Being knocked out in the boxing ring doesn’t normally evoke the fondest of memories.
But it did for Robert “Bob” McGrath Sr., who was honored to be leveled by the likes of actor Burt Reynolds.
The two faced off as college students in the 1950s, when they served together as counselors at a Florida boys’ camp.
“He and my brother were good friends at the camp,” recalled Mr. McGrath’s brother, Patrick McGinley, laughing at the memory. “We had a photo of them together. My brother didn’t know Reynolds was a Golden Gloves champion, but the kids at the camp did, so they were goading them for an exhibition match. They made a makeshift ring. It took about 30 seconds and my brother was down. For the rest of the summer, Burt Reynolds felt terrible.”
Mr. McGrath, a longtime American history teacher and council member from Penn Hills, died May 19 after a series of recent health setbacks. He was 85.
He was born in Denver but the family moved to Titusville, Crawford County, when he was a young boy, after his father died.
By 1953, they settled in Penn Hills, where Mr. McGrath played on the high school football team and graduated in 1954.
He went on to the University of Tampa, then completed his education at Ohio Northern University, earning a bachelor’s degree in American history in 1959.
During a trip home to Penn Hills, he met Brenda Kapp and the two married in September of 1959.
That same year, Mr. McGrath enlisted in the Army National Guard, where he served for six years.
He taught briefly at Franklin Regional High School before joining the faculty at Penn Hills High School in 1965.
For the next 30-plus years, he taught American history to students, many of whom he considered his second children, said his brother.
“He was a rock for his students,” said Mr. McGinley, a law professor at West Virginia University College of Law. “When I would go home and we’d go out, he would see students from 20 or 30 years before and he would remember them. He treated his students like they were his children and he cared a great deal about them. I think that was a very special part of his life, to see his students go on and do good things in their lives.”
But, teaching was just one of Mr. McGrath’s jobs.
To support his family of five children, he moonlighted with Penn Hills in the public works and code enforcement offices, including as interim director of code enforcement.
“He held as many as three jobs at a time,” said his son Robert “Bobby” McGrath Jr., of North Kingstown, R.I. “He was very hardworking.”
His father’s job near large construction equipment was the ultimate thrill for a young boy, Bobby McGrath recalled.
“He once arranged for me to ride along on one of those big motor graders,” he said. “And, I remember him going out for building inspections.”
Eventually, Mr. McGrath decided to make a run for Penn Hills council.
“My dad just was always so concerned and committed to our community,” his son said. “I think maybe being a history teacher incentivized him to get involved in politics.”
Mr. McGrath served on council from 1988-1990 and 1992-2000, including as deputy mayor in 1998, before he decided not to seek reelection.
A Republican, his brother found partisan politics distasteful, Mr. McGinley said.
“He wasn’t a partisan,” he said. “When he was on council, Penn Hills had a lot of dissension and he was always looking for practical answers.”
Mr. McGrath was an ardent Steelers and Penguins fan who tolerated the Pirates, but he remained loyal despite giving up hopes for a pennant, his son said.
“About 10 years ago, he said to me, ‘I’m never gonna live to see the Pirates win another World Series,’ ” he said, laughing. “But, he was still a devoted fan — he still watched through all the misery.”
When he gave a presentation in 1991 at a United Nations conference in Prague — in what was then Czechoslovakia — Mr. McGinley offered his brother the trip of a lifetime.
“My brother hadn’t had a chance to travel and the U.N. was going to pay for me to fly and I said to him, ‘OK, I’m taking you with me,’” he recalled. “We went to Paris, we visited Versailles, then we flew to Berlin, where Bobby met us.”
The trio rented a car and drove through the night through Poland and into Prague. After the conference, they visited other former Eastern Bloc countries and even toured a school.
“It was a crazy few days,” Mr. McGinley said.
As history buffs, the brothers were in their glory.
“We both read history — that was our thing — so going there was like Kennywood for us,” Mr. McGinley said.
The trip is among the many fond memories that his brother and son keep close to their hearts.
“It was a turning point in our relationship,” his son recalled. “It helped to make up for all of the grief I caused my parents in my rebellious teenage years.”
“It’s precious,” his brother said.
Along with his wife, son and brother, Mr. McGrath is survived by his children Michael P. McGrath of New Kensington; Julie L. Scott of Nashville, Ark.; Jill McGrath Keebler of Penn Hills; James C. McGrath of Arnold, Md.; 10 grandchildren, and six great-grandchildren.
A private memorial service is being planned for a later date.
Memorial donations may be made to the Penn Hills Service Association, 2519 Main St., Penn Hills, Pa. 15235 or: https://www.pittsburghfoodbank.org/agency/penn-hills-service-association.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.