One is a 62-year-old lifelong educator living in Ohio Township who provides therapy for children under the age of 3 who have developmental disabilities.
The other is a 51-year-old businesswoman in Aleppo who has made good money over last 25 years by investing in startup companies and watching them flourish.
Both women, who have never held statewide elected office, are presenting themselves as Harrisburg outsiders who can get things done in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives.
And while bigger races snag the spotlight, Michele Knoll, the Democratic educator, and Valerie Gaydos, the Republican businesswoman, are competing in a moderate district filled with crossover voters that could be an indicator for how larger midterm elections will play out next month.
The candidates are vying for the District 44 seat vacated by retiring Rep. Mark Mustio, a Republican from North Fayette, who has held the office since 2003.
The district spans the west and north Allegheny County suburbs surrounding the Pittsburgh International Airport, including Moon, Findlay, North Fayette, Crescent, Aleppo, Ohio Township, Sewickley and Edgeworth — and the seat has always been held by a man.
Read More
The makeup of the area is middle class, filled with a high proportion of seniors, teachers and blue-collar union workers.
Those demographics — as the candidates see it, anyway — could play to either candidate’s advantage.
“I look like this district,” Ms. Knoll said. “This district’s biggest demographic is me: a white, college-educated woman, middle-aged or older. So that’s who I’m getting door to door.”
Ms. Knoll said she first considered running for the seat four years ago when Mr. Mustio was running unopposed. With the election of Donald Trump as president in 2016, it seemed like the right time.
She was one of 20 candidates this year to graduate from Emerge Pennsylvania, an organization founded in 2015 to provide six months of training to Democratic female candidates on campaign strategy, fundraising and speech-writing.
“We have very few educators in the General Assembly, and that’s the second-biggest block in the budget,” she said. “People making decisions on education have never stood in front of a classroom. They’ve never done without supplies because there aren’t enough supplies in the school. Having those experiences informs decisions I could make.”
Ms. Gaydos, meanwhile, said she’s finding a lot in common on front porches. Her grandparents emigrated from Slovakia, and her father used the G.I. Bill to become a dentist for union mill workers in Ambridge. She attended Quaker Valley School District and graduated from Sewickley Academy, a prestigious private school, in 1985.
She portrays herself as someone who eschews political stereotypes.
“There’s an independence to a lot of people here,” Ms. Gaydos said. “People are sick of both parties and they just want people to work together again.”
“I’ve been in business 25 years and never once has party affiliation ever been a factor in getting something done,” she added. “And I think that resonates with a lot of people because they’re just sick and tired of people digging in their heels and taking one side or the other.”
According to Pennsylvania voter registration data as of June, the 44th District is remarkably competitive: 43 percent were registered as Democrats, 42 percent were Republicans, and 15 percent were another party or independents.
Only a dozen of the 288 House districts had a tighter margin between Democrats and Republicans, according to the state data.
In the 2016 election, most of the district went for Mr. Trump — but not by an insurmountable margin. Ms. Gaydos said she navigates difficult conversations about Mr. Trump by presenting herself as apart from the president’s personality.
“People are conflicted, there’s no doubt about that,” she said. “But when I talk to them, I say, ‘Look, I support the agenda, I just don’t support the antics.’ That’s how I feel.”
So the antics never cross a line? For some people, they do, she said. For others, he’s preferable to voting for a Democrat.
“Do you want somebody who might have a better face or more appealing face and approach to things — but then not get anything done?” she said, outlining the thinking of Mr. Trump’s supporters. “Or would I rather have someone get something done and be a little rough around the edges?”
The two candidates have distinguished themselves along conventional party lines. How — and how much — state education money is spent is shaping up to be a central issue.
Ms. Knoll supports better education funding, a $15 an hour minimum wage and better staffing for state agencies, such as the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, that enforce state provisions that remain strong where the Trump administration has pulled back.
Ms. Gaydos, a former president of the Pennsylvania Angel Network, a statewide group of angel investors, wants to use her office to scale back government.
“She wants to throw more money at schools,” Ms. Gaydos said. “I have run lean startup companies. I’ve started with zero. People don’t mind paying taxes, they just want to make sure it’s not being done wastefully.Throwing money at something is not always the answer.”
Ms. Gaydos criticized Ms. Knoll’s vote to raise taxes to pay for a school demolition when she served on the Avonworth school board in the 1990s. She said she hears from seniors living on fixed income who grouse about the notion of paying more for education.
“We’ve got really phenomenal school districts ... these are some of the highest-paid teachers and highest-benefiting schools, probably in the state,” Ms. Gaydos said. “And that’s not lost on a lot of people to have a candidate say we need more money to go to schools.”
Ms. Knoll said she faced a difficult decision with no other choice. The demolition removed aging, asbestos-filled buildings and replaced them with homes, she said.
“You can’t just walk away from it,” Ms. Knoll said.
In an historic year for women running for office, there’s a sharp divide on the significance of that fact.
Ms. Knoll has embraced the outpouring of support, she said, from a core group of women volunteers who hit the streets with her. Ms. Knoll believes outrage at Mr. Trump, as well as the #MeToo movement, will translate to high turnout among women and flip the 44th District in favor of Democrats.
Ms. Knoll even shared a story, published in an opinion piece in the Post-Gazette in August, of an unwelcome embrace on the campaign trail.
Ms. Gaydos said she believes the #MeToo movement has unfairly turned all women into victims.
“I’m tired of victimology,” she said. “Are there problems, are there disparities? Yeah, you bet there are. But there are some things women get that men don’t, and vice versa, and what we should be doing is celebrating what we each are very good at doing instead of pitting the genders against each other.”
Of Ms. Knoll’s claims, she said, “Look, we’re all grown adults; we can handle that. And if you can’t handle that, you shouldn’t run for the office. That’s the way I feel.”
Ms. Knoll responded with a statement: “We should all find my opponent’s comments to be offensive. She believes that sexual violence or harassment should be accepted, tolerated or ignored, and that victims are to blame. I disagree wholeheartedly.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.