Patrick Gallagher, an anthropology professor who created an academic flap at George Washington University in the 1960s with a proposal to abolish grades, died July 31 of congestive heart failure at his home in Fort Bragg, Calif. He was 76.

After joining the GWU faculty in 1961, Mr. Gallagher quickly built a reputation as a popular lecturer and was named chairman of the anthropology department. In January 1968, the 475 freshmen in his introductory anthropology course burst into applause when he said he would award all of them an A for the fall semester.

Then he announced plans to give an F to each of the 100 upperclassmen in his psychological anthropology class. The resulting furor reached the front page of The Washington Post and was immediately taken up by a committee of the GWU Faculty Senate.

Mr. Gallagher's ultimate goal was to abolish what he considered an arbitrary grading system because, he told The Post, grades "get in the way" of true education.

Advertise with us

"People are out after grades," he said. He believed a university should concentrate on teaching students how to conduct their lives in a "reasonable and enjoyable way."

After being summoned before the faculty committee, Mr. Gallagher backed down and abandoned his all-or-nothing grading plan. He agreed to evaluate his students "within the existing grade system," and in return the committee promised to explore alternatives to the university's grading practices.

"We are united entirely as far as the goal is concerned: the philosophy of grading and its relationship to education," he said at the time.

In the end, his students received traditional grades according to the university's established scale. But less than two weeks after the imbroglio began, Mr. Gallagher resigned. Whether he quit voluntarily or was forced out by university officials remains in doubt.

Mr. Gallagher was born in Wilkinsburg, Pa., and served in the Navy before attending the University of Pittsburgh. He received a fellowship to Yale University and did research on the Guajira Indians in Venezuela and later published a book about them. He received his doctorate in anthropology from Yale in 1961.

Advertise with us

After his abbreviated career at GWU, Mr. Gallagher taught at several other colleges, including Davis & Elkins in West Virginia.

Late in his teaching career, he was in a serious car accident that left him in a coma. After his recovery, he wrote and lectured about his near-death experience and took up Zen meditation.

Correction/Clarification: (Published Aug. 17, 2006) This Washington Post obituary of Patrick Gallagher that appeared in Aug. 14, 2006 editions gave an incorrect date for his death, which was July 31. Also, he received his doctorate from Yale University in 1961, not 1964, and his daughter's name is Lisa Gallagher.