If the admiration and respect of his former students and colleagues were measured in droplets of water, James Cavalier would have been adrift in an ocean.
He was so beloved as the head of school and founder of the Sewickley Academy’s Senior School that Mr. Cavalier’s presence alone drew alumni to many reunions.
A former student of his at Shady Side Academy, where he taught Latin and English for eight years, started a scholarship fund in Mr. Cavalier’s name at Sewickley Academy to show his admiration and love for the man they called “Mr. Cav.”
“I was struggling. I couldn’t see the path forward,” said William F. Lieberman, recalling his teenage years at Shady Side Academy, when Mr. Cavalier taught him Latin and served as his faculty adviser in the 1960s.
“He helped me see the path forward. He was a great mentor, and hundreds of other students felt the same way,” said Mr. Lieberman, the owner of a successful insurance business, vice chairman of the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission and a trustee at the University of Pittsburgh. “He was a model for my life and has affected my life in a big way, and that’s why I started a scholarship in his name at a school I’d never seen or been to.”
Mr. Cavalier, of Sewickley, died Jan. 5 of complications from COVID-19. He was 93.
One of six children of a postal clerk, Mr. Cavalier had a tough upbringing in several Pittsburgh neighborhoods.
He studied classical languages at The Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C., earning a bachelor’s degree in 1950.
He taught briefly at Calvert Hall College High School in Towson, Md., before returning to Pittsburgh in 1955 to teach at Shady Side Academy.
His path to Sewickley Academy was somewhat serendipitous and started during the summer of 1962, when he left the doldrums of summer school in Pittsburgh to serve as a tutor at a boys camp in Maine, run by then-Sewickley Headmaster Cliff Nichols.
“I was sick and tired of teaching school and going to summer school,” Mr. Cavalier recalled in a Sewickley Academy interview four years ago.
Mr. Nichols offered him a chance to develop and launch a senior school at Sewickley Academy, which then only went to ninth grade, Mr. Cavalier said in the interview.
Leaving his job at Shady Side wasn’t an easy decision, said his son-in-law Mark Plotkin, husband of Mr. Cavalier’s daughter Teresa Cavalier.
“He loved Shady Side, he really did,” said Mr. Plotkin, of Bethesda, Md. “He could have been potentially content just teaching English and Latin, but he told me that he saw the opportunity to build something new and big and different — that could touch people’s lives in a way that he couldn’t as a teacher. He could do something on a larger scale that could benefit students outside his classroom.”
The decision wasn’t easy on the students at Shady Side, either, said Mr. Lieberman, who said the 1963 yearbook was dedicated to their former teacher and adviser. In 2013, that graduating class even asked Mr. Cavalier to come to their 50th reunion. He was happy to do so.
When his first class of seniors graduated from Sewickley Academy in 1966, Mr. Cavalier was honored with the “Cavalier Cup,” an award that has since been given to the graduating senior who exemplifies the best scholarship, sportsmanship and citizenship among the senior class.
Mr. Cavalier thrived in the new environment, building an educational program that focused on more than just athletics or academics.
“He loved it. He would get there early and stay late, and he was always attending student events,” Mr. Plotkin said. “He was really a part of the students’ lives, and not just in the classroom. He would often talk to students about their relationships with their parents. He would help with their hardships. He was a holistic educator.”
He was also devoted to economic and racial diversity among the students and faculty, said his daughter Elisa Cavalier, of Sewickley.
“He felt diversity was key,” she said. “He went to Cliff Nichols and talked him into financial aid to help students and help make the student body more diverse. It started with the first class and moved forward.”
In 1984, the school received a generous gift to help bolster that initiative from an unexpected source.
“I hadn’t seen him in 21 years, and I stopped by the school on my way home from a meeting just to say hello. I didn’t even know where Sewickley was,” recalled Mr. Lieberman, who spoke with Mr. Nichols when he was told that Mr. Cavalier was out. “I decided right then and there to set up a scholarship in his name. That became a relationship that we fostered for the next 35 years.”
Mr. Cavalier was so revered among other alumni that when Mr. Lieberman offered to match donations on the occasion of his mentor’s retirement in 1992, the donation goal was satisfied in less than two weeks.
“In those schools, they catered to the athletes and scholars, of which I was neither,” said Mr. Lieberman, a 1965 Shady Side graduate. “He made me feel that I had a lot to offer, and I didn’t always have to be the best there was. He showed me there were other ways I could contribute in my life, and that stayed with me all my life. I hope I lived up to his confidence in me.”
“Dad had this unique ability to make kids want to excel,” Elisa Cavalier said. “They wanted to make him proud, and he took great joy in the students’ accomplishments, whether they were big or small. He had an incredible ability to remember people’s names and details of their lives, way after the fact. It endeared the students and the alumni to him as well, because Dad was always up on what they were doing.”
“A teacher, a leader, an extraordinary philanthropist (a word which finds its roots in the Greek for ‘lover of mankind’), ‘Mr. Cav’ was an extraordinary human being, whose loss we all profoundly feel,” said Kolia O’Connor, current Sewickley Academy head of school, in an online tribute. “‘Mr. Cav’ touched hundreds of students, faculty, staff, and parents who benefited from the wisdom, leadership and guidance he provided over the years.”
After retiring from Sewickley, Mr. Cavalier worked for 10 years as an admissions officer at Carnegie Mellon University.
He received many honors and awards over his storied career, but perhaps the most auspicious came on his 90th birthday in 2017, when the school renamed his former on-campus home the “Cavalier House.” It now serves as headquarters for the school’s advancement office and, notably, alumni relations.
“I think he was constantly surprised anytime that he was feted in one way or another,” his son-in-law Mr. Plotkin said. “He was always genuinely shocked. He couldn’t understand why people were making such a big deal.”
In June 1957, Mr. Cavalier married Jacqueline “Patty” Hartley, a nurse practitioner whom he met while she was caring for his mother at St. Francis Hospital.
In recent years, the couple split their time between their home in Sewickley and a condominium in Naples, Fla., where they loved fishing, golfing and socializing.
Mr. Cavalier also kept in close contact with many of his former students, including Mr. Lieberman, who often met his mentor for lunch before the pandemic. In more recent days, he called Mr. Cavalier several times a week, which kept them both from feelings of isolation, Mr. Lieberman said.
“He was a wonderful man,” Mr. Lieberman said. “He was all of the good things there are in life.”
Along with his wife, two daughters and son-in-law, Mr. Cavalier is survived by his other daughter, Carolyn Cavalier, of Peacham, Vt.; his siblings, Mary Jane Fuller, of Columbia, S.C., Sarah “Sally” Lee, of Santa Barbara, Calif., and Joseph Cavalier, of Lincroft, N.J.; and three granddaughters.
He was preceded in death by his brothers, Anthony “Buddy” and Paul.
A public memorial will be scheduled at a later date.
Memorial contributions may be made to The James E. Cavalier Scholarship Fund at Sewickley Academy, www.Sewickley.org/Cavalier; Sewickley Valley YMCA, 625 Blackburn Road, Sewickley, PA 15143; or Sewickley Public Library, 500 Thorn St., Sewickley, PA 15143.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.