It takes a special person to sit in judgment of others, to sentence someone to the ultimate punishment -- death -- and to hear the series of agonizing, heartbreaking details that led to that point. And, perhaps most importantly, to do it without becoming jaded.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge David R. Cashman was one of those rare people.

For more than three decades, Judge Cashman presided in the Criminal Division of the county court as “one of the best judges on the bench,” according to defense attorney Patrick Thomassey.

“Judge Cashman was an old-school type of judge,” he said. “He was the kind of guy who looked at every case individually -- every defendant -- individually. He was the best at it that I ever saw.”

Advertise with us

Judge Cashman, who had been serving as a senior judge since the beginning of this year, died Sunday in his sleep at his Mt. Lebanon home. He was 76.

The son of two doctors, he grew up in North Haven, near New Haven, in Connecticut.

“His mother was a psychiatrist and his father was a GP,” said his wife, Kathryn Cashman. “They worked out of the house, so he would see patients coming and going. He even helped to deliver babies.”

Judge Cashman chose a career in law rather than medicine, following in the footsteps of one of his uncles, who was a lawyer.

But, he didn’t make that decision right away.

Advertise with us

In fact, Judge Cashman earned a bachelor’s degree in Chinese studies from Brown University, an Ivy-League school in Providence, R.I., in 1968.

Years later, he and his wife would eventually visit China, a country and culture that always fascinated him, Mrs. Cashman said.

In the spring of his senior year at Brown, a snafu with his transcripts convinced Judge Cashman to study at Duquesne University School of Law.

His records were inadvertently switched with those of a younger student of the same name when Judge Cashman applied to a variety of law schools.

“None of the law schools got back to him, but his brother Justin was in the admissions department at Duquesne and told David that he’d been accepted at Duquesne,” his wife said, laughing at the memory. “David told him, ‘I didn’t apply to Duquesne.’ His brother said, ‘Well, we found out that none of your transcripts came through in time, so we’ve accepted you anyway.’”

Advertise with us

The following year, after the mix-up was corrected, Judge Cashman was accepted by several prestigious law schools, including Georgetown, but he decided to stay at Duquesne, where he earned a law degree in 1971.

In 1977, when he was working for the Downtown firm of Cauley Birsic & Conflenti, he met Kathryn Aloe, whose family business was among the firm’s clients.

“After we met, we would run into each other from time to time, but after we finally went on a date, I knew that night -- I told him, ‘This seems really good,’ and he said, ‘I can handle that.’ And we were married in October of 1980,” his wife said.

Gifted with an “incredible memory,” that would later serve him well on the bench, his wife said, Judge Cashman could recite details of all of the cases he handled, even decades later.

Little white lies were never an option in their marriage, Mrs. Cashman said, laughing.

Advertise with us

“I learned early on that I had to tell him the truth, always,” she said. “He would point to all of his case files in their drawers and say, ‘I remember what’s in there.’ It was really remarkable.”

Three years after founding a partnership with his friend Gerald Cipriani in 1985, Judge Cashman was appointed to the county Common Pleas Court by Gov. Robert P. Casey to fill the unexpired term of Judge Robert A. Doyle, who became a senior judge in the court’s Civil Division.

Three years later, Judge Cashman, a lifelong Democrat, was rated “exceptionally qualified” -- the highest possible ranking -- from his peers in the county Bar Association and won his first 10-year term in office.

He presided over several memorable and tragic cases over the years, including in 2005, when he sentenced defendant William Thompson to life in prison for the triple slaying of an 8-year-old girl, her father and a suspected drug dealer, in 2002.

A jury convicted Thompson of being one of the gunmen who killed Thomas Mitchell III, a paraplegic and drug dealing rival who was sitting in a wheelchair outside of Mr. Tommy's Sandwich Shop in Homewood, investigators said.

Advertise with us

The Coles family, including 8-year-old Taylor Coles and her father Parrish Freeman, 35, were seated near Thompson at the restaurant when they were hit by a barrage of bullets from Thompson and his co-defendant Andra Crisswalle.

Fifteen years later, Judge Cashman agreed to recuse himself from presiding over a trial for Thompson’s son, DaQuan Thompson, who was charged with homicide by vehicle while driving under the influence and related counts.

According to the criminal complaint filed against him, DaQuan Thompson had a 0.191% blood alcohol content - more than twice the legal limit - and was traveling at 60 mph in a 25 mph speed zone in Shadyside, when he caused an accident, killing a front-seat passenger in his car.

When a defense lawyer mentioned the elder Thompson to Judge Cashman, the judge immediately began citing specific details from the case.

"Do I remember this case?" Judge Cashman asked, according to a Post-Gazette story at the time. "It's indelibly etched in my brain. It's one of the most horrific cases I've ever been involved in."

Advertise with us

In one unforgettable incident in 2010, Judge Cashman was called an “idiot” by a man who flew into a rage during sentencing for the rape and murder of his 2-year-old daughter.

In a courtroom spectacle that even spilled into the hallway outside Judge Cashman's third-floor courtroom, William Page railed that he was innocent of waking his daughter Nyia on a February night in 2007, sexually assaulting her, then abandoning her in woods behind the family's Braddock home, where she froze to death in 7-degree weather.

Judge Cashman was having none of it.

"Not only did you rape your daughter -- " said the judge, who Page interrupted several times as he attempted to pass sentence.

"Listen, idiot," Mr. Page shot back. "I didn't kill anybody. Give me the time so I can go, all right?"

Advertise with us

According to a June 2010 Post-Gazette story, Judge Cashman whacked the bench with his fist, threatened to toss Page from his own sentencing if he didn't shut up and declared him "a despicable human being," and then granted the defendant his wish. He gave him the time that Page asked for, and more.

When the judge left his courtroom a little while later, he spoke to reporters briefly.

“Let me tell you,” Judge Cashman said, pointing to himself. “This idiot's going home at 5 o'clock tonight. That idiot isn't.”

Judge Cashman didn’t stand for any baloney from lawyers either, requiring appropriate dress and respect, Mr. Thomassey recalled.

In 2002, he held a defense lawyer in contempt of court for not showing up to defend his seventh continuance request in three years for the same client.

Advertise with us

“You could tell by just how he ran his courtroom that he demanded respect for the court,” Mr. Thomassey said. “He was a no-nonsense guy and he’s going to be missed tremendously.”

Her husband loved golfing and reading murder mysteries in his free time and tried hard to leave his work at the courthouse, but it was sometimes impossible to avoid the haunting cases he dealt with, Mrs. Cashman said.

“You see some awful parts of humanity when you're in the criminal division,” she said. It really bothered him when it involved a child -- those were the cases that bothered him the most. He was very good at compartmentalizing himself, she said.

“In my personal opinion, he was a judge’s judge,” Mr. Thomassey said. “And, he was very good at what he did.”

Along with his wife, Judge Cashman is survived by his children Alex Cashman, of Upper St. Clair, and Chris Cashman, of Mt. Lebanon; his twin sister Grace Corkery, of Boston, and five grandchildren.

Advertise with us

A blessing service will be held Thursday at 10 a.m. at William Slater II Funeral Service, 1650 Greentree Road., Scott 15220. Entombment to follow at Queen of Heaven Cemetery.

In lieu of flowers, memorial donations to the Pittsburgh Food Bank are appreciated.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.