On the issue of banning discrimination in doctor’s offices and hospitals, Allegheny County Council members unanimously and quickly came together to pass protections for numerous protected classes, including gender identity.  However, passionate debate and bickering over meeting rules ensued before two proposals — one to ban “less lethal” weapons, the other to mandate COVID-19 testing at county facilities — ultimately failed after several weeks in the committee process.

With all 15 members present, council on Tuesday passed a countywide nondiscrimination requirement in medical treatment settings.

The county’s protected classes include: race, color, religion, national origin or ancestry, sex, gender identity or expression, sexual orientation, disability, marital status, familial status, age or individuals who use a guide or support animal.

Councilman Paul Klein, D-Shadyside, introduced the measure in June, citing the Trump administration’s June 12 reversal of health care protections for trans individuals in hospitals, doctor’s offices and in dealing with insurance companies.

Advertise with us

The harmony stopped when the time came to cast a final vote on a measure that would ban the Allegheny County police from using so-called less-lethal weapons such as tear gas, flash-bang grenades and bean bag rounds. Only three members — including co-sponsors Bethany Hallam, D-at large; Olivia Bennett, D-Northview Heights; and Anita Prizio, D-O’Hara — voted in favor of the measure. The rest voted against.

The bill arrived to the full council with a negative recommendation from the Health and Human Services committee.

During the several minutes of statements preceding the vote, Councilman DeWitt Walton, D-Hill District, said the measure is “not in the best interest in our citizenry at large.”

While he did vote against the bill, Council President Pat Catena said he considered peaceful protesters being hit with tear gas a “serious problem” and said that he’s “very interested” in learning findings of the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board’s investigation of the violent clash between police and protesters June 1 in East Liberty. The incident is now the target of a federal lawsuit.

Ms. Hallam and Ms. Bennett’s bill to mandate COVID-19 testing at the county’s Kane Regional Centers and the Allegheny County Jail and to test all county employees also failed in a 10-5 vote. Those in favor were Ms. Bennett, Ms. Hallam, Mr. Klein, Ms. Prizio and Mr. Catena.

Advertise with us

Prior to the final vote, Ms. Hallam introduced an amendment to make testing among employees voluntary. The motion failed 9-6.

Members delivered impassioned statements and counterarguments, at times personal, about the merits of testing employees for the novel coronavirus.

Councilman Tom Duerr, D-Bethel Park, said his aunt was one of the residents who died of COVID-19 at the county’s Kane center in Glen Hazel but said he couldn’t support testing employees as it would only represent a “snapshot” in time of whether a person was positive or negative for the respiratory virus.

The state has already mandated testing at the county-run long-term care facilities.

Mr. Catena said he supports testing staff because he is worried about the positive cases that have emerged among employees in the county courthouse. Mr. Catena, who joined the meeting by phone, said that he didn’t attend in person because he is taking care of his mother who is recovering from surgery and didn’t want to risk being exposed.

Advertise with us

The bill on testing arrived to council with an affirmative recommendation from the Public Safety committee, after earlier receiving a negative recommendation from that same committee.

Members introduced several other bills and sent them to committee, including Mr. Catena’s bill aimed at making county employees’ salaries more transparent.

“When I came on as president, I said I was going to keep the public informed about what their tax dollars are being spent on, and I think this is a good example of that,” Mr. Catena said, adding that budget season is soon approaching.

Council is now on recess until Aug. 18.

Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com