This quintessential story of the Great American Experience begins in Cleveland, ends in Franklin Park and bulges in the middle with tales of hard work, perseverance, religious piety and baseline family values. James F. O’Day Sr., who retired in 1997 as a vice president at Pittsburgh National Bank, died Thursday, surrounded by his extended family. He was 87.
The eldest son of a working-class Irish immigrant father and American mother, Mr. O’Day distinguished himself at an early age as a high school class officer, honor roll student and center on his Catholic school’s championship football team. He attended Duquesne University in Pittsburgh on a football scholarship in an era when the Dukes had a premier program. Decades later. he was inducted in the university’s Sports Hall of Fame.
“He was always an athlete, even later in life when he kept himself in shape and played tennis,” said Peter Kalis, a Pittsburgh attorney and Mr. O’Day’s son-in-law. “It was part of a work ethic he adhered to even after retirement.”
At Duquesne’s School of Business Administration, Mr. O’Day made the dean’s list, led his fraternity and an intra-fraternity council and achieved the rank of cadet colonel in the Army ROTC. After college, he was commissioned a second lieutenant in the 3rd Armored Cavalry Regiment and served as an Army artillery liaison officer in the Korean War.
Following an honorable discharge in 1954, he attended Case Western Reserve University Law School, where he worked as associate editor of the law review. In 1957, he was wed to Mary Elizabeth Gibson of Leetonia, Ohio. The couple had seven children and the marriage lasted until her death in 2010.
“Jim’s greatest legacy is his extraordinary family,” said Mr. Kalis, who married Mr. O’Day’s oldest daughter in 1990. “I have very powerful memories of dinners with the O’Day family and conversations about sports and politics that could be described as a contact sport, but ended with a lot of shared love and respect.”
Mr. O’Day taught his family to adhere to core values, said Mr. Kalis. His strong belief in family structure included firm ideas about who was included in the family.
“Every year, the O’Days would have a family photo taken,” Mr. Kalis said. “When I started dating his daughter, he made it very clear that I would not be in the photo until we got married. But I could take the photo. There wasn’t a phony bone in his body.”
Mr. O’Day was employed as an attorney in Cleveland with the New York Central Railroad, National Castings Co. and Cleveland Trust Co. In 1970, the family moved to Pittsburgh when he was recruited as vice president of governmental affairs by Pittsburgh National Bank. He retired as senior vice president in 1997.
He also served as a member the Duquesne University board of directors, chaired its athletic committee and was given the Father McAnulty Service Award for his longtime dedication to the university.
Mr. Kalis remembers his father-in-law as a Renaissance man — a devout Roman Catholic, avid reader, enthusiastic New Deal Democrat and devoted family man.
“He would return from trips and always find time to take his sons to North Park to teach them to play tennis,” he said. “In later years, he took great pride in his grandchildren, keeping up the family tradition of being active and achieving on many fronts. They repaid that love as well. The family, top to bottom, regard themselves as being very lucky to have had him as a parent or grandparent.”
Mr. O’Day is survived by his children, Mary M. O’Day of Naples, Fla., and McCandless; Jim O’Day Jr. of the St. Louis area; Nancy Eichenlaub of Pine; John O’Day of Charleston, S.C.; Ann Heinauer of Fox Chapel; and twins Michael O’Day of Fox Chapel and Thomas O’Day of McCandless; 18 grandchildren and two great-grandchildren.
Visitors will be received 3-7 p.m. Monday at McCabe Brothers Inc. Funeral Home, 6214 Walnut St., Shadyside.
A Mass of Christian Burial will be held 10:30 a.m. Tuesday at the Chapel of the Holy Spirit at Duquesne University, 600 Forbes Ave., Uptown, followed by interment at Holy Savior Cemetery in Richland.
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.