When Paul S. Caplan became a doctor in 1936, medicine was “more of an art than a science.”
Those were his words to the Allegheny County Medical Society during an awards ceremony in 2003, when he explained how much the practice of medicine had changed in his 60-plus years as a physician.
“Ninety percent of the advances in medicine have occurred in my lifetime,” he said. “My generation has lived through extraordinary periods of medical achievements. … I remember an era of no medication for hypertension, no antibiotics, no pneumococcal pneumonia vaccine. I remember waiting for the spontaneous crisis of pneumococcal pneumonia — you would tend a patient’s bedside, and if the fever broke, the patient would live.”
Also a World War II veteran and longtime professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Dr. Caplan, 107, died in his Oakland home on Saturday after a series of recent health setbacks.
Dr. Caplan was born in California, Pa., in 1912, just months after the Titanic sunk on its maiden voyage.
“He actually knew people who fought in the Civil War,” said Dr. Caplan’s friend and business partner, rheumatologist Dr. Terence Starz, who remembered him as “a remarkable person with great caring, great wisdom and great commitment to his patients.”
A childhood encounter with a doctor who made a house call to tend his sick mother changed the trajectory of Dr. Caplan’s life, said his daughter Roberta “Robbie” Caplan, of New York City.
“When my dad was 10 he was impressed with the gentle manner and kindness of this physician, and he decided right then he wanted to be a doctor,” she said. “It made quite an impact on him.”
As a teenager, Dr. Caplan found a love of jazz and especially the trombone, which he continued playing even recently.
“In high school, he wanted to learn the clarinet, but they already gave out the clarinets, so he took the trombone,” his daughter said.
He and a group of friends formed the Caplan Jazz Band and played weddings and bar mitzvahs for extra spending money.
“They got paid very little, but they ate very well, especially at Italian weddings,” Ms. Caplan said.
Dr. Caplan attended Pitt Medical School, where he graduated in 1936, before serving his internship at Montefiore Hospital and his residency at Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital in Boston.
He met Gertrude Forman on a double date, although she wasn’t his date.
“They were on a double date with the wrong people,” his daughter said, laughing.
The couple married in 1942; Mrs. Caplan died in 2006.
Dr. Caplan’s first years as a physician were some of the most harrowing of his life.
He joined the Army in 1942 and by 1944 found himself working as a battalion surgeon for the 83rd Infantry Division in the European theater. He landed on Omaha Beach five days after D-Day in June 1944 and treated soldiers wounded in the offensive. The toughest part was deciding who should be treated on the battlefield — and possibly die — and who would be lucky enough to be evacuated by ambulance, his daughter said.
“In those days, medical care was very rudimentary,” she said. “My dad came back home with a rare French cognac and psychological issues.”
But, the war also gave Dr. Caplan a special perspective about the connection between the brain and body when it came to illness.
Once, when he was treating a man who complained of non-heart-related chest pain, Dr. Caplan deduced that he was actually suffering from PTSD — although it wasn’t recognized as such at the time — from the war, when the patient had been taken prisoner by the Germans and chained to a tree.
“My father was the Sherlock Holmes of the body; he was a real investigator,” Ms. Caplan said. “When he told the patient, he and his wife and my dad hugged each other and laughed and cried. He said it was one of the best days of his career.”
“One of the remarkable things about him is that he looked at the whole person,” said Dr. Starz, who was a partner in Dr. Caplan’s Oakland-based practice for 35 years and looked upon him as a father figure. “He listened to his patients — really listened — and educated so many of us on taking care of the whole person.”
“They don’t make doctors like him anymore,” said his daughter, who recalled a grant her father received in the late 1950s from the National Institutes of Health to study osteoarthritis among coal miners.
“It became the definitive study that enabled coal miners to get disability payments,” she said. “My father had an impact on humanity in his own humble way.”
For more than 20 years, Dr. Caplan traveled with the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra around the world as its tour physician, and he maintained his practice, Arthritis and Diagnostic Associates, until he was 96 years old. He was honored with numerous accolades and awards during his long career.
His secret to longevity? Do something you love, Dr. Starz said.
“He was a model physician who dedicated his life to providing the best care he could to his patients,” he said. “His work really was his hobby.”
Dr. Caplan was also a beloved patriarch of his family, Ms. Caplan said.
“He was wonderful, he was impish, he was funny, he was kind, and he was tender,” she said.
In his speech to the medical society, Dr. Caplan reminded his colleagues that compassion is the touchstone of a good physician.
“Medicine is still the relationship of a suffering human being with a healer,” he said. “It is a rare gift to care for the sick. I am fortunate to be a member of this noble profession.”
Along with his daughter Roberta, Dr. Caplan is survived by another daughter, Donna Hersh, of Orange, Conn.; four grandchildren; and four great-grandchildren. He was preceded in death by his brother Joseph Caplan.
His funeral was private.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.