“Nick the Blade” died last week after he suffered a heart attack at a Florida bar while drinking his usual pinot grigio.

For Eugene Gesuale, a 6-foot-4, 250-pound East Liberty drug dealer for the Mafia once seen on surveillance snorting cocaine with one hand and urinating off a balcony with the other, it was a refined way to go at age 73.

“I was surprised he was nursing such a girly drink,” said Roger Greenbank, the retired FBI agent who helped send him to federal prison for 28 years during the Mafia crackdown of the 1980s. “Would have thought something more macho would have been his style.”

He died July 28 after collapsing at the Past Times Restaurant and Bar in Ormond Beach near Daytona.

Advertise with us

Gesuale, who was released from prison two years ago on a drug and tax sentence imposed in 1986, had deep Pittsburgh roots but relocated to Florida, where he also had once been active in the drug underworld. He didn’t exactly hide; he gave an interview to a gangster website and posed in a loud purple shirt sitting on the back of a high-end car.

It was typical posturing for a man who once lived in a $1,200-a-month Highland Park penthouse under an assumed name, wore Gucci shoes, drove a Jaguar (registered to his mother), bought girlfriends fancy gifts at New York boutiques, dined at the best restaurants and always flew first-class.

Quick with a knife, he had been arrested numerous times for assault but was never convicted.

“He was the ultimate thug,” said Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Manning, who prosecuted Gesuale as first assistant U.S. attorney.

Gesuale, Mr. Greenbank said, had “absolutely no redeeming qualities.”

Advertise with us

Gesuale’s older brother, Anthony, 75, who lives in Ohio, said he had distanced himself from his younger brother while Eugene was behind bars but disputed the FBI’s version of Eugene’s life. He said his brother was ruined by using drugs and that he was set up by informants.

“It’s a terrible thing, drugs,” he said. “It all boils down to drugs. He was a victim of the drugs.”

He said prior to getting involved with cocaine, Eugene was a successful hairdresser in Squirrel Hill. He also said his brother had been a good student when they went to Catholic high school together in Los Angeles.

But he said the drug life consumed Eugene and he became an addict. Even in prison, he said, Eugene was using drugs but he never got the help for addiction that he needed.

As for his criminal life, Anthony said Eugene was not the evil man the FBI said he was and that his sentence was harsher than sentences given to other people, even those convicted of murder.

Advertise with us

“He never killed anyone,” he said. “Yes, he may have stabbed a few people, but those were neighborhood disputes. It’s unjustifiable what they did to him.”

Federal officials said Gesuale got what he deserved, however.

As prosecutors here and across the U.S. pursued the Mafia in the 1980s, Gesuale was their first big local catch.

But getting him wasn’t easy.

Just prior to Gesuale’s indictment on drug charges in 1984, FBI secretary Jacqueline Wymard leaked information about the case to her boyfriend, mobster John Carrabba, who tipped off Gesuale’s cronies. He disappeared.

Advertise with us

He was indicted in 1985 with five associates, including Pagans motorcycle gang leader Dan “Deacon” Zwibel and a Pittsburgh Press truck driver, Roy Ingold, who would later testify against him.

After Ingold went to prison, he told agents Gesuale was in Jamaica, where federal marshals and the FBI eventually tracked him down. Authorities flew him back to Pittsburgh on a Learjet in July 1986. He was convicted later that year.

Gesuale was never a true member of the Pittsburgh La Cosa Nostra. Rather, he was an LCN associate, dealing coke on a massive scale for the Pittsburgh family run by John LaRocca and Mike Genovese and in cahoots with Zwibel.

Gesuale ran a prostitution ring in New York’s Little Italy and assorted other enterprises, often with mob enforcer John Leone as his muscle and Genovese associate Charles Porter as his protection.

He also supplied coke from Colombia to New York mobsters through his partner Paul Mazzei, the “Pittsburgh connection” portrayed in the movie “Goodfellas.” The producers took some liberties on that one; while the character was based on Gesuale’s narcissistic personality, it was actually Mazzei who was involved in the Boston College basketball point-shaving scheme and had the ties to Henry Hill and New York’s Lucchese crime family. Gesuale was the drug supplier, the FBI said.

Advertise with us

Gesuale grew up in the Larimer area, the son of a Bell Telephone worker. He dropped out of Central Catholic High School in the 10th grade, finished high school in Los Angeles, where he lived for a time with one of his sisters, and later attended Pittsburgh Beauty Academy to become a hairdresser.

But he also ran wild in East Liberty. By the 1960s, he was dealing heroin, according to the FBI, Pittsburgh police and the former Pennsylvania Crime Commission.

He proved a smart and slippery target for law enforcement. In the “Lebanese Connection” case in 1973, a federal grand jury accused him and 10 others of smuggling heroin into Pittsburgh from Beirut. But a federal judge tossed the case, saying there wasn’t enough evidence.

City police repeatedly arrested him for assaults in the 1970s and ’80s, including a brawl in Shadyside, a shooting in a Downtown parking lot, and an attempt to kill a man by running him over with his car. Each time, the victims refused to cooperate and the charges were dropped.

John LaRocca, the mob boss here for many years, was once asked why he kept someone around as volatile as Gesuale.

Advertise with us

“He keeps the heat off of us,” he replied.

Gesuale’s life of crime and his high-living finally ground to a halt in the 1980s, when the U.S. attorney’s office brought its case, which included engaging in a continuing criminal enterprise, the most serious federal drug offense.

Mr. Manning, who tried the case with Assistant U.S. Attorney Bruce Teitelbaum, summed up his target this way to the jury: “He is a hustler, a gambler, a spendthrift, a man with a violent temper, and a man with expensive taste.”

Five days into the trial, Gesuale decided to plead guilty. U.S. District Judge Donald Ziegler sentenced him to 45 years, but that was in the days of parole. He was released on Oct. 31, 2014.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette or 412-944-6551