A public hearing over Pittsburgh’s proposed annexation of Wilkinsburg was about to end on Thursday when a borough resident hurried through the door, delivering the night’s most passionate argument against the merger.

“This is not popular,” said Renee Donley, of Wilkinsburg, addressing two members of Pittsburgh City Council and a small gathering of neighbors. “If you end up putting it on the ballot, it is in fact going to fail.”

City Council’s vote on whether to annex the 15,000-resident borough was tabled until next year after members rejected it in February, saying they needed more information on the plan that would join the East End community with the city of Pittsburgh.

Thursday’s hearing at a North Side community center was the third in a series of information sessions open to the public.

Advertise with us

Those in favor of the merger say it would lower property taxes for Wilkinsburg residents while adding tax revenue for Pittsburgh and a boost to its population.

But those opposed, like Ms. Donley, are wary of gentrification and rising housing costs that could result from real estate developers hungry to revitalize the area.

“This is about bankers and developers who will make a fortune if they continue the East Liberty and Bakery Square development into Wilkinsburg,” Ms. Donley said, “but Wilkinsburg doesn’t want this.”

She was quick to single out the Wilkinsburg Community Development Corp. for its support of annexation.

Last year, the nonprofit economic development group rifted with Wilkinsburg’s Council after it campaigned to bring the annexation to a vote despite some council members’ disapproval.

Advertise with us

Bud Wise, chair of the WCDC, was in attendance and made his pitch for annexation.

“I think it would be a win for both Pittsburgh and for Wilkinsburg,” Mr. Wise said. “I’ve watched my hometown decline for decades — it’s the population loss, the reduction in businesses, it’s the increase in vacant properties and blight.”

In dispute of Ms. Donley, Mr. Wise claimed the move was in fact a grassroots effort that arose from focus groups conducted with residents.

Mr. Wise, who lives in Squirrel Hill, said a primary obstacle to investment in the area was high property taxes.

Because Wilkinsburg funds many of its own services, including its police department, some residents see the merger as a way to share services and lower their taxes.

Advertise with us

While there are months before City Council will take their vote, those in support and those opposed seem to be locked in a stalemate. Should council vote to annex Wilkinsburg, the final decision would go to a vote that would allow the borough’s residents to decide themselves.

Kate Luxemburg, another Wilkinsburg resident opposed to annexation, offered council members what she sees as an alternative solution to help increase Pittsburgh’s population.

Ms. Luxemburg believes the city should turn vacant homes within Pittsburgh limits into affordable housing to attract residents. The Wilkinsburg resident referred to these homes as in “legal limbo” because of tax liens placed on them by the county.

“Look at the problem of it from the point of view of affordable housing,” Ms. Luxemburg said. “And the most important housing is the housing that’s already built.”