The Wilkinsburg annexation process has met another challenge, just days before a judge is set to review a petition to restart the merger process, as objections start rolling in.
A group of five Pittsburgh residents filed a joint objection on Thursday against the initiative, along with three others — two Wilkinsburg residents and one city resident — who recently filed separate objections.
On Sept. 29, the Wilkinsburg Community Development Corporation filed a petition to restart the merger process, after it was voted down by Pittsburgh City Council in February.
The WCDC’s petition is operating under the Pennsylvania 1903 Annexation Law, according to the court filings. However, the objectors are arguing that the law is invalid because it was repealed by the state Legislature in July.
Attorney Cliff Levine, who is representing the WCDC argued that the law was still valid because the repealed sections were not completed according to proper procedure laid out in the state’s constitution.
However, the group of objectors argues that even if that is the case, the law was previously repealed in 1970 when the General Assembly was reviewing changes of municipal boundaries but did not act within the constitutionally mandated two-year time limit.
Read More
“Even if, for some reason, this court finds that the 1903 Annexation Law survived the [1970] deadline … the General Assembly’s repeal of the 1903 Annexation Law was effectively repealed by Act 41 of 2022,” attorney Chuck Pascal, who represents the group of five objectors, argued in the filing.
Validity of the 1903 law aside, objectors also have raised the issue that if proceedings continue to follow the outline of that law, it doesn’t allow for “any formal participation” by the Pittsburgh Public School District or Pittsburgh residents.
“Only the City Council of the City of Pittsburgh has a role, and, of course, City Council has no governance authority over school district affairs,” the objection said.
Pam Harbin, a member of the Pittsburgh Public School Board, is listed in court documents as one of the objectors, acting in her official capacity.
During the first round of merger discussions, the Wilkinsburg School District said that it was open to discussing what a merger between it and Pittsburgh Public Schools would look like.
Currently, Wilkinsburg students in grades 7 to 12 already attend city schools, but people have raised concerns about the strain that could be put on PPS by adding K-6 students as well.
Although the Wilkinsburg school district is in good financial standing according to district officials, any debts and contracts they have would belong to city schools if the annexation goes through.
As it stands, only Wilkinsburg residents would be able to vote on the merger via a ballot referendum. Mr. Pascal called this “a deprivation of a fundamental right” in his filing by not allowing city residents to also vote on it.
“Certainly, the people of Pittsburgh should have the right to vote on the same issues as the people of Wilkinsburg as it would affect them equally, if not more so,” the court filing read.
Similar issues were echoed in the other objectors’ filings.
A hearing for the petition to restart the annexation process is scheduled for Oct. 18, where Common Pleas Judge Joseph James will consider the original petition and all objections.
If he approves the effort to restart the merger process, Pittsburgh City Council will have three months to vote on the measure. If it approves it, it will then appear as a ballot referendum in the 2024 primary election.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.