Charles “Carl” Grefenstette was the sort of man everyone wanted to honor.
As a World War II veteran and top executive of The Hillman Company, where he was a close friend and trusted confidant of the late billionaire financier Henry Hillman, and as one of Duquesne University's “most prominent graduates” — according to its president — the devout Catholic and father of nine deserved it.
“Carl was a very special person of enormous accomplishment and generosity,” said Duquesne President Ken Gormley. “He was nationally respected as a business leader, known for the high ethical standards he modeled and insisted upon in his work, in addition to being a leader among generations of Duquesne graduates.”
Though he was grateful for the honorary gestures, her father’s response was often the same, said his daughter, state Superior Court Judge Mary Jane Bowes.
Thanks, but no thanks.
“My father was very humble about his accomplishments and really did not like recognition,” his daughter said. “For most of his life, he declined awards. He wasn’t looking for accolades and honors. He was just looking to do the right thing, and he did.”
A legendary wit and semi-pro baseball player who was coached by Honus Wagner, Mr. Grefenstette, of Scott, died June 4, just a week shy of his 95th birthday.
He was born in Toledo, Ohio, but raised mostly in Carrick, where he pitched the Carrick All-Stars to South Hills Baseball League championships.
After graduating from St. Basil High School in 1945, he played for the Dormont Club of the Greater Pittsburgh League. Wagner, the “Flying Dutchman,” was coach and manager. Mr. Grefenstette also shared the field with another Hall-of-Famer, Pirates right fielder “Big Poison” Paul Waner.
Known for his curve ball, Mr. Grefenstette was signed by the Boston Braves but chose instead to serve his country and joined the Navy during World War II, “even though I couldn’t swim,” he said in a 2017 history compiled by the Hillman Family Foundations.
While his unit was training for an amphibious invasion in the Pacific, the war ended with the atomic bombings of Japan.
Mr. Grefenstette served on a landing craft tank, returning Asian prisoners to their homelands. He was later transferred to shore in Yokosuka, Japan, where he played baseball for the Navy.
Once, upon entering a Catholic cathedral, Mr. Grefenstette saw Japanese civilians praying the rosary. It was a memory that helped to shape a faith that would guide him for life.
Back home, Mr. Grefenstette decided against joining a Braves’ minor league team, instead becoming the first in his family to go to college.
At Duquesne, he used the GI Bill to study accounting while pitching for the Dukes from 1947-1950. The summer after he graduated in 1950, Mr. Grefenstette played semi-pro ball for a season in Canada.
Around the same time, Mr. Grefenstette met Mount Washington native Mary Jane Kelly at a dance in Brentwood.
In the 2017 Hillman history, he recalled that night in detail.
“She was a beautiful brunette,” Mr. Grefenstette said in 2017, “so I asked her to dance. Then my buddy asked her to dance, and she said, ‘Do you know Carl Grefenstette?’
“He said, ‘Oh, yeah. You don’t want to have anything to do with him. He’s a prude.’ Later she told me, ‘Right then, I knew I wanted to talk to you.’”
The couple married in 1951 and went on to have nine children. Mrs. Grefenstette died in 2013.
The Grefenstettes also adopted two nieces who were left orphaned when their parents died in a car crash in Cairo, Egypt.
“We were very blessed with a wonderful family,” Mr. Grefenstette recalled in the 2017 interview. “Mary Jane was a hero. Christmases were wonderful. On Christmas Eve, she’d work until 2 o’clock at night, running out to the all-night drugstore to get more gifts.”
In 1951, Mr. Grefenstette answered an ad for an accountant at Pittsburgh Coke & Chemical, a publicly owned company the Hillman family controlled and operated, according to the Hillman Family Foundations.
By 1963, Henry Hillman recognized his talent and work ethic, tapping Mr. Grefenstette to join the outside accounting company that prepared the company’s taxes. The move would enable Mr. Grefenstette to earn certification as a public accountant. He later became indispensable to Hillman, helping to transform the company into the country’s largest investor in venture capital by the early 1980s.
“Carl and Henry were a formidable team,” said Joe Manzinger, chairman and CEO of The Hillman Company, in a company statement. “They had a wonderful rapport and thrived on deal-making. Carl was named president … in 1981, kicking off a long run in which he and Henry identified opportunity after opportunity. When discussing past deals, the two takeaways you always had were how much fun they were having and their mutual respect.”
“I loved it,” Mr. Grefenstette recalled of the years he spent with Mr. Hillman, negotiating deals for companies that ran the gamut from energy and biotechnology, to deepwater oil exploration, to medical supplies.
“He really didn't have an ego, and I think that’s what attracted Henry Hillman to my dad, and Henry Hillman didn't have an ego, either,” Judge Bowes said of her father. “They had real synergy together. They thought the same way and had the same high ethical standards. It was a great partnership.”
Mr. Grefenstette was named CEO in 1990 and retired in 2018 — at the age of 90 — after the death of Hillman a year earlier.
He served on the boards of the Hillman Family Foundations and Duquesne, where Mr. Grefenstette led the search committee in 1988 for the university’s first lay president, John E. Murray, and where he was selected as a charter member of the university’s Century Club of Distinguished Duquesne Alumni.
One of the few other awards Mr. Grefenstette accepted was the university’s highest honor for an alumnus, the McAnulty Service Award. Hillman recognized his friend and colleague in his final wishes, establishing the Carl G. Grefenstette Center for Ethics in Science, Technology and Law at Duquesne.
It was a fitting tribute, Mr. Gormley said.
“Carl was so well respected and known for his deep sense of what’s right. In the world of business where things can quickly get murky, Carl was known for his natural sense of ethics rooted in his Catholic faith and upbringing,” he said.
He was also deeply respected at the Hillman Family Foundations, President David Roger said.
“He just had this profound wisdom — It just came to him naturally,” Mr. Roger said. “And he was notoriously witty. He was never boastful, but he was brimming with love for his family. We’re really going to miss him. He was a very special person.”
A lover of golf and Ireland, Mr. Grefenstette often hit the links with Hillman, including the time he shot a hole-in-one on an iconic tee at the Augusta National Golf Club.
“Henry Hillman previously hit a hole-in-one on the same hole — the 16th!” Judge Bowes said.
As per the club’s tradition, her father was expected to buy the house a round at the club’s tavern. But Hillman insisted on paying the tab, said Judge Bowes.
In addition to Judge Bowes, Mr. Grefenstette is survived by his other children, John, of Lake Frederick, Va., Greg, of Paris, France, Carol, of South Beach, Fla., Jerry, of Whitehall, Jim, of Dana Point, Cal., Edward, of Mt. Lebanon, Carl Martin, of Wexford, Jennifer Grefenstette Coblin, of Bethel Park, and Lisa Kelly Goodall, of Herndon, Va.; a sister, Margie Bankert, of Butler; and 25 grandchildren and nine great-grandchildren.
His funeral was Saturday.
Memorial contributions may be sent to Mary’s Place, 2905 Castlegate Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15226
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.