Criticism of the Senate health care bill raised by advocacy groups for the elderly and industry associations that serve senior consumers are part of what has thwarted Republican leaders’ efforts to move the legislation forward.
Powerhouse lobbyists such as AARP, the American Medical Association and nursing home provider groups have been joined by smaller outfits like the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys and National Adult Day Services Association in raising concerns about one or both of two potential impacts on older adults: higher insurance premiums and Medicaid funding changes that could reduce access to and quality of care for frail individuals in nursing homes and the community.
Aside from analysis by the Congressional Budget Office and others of how people just shy of Medicare age could expect to pay thousands of dollars more annually to buy private health insurance than under the Affordable Care Act, 112 organizations joined in paid advertising criticizing proposed caps on Medicaid funding.
AARP has led much of the lobbying, summarizing in a letter to senators its contention that “premiums and out-of pocket costs for 50-64 year olds buying their own insurance would skyrocket, Medicaid coverage for millions of seniors and people with disabilities would be at risk and the fiscal sustainability of Medicare would be weakened.”
Just before the announcement at midday Tuesday that Senate leaders were delaying action on the Better Care Reconciliation Act, the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation released its assessment that the bill would raise health insurance premiums an average of 74 percent over three years for those using the government exchange, with people ages 55 to 64 particularly affected.
Individuals in that age group would see premiums more than double for the most common silver plan, up 115 percent to $583 from $271, according to the California-based foundation. Those with incomes below 200 percent of the federal poverty level would be hardest hit by subsidy changes, with premiums rising to $272 from $69 for silver plan coverage — or 294 percent higher than at present.
Read More
The biggest impact on older adults’ premiums comes from allowing insurers to charge them five times as much as younger adults pay, as opposed to a 3-to-1 limit under Obamacare.
“I’ve never seen legislation like this,” said Kaiser president and CEO Drew Altman. “It’s unprecedented.”
Premium increases wouldn’t be the only worry. Kaiser senior vice president Larry Levitt said the average deductible would rise to $6,100 under the bill, up from $3,600 under the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare.
The potential for such changes has worried middle-age consumers such as Suzanne Meyer, 52, of Edgewood, who had to quit a full-time job that provided health insurance coverage to care for her ill husband, Jeremy, who has since died.
She paid $420 monthly under the Affordable Care Act for a policy purchased on the government exchange to cover her, him and their two children. As a self-employed marketing consultant, she fears the potential impact of the Senate’s current bill.
“My business has gone very well,” Ms. Meyer said, “but I just don’t know that I could carry those kinds of costs. I don’t know how people are going to do it.”
The legislation’s impact on Medicaid funding is not as quick and direct in affecting older adults, but has drawn widespread criticism nonetheless. The program has long been a shared federal-state entitlement providing nursing home care for the low- to- moderate-income elderly and for younger disabled individuals, with the federal share amounting to 52 percent in Pennsylvania. But senior advocates and the long-term care industry alike fear that that guarantee is jeopardized.
Republicans looking to repeal Obamacare have added cost controls that would cap Medicaid funding to the states in an unprecedented manner. The change would limit increases in spending to inflation-rated adjustments that drop the potential payments over time. The Congressional Budget Office estimates the cap would send $772 billion less to states than would otherwise be the case over the next decade, and the gap would get even wider thereafter.
Nursing homes represent only a small part of overall Medicaid funding, but the program covers 63 percent of overall spending on nursing home care in Pennsylvania, with the rest coming from higher-paying Medicare and private pay residents in the 89,000 beds statewide.
The Medicaid reimbursement rate averaging $198 per day already falls well short of what facilities need to provide quality care, and it has not gone up in most recent years because the state has funneled any additional dollars for long-term care into home and community-based services, according to Russell McDaid, president of the Pennsylvania Health Care Association. The association is the lead group representing for-profit nursing homes in the state.
Under the proposed limits on Medicaid funding, he said, “reimbursements will fall even further behind inflation, fall further behind costs. ... I don’t think it’s irresponsible to say that if this goes forward as currently proposed, facilities would be forced to close beds in part or in their entirety and turn over the keys and say, ‘Here, state — here, federal government — you figure out how to make this work at the numbers you’re giving me.’”
Marc Stier, director of the left-leaning Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center, said the worst impact of such cuts is compounded by the fact that they would come when the size of the oldest-old population in need of care is surging a decade from now. The cuts could also jeopardize the growth of those Medicaid-funded home and community services that help people avoid more expensive nursing homes, Mr. Stier noted.
“The state would have to change eligibility rules or benefit levels,” affecting numerous needy people because the state would lack any additional funds of its own to make up for federal shortfalls, he said.
Gary Rotstein: grotstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1255; Kris B. Mamula: kmamula@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1699.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.