An effort is underway to remove Rennick Remley, one of four candidates seeking to represent Pittsburgh’s District 8 in city council, from the March 6 special election ballot.

A petition seeking to remove the Republican candidate due to objections over his residency status was filed late Monday in the name of two residents of District 8, Helen and Joseph Cupelli.

District 8 includes Shadyside and portions of Oakland, Point Breeze and Squirrel Hill. Under the Home Rule charter, a City Council member must have lived in the district for at least one year prior to the election. But the petition notes that on Jan. 18, the same day Republicans filed nominating papers naming Mr. Remley as their candidate, he submitted an address-change form suggesting he’d moved from St. James Place, in Shadyside, to Forbes Avenue.

While both addresses lie within the district, the petition says, “Remley has not resided at the St. James Place address for approximately two years,” and indeed “has not resided within the 8th Councilmanic District … for at least an equivalent amount of time.”

Advertise with us

Had Mr. Remley lived outside the district during that period, he’d be disqualified from holding the office should he win it, the petition argues. And that, in turn, would mean that Mr. Remley’s nominating papers were fraudulent, because they included a sworn statement that the candidate is eligible for the office being sought.

The petition does not provide evidence that Mr. Remley did not live in the district prior to Jan. 18. County voting records show that Mr. Remley voted at the polling place associated with the St. James Place address between 2015 and 2017.

But attorney Chuck Pascal, the lawyer who filed the petition, said, “We expect to present witnesses to show that Remley hasn't lived at the address in Shadyside for several years. We also expect to produce witnesses who will offer testimony to demonstrate that Remley has lived elsewhere in the city, outside of District 8, throughout the last year, and may continue to do so.”

Mr. Pascal said the candidate’s history of the voting district wouldn’t matter “if he didn’t really live there, and I believe we can prove he didn’t.”

Mr. Remley did not respond to calls made by the Post-Gazette Monday and Tuesday, but on Tuesday his campaign issued a statement calling the petition “poorly researched” and saying it represented “another example of the dangers of the single-party machine rule that has held Pittsburgh back.”

Advertise with us

Campaign spokesman Dennis Roddy said: “This is a one-month campaign and Democratic operatives are trying to tie up the Remley campaign with a meaningless court action.”  He said Mr. Remley’s civic engagement in the district included regularly attending church within Shadyside.

Mr. Pascal, a longtime state committeeman and delegate to the Democratic National Convention, typically represents Democrats in election-related cases. It’s not unusual for such challenges to use rank-and-file voters as stand-ins for a candidate or party, but Mr. Pascal declined to identify who was backing the challenge.

Three other candidates are in the running: Restaurant owner Sonja Finn, who Democrats nominated as their challenger, and independent candidates Marty Healey and Erika Strassburger, who served as the District 8 office’s chief of staff for former City Councilman Dan Gilman.

Election challenges are typically heard before county Judge Joseph James, whose office confirmed that a hearing was scheduled for the morning of Jan. 30. But the candidates may have an opportunity to argue the point before then: The 14th Ward Independent Democratic Club is sponsoring a debate for all four candidates from 1 to 3 p.m. Sunday at Chatham University’s Eddy Theater.