death — I don’t know about you, but I don’t think it’s natural when we have 26-year-olds falling dead on the floor of the jail.”
Ms. Hallam mentioned other jail boards in the country that are permitted to conduct oversight investigations into jail deaths, including those on Rikers Island in New York and Denver.
Mr. Harper said the jail could not provide the board with information because it’s pending litigation.
But Ms. Hallam claimed the jail’s legal team told her they were holding on to records even for cases that weren’t pending litigation — but could be in the future.
“There may not be pending litigation at this time, but in the future, it could be, so therefore, we cannot give that information,” Mr. Harper said.
Earlier, Mr. Harper disputed the grim portrait of the deaths in his jail, stating that the facility’s death rate is significantly below the national average.
Jesse Bunch: jbunch@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.