WASHINGTON — Pennsylvania dairy farmers are applauding a recent international trade dispute victory and hoping the decision will be a boon for one of the nation’s top milk-producing states.
The U.S. was issued a win late last month when a panel ruled that Canada violated its trade obligations with the U.S. by not allowing the promised amount of American milk, cheeses, ice cream and other dairy products over its borders duty-free for Canadian consumers.

“I was very skeptical that Canada was going to comply with the dairy policies because history would tell you that they are extremely protective of it. When I first saw [the decision] I was like ‘wow we actually got that?’” said Glenn Stoltzfus, a dairy farmer in Berlin, Pa.
The three-person panel adjudicating whether Canada broke the rules under the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Trade Agreement concluded that the northern country was giving preferential treatment to its own dairy processors and shutting out other parts of the supply chain, like distributors and retailers.
“What that looks like is rather than being able to sell to the full range of eager buyers in the Canadian market, U.S. cheese companies or fluid milk companies here in the U.S. were forced to sell to their competitors,” said Shawna Morris, a trade policy expert for the National Milk Producers Federation and the U.S. Dairy Export Council, who described Canada’s policy as “protectionist.”
“Frankly, one of the main agricultural benefits of USMCA was the expanded dairy access,” she said.
Read More
Canada disagrees with the U.S. interpretation of how the tariff quotas should be allocated under the trade agreement.
Canada’s Global Affairs office did not respond to a media inquiry. The Canadian Dairy Commission declined to comment.
The U.S., however, hailed the decision as a “historic win” that “will help eliminate unjustified trade restrictions on American dairy products, and will ensure that the U.S. dairy industry and its workers get the full benefit of the USMCA,” U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai said in a January press release.
While Mr. Stoltzfus’ 700-cow farm in Somerset County mostly ships its milk south to markets in Maryland and Virginia, the dairy farmer anticipates that further opening the door to Canada will increase overall demand.
“I'm in a wait-and-see mode,” he said. “I was pleasantly surprised at this ruling.”

Pennsylvania is among the top 10 milk producing states in the nation, according to U.S. Department of Agriculture figures for 2020.
The Commonwealth is home to between 5,400 and 7,000 dairy farms, with about 500,000 cows; the exact figures fluctuate depending on the source.
Pennsylvania’s dairy industry accounts for $12.6 billion of direct and indirect economic activity annually and supports roughly 52,000 jobs, according to the state and the Harrisburg-based Center for Dairy Excellence.
Despite the number of farms being on the downward trend, milk production has actually increased, according to the center, which estimates that each cow produces about 2,500 gallons of milk per year.
The center cites milk price volatility, land availability and access to milk markets as the main challenges for Pennsylvania’s dairy farmers, but overall it projects positive market trends as large companies build milk-processing facilities in the Northeast region of the U.S.
Yvette Longenecker is a partner in a Blair County-based dairy cooperative that milks 2,000 cows three times a day. Large tanker trucks make daily stops at Ms. Longenecker’s three farm sites, operated under the name Penn England LLC, to haul away gallons upon gallons of milk to regional facilities run by the Minnesota-based Land O’Lakes Inc.
A Land O’Lakes plant in Carlisle, Pa., produces butter, dry milk products and liquid dairy products, including condensed milk and coffee creamer, according to Dairy Foods’ USA plant directory.
“When Canada, if they actually comply with the USMCA ruling, starts accepting more of an open import of dairy products, then that just creates more of a demand for American milk, which helps our milk prices,” Ms. Longenecker said. “It's expensive to run a dairy farm, and we really rely on good milk prices to turn a profit.”
Ms. Morris’ organizations, which lobby for opening more international markets for U.S. dairy, estimates that one in every seven gallons of milk from the nation’s more than 34,000 dairy farms becomes a dairy product destined for a foreign market — up to 150 countries.
U.S. dairy exports reached $6.5 billion in 2020 — a growth of 9% year over year — “despite significant challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic and ongoing trade policy issues with Canada and China,” according to the USDA.
Mexico, Canada and China were the top three markets last year, accounting for about 45% of sales. The department noted growth in Southeast Asia, with dairy shipments to the region up 25% over 2019, as demand for skimmed milk powder grew in the Philippines and Indonesia.
Canada has until February to comply with the ruling.
The USMCA was enacted in July 2020, replacing the North America Free Trade Agreement.
Ashley Murray: amurray@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.