Thomas A. Livingston was recognized as the go-to criminal defense attorney in Pittsburgh for decades. He was known for never letting his clients cooperate or take the stand but also for his eloquent closing arguments in which he spoke of his admiration for the Constitution.

Former U.S. District Judge Don Ziegler, joking at a continuing legal education workshop, once said that Mr. Livingston probably had more not-guilty verdicts by himself than the entire roomful of lawyers combined.

He might not have been kidding: Mr. Livingston once won 10 consecutive not-guilty federal jury verdicts.

Mr. Livingston, of Nevillewood, died Saturday at UPMC Presbyterian after a short illness. He was 88.

Advertise with us

Although he retired in the early 1990s, Mr. Livingston’s reputation as a zealous advocate for his clients continues to be shared with young law students and new attorneys in the Pittsburgh community.

Allegheny County Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning, who teaches some of those students from Duquesne University, was a young federal prosecutor when he went up against Mr. Livingston in court.

He recalled perfectly tailored suits, French cuffs and fancy cuff links.

But it was spell-binding closings that made Mr. Livingston a mentor to him.

“Sometimes, they were bamboozling,” the judge said. “And often he wouldn’t even talk about the facts. He would tell me, ‘I don’t need to talk about the facts. They really don’t do me any good.’”

Advertise with us

Judge Manning described Mr. Livingston as extremely polite with an incredible intellect.

“He could quote Karl Menninger and Yogi Berra in the same sentence,” Judge Manning said.

Mr. Livingston tried many high-profile cases in Pittsburgh, representing mobsters, a county detective; numerous local and state officials and magistrate judges.

He also ran for mayor of the city of Pittsburgh in 1973 against Pete Flaherty, with whom he had once been great friends, and then later reconnected in retirement.

The two were at the 1968 Democratic Convention in Chicago as advance men for Hubert Humphrey, Mr. Livingston’s son, Patrick, said.

Advertise with us

After the failed bid for mayor, Patrick said, his father, who grew up in the Hill District but raised his family in Brookline, returned to the courtroom.

“It’s completely where he belonged,” said his son, who also is a lawyer.

The last case his father tried had to happen twice. The first time, when he represented Thomas J. Reilly, who was accused of bilking thousands of investors in the Seven Fields real estate Ponzi scheme in Butler County, the case ended in a hung jury, with 10 jurors voting not guilty.

In the retrial, Mr. Reilly was found guilty and sentenced to prison.

Judge Ziegler said Mr. Livingston was the best defense attorney in Pittsburgh by far.

Advertise with us

“He was just head and shoulders above any lawyer who appeared before me,” he said. “Tom was just at an entirely different level. The eloquence of his arguments are unmatched today.”

Both Judge Ziegler and Judge Manning remembered Mr. Livingston for his closing arguments in which he’d draw parallels with the Constitution and how it protects Americans from totalitarian government.

“He’d try to wrap the flag around the jurors — ‘this is us against the government,’ ” Judge Manning said. “‘We are a government of laws.’ ”

Judge Ziegler remembered the same, quoting the lawyer who tried more than 25 cases in his courtroom: “‘In the Soviet Union, the people have Lenin under glass,’ ” Mr. Livingston would say. “‘In the United States, the people have a Constitution under glass.’ ”

In addition to his son, Patrick, Mr. Livingston is survived by sons, Terrance, of Chicago and Thomas, of Brookline; and daughters Kathleen Azar, of Upper St. Clair, and Ann Margo Livingston, of Pittsburgh; as well as seven grandchildren.

Advertise with us

Visitation will be from 6 to 8 p.m. Tuesday and from 2 to 4 and 6 to 8 p.m. Wednesday at William Slater II Funeral Service at 1650 Greentree Road, Scott, 15220.

A Mass of Christian burial will be held at 10 a.m. on Thursday at St. Barbara Church, 45 Prestley Road, Bridgeville.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.