Rennick Remley, the Republican running in a City Council special election, did not appear at a Tuesday morning court hearing in which lawyers argued over his whereabouts. And during the hour-long hearing before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph James, solid evidence about where he lived was almost as elusive.

Voting in the special election

The Allegheny County Elections Division reminds residents who plan to vote in the city's District 8 special election on March 6 that they must be registered by Monday. Voters who have moved or changed their name or party affiliation also must notify the elections division. Voters can do so at www.votespa.com.

But by mid-afternoon, Judge James had penned a one-sentence order keeping Mr. Remley on the March 6 ballot.

Advertise with us

“We are delighted, but not surprised, that Judge James found that the challengers brought a weak and unsubstantiated case aimed at preventing any Republican from appearing on the ballot,” said Ron Hicks, a Republican attorney who represented Mr. Remley.

The ruling can be appealed. But attorney Chuck Pascal, who’d filed the petition seeking to remove Mr. Remley, said he would have to consult with his clients on whether to appeal.

Mr. Remley is one of four candidates running to replace former City Councilman Dan Gilman. But last week Mr. Pascal, who frequently represents the Democratic Party and its candidates, filed a petition on behalf of two residents challenging Mr. Remley's candidacy.

Under the city's home rule charter, a City Council member must have lived in the district — which in District 8’s case includes Shadyside and portions of Oakland, Point Breeze, and Squirrel Hill — for at least one year prior to the election. Mr. Pascal's petition argued that Mr. Remley had not done so.

"It's a heavy burden [to show] that somebody is no longer a resident," argued Mr. Hicks, who represents the county's Republican Committee, before Judge James. Mr. Remley's voting record, he suggested, offered proof that he lived within the district even if he sometimes hung his hat elsewhere: Mr. Remley had been registered to vote from Shadyside's St. James Place since 2015.

Advertise with us

But on Jan. 18, the same day Republicans filed papers naming him as their candidate, Mr. Remley submitted an address-change form showing he’d moved to an apartment building in Squirrel Hill. According to testimony on Tuesday, that building is owned by George Mongell, who like Mr. Remley is a member of the district's Republican committee.

Mr. Pascal brought forth a handful of witnesses who painted a murky picture of Mr. Remley's lodgings.

Mary McKinney Flaherty confirmed that Mr. Remley had stayed on the third floor of her St. James Place home until May of 2016, when he told her he was moving to Squirrel Hill, she said. But his mail was forwarded not just to that address, but to another one, possibly on Washington Place in Uptown, she said.

Elizabeth Reed, the property manager at Washington Place's Chatham Towers condominium complex, said that she had often seen Mr. Remley on building cameras, though not recently. The complex is in Uptown, well outside District 8. A doorman said he had seen Mr. Remley exiting the building "almost every morning" for the past six or eight months. Anthony Dolan testified that Mr. Remley had told him he lived near PPG Paints Arena in Uptown.

Mr. Remley did not testify or appear at the proceeding, and Mr. Hicks offered no other proof of residency beyond Mr. Remley's voting record. In his closing argument, he noted that the state election code asserted that “a person shall not be considered to have lost his residence who leaves his home ... for temporary purposes only, with the intention of returning.”

Advertise with us

Asked after the hearing why Mr. Remley did not appear, Mr. Hicks said, "He didn't have to," because the burden of proof was on those contesting his residency. He noted that Mr. Pascal had not produced any records proving Mr. Remley lived anywhere else.

After the hearing, Mr. Pascal noted that the evidence showed that wherever Mr. Remley lived, it hadn't been at St. James Place since 2016 — even though that was the address listed on his voter registration until this month. Mr. Hicks, he said “kept relying on the fact that [Mr. Remley’s voting record showed he stayed within the district, when the clear proof was that he didn’t live at the address on his registration.”

"I've never seen a residency challenge where the candidate didn't appear," he added.

Mr. Pascal’s clients, petitioners Helen and Joseph Cupelli, also did not attend the hearing, though that is not uncommon in such proceedings.

Judge James, who noted at the end of his hearing that “time is of the essence,” issued his one-sectence order shortly after 2:30 p.m. Republicans lost little time hailing him for having “rejected this attempt to restrict ballot access to a single, monopoly party,” while lamenting that the race had been “made all the harder by the waste of time and resources surrounding this ballot access challenge.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.