Lawyers for Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh and other faith-based groups say their employees could get coverage for birth control under the Affordable Care Act without trampling on the agencies’ religious opposition to having any role in providing some or all contraception.
“There are many ways in which the employees of a (faith-based employer) with an insured plan could receive cost-free contraceptive coverage through the same insurance company that would not require further involvement by the (employer),” said the brief filed Tuesday with the U.S. Supreme Court. “And each one of those ways is a less restrictive alternative that dooms the government’s ongoing effort to use the threat of massive penalties to compel petitioners to forsake their sincerely held religious beliefs.”
But government representatives say that while they could bend a little more in accommodating religious objections, such changes probably wouldn’t satisfy everyone and would lead to “years of additional litigation, during which tens of thousands of women would likely continue to be denied the coverage to which they are legally entitled.”
The arguments were filed Tuesday with the Supreme Court after it called for additional briefs in the agencies’ pending challenge to the contraception mandate in Obamacare — an unusual request after the parties had already made oral arguments before the court last month.
Pittsburgh Roman Catholic Bishop David Zubik, representing Catholic Charities of Pittsburgh, is the lead plaintiff among several agencies that made similar arguments in cases that were consolidated for purposes of the Supreme Court case.
All of the parties involved represent faith-based institutions such as charities or schools — also including faith-based charities in the Diocese of Erie as well as the Presbyterian-affiliated Geneva College in Beaver Falls — which are arguing on religious grounds against a provision involving contraceptives in the Affordable Care Act. The act requires that female employees be provided free contraceptive devices and counseling. Lower courts have issued conflicting opinions.
Read More
The act does exempt strictly religious institutions such as churches, but it treats religiously affiliated charities and schools differently. The administration allows faith-based charities to opt out by submitting their objection in writing.
But since that opt-out form would trigger the insurance companies themselves providing the free contraceptives, Bishop Zubik and other representatives of these faith-based groups contend this “hijacks” their insurance plans and makes them complicit in providing what they consider a moral evil. The Catholic groups object to artificial contraception in general, the Protestants mainly to those that they fear could cause early abortions.
A brief suggesting alternatives was filed jointly by the law firm of Jones Day, representing Bishop Zubik, and attorneys for the other agencies challenging the mandate.
It argues that a religious employer could simply buy an insurance policy that does not include contraceptive coverage, without submitting an opt-out notice. The insurer, recognizing this gap in coverage, could then inform the employees directly of their option of getting a second policy with the sole purpose of providing contraceptives for free.
The brief also contended that this wouldn’t affect many workers because such faith-based agencies are “are more likely to hire individuals who share their religious beliefs and are thus less likely to opt for coverage that violates those shared religious beliefs.”
But U.S. Solicitor General Donald Verrilli Jr. argued that the government has already accommodated religious groups by requiring no more than a simple opt-out notice.
He said that while the court could remove the opt-out requirement, doing so would come at “a real cost.”
He added: “The self-certification process was adopted with broad support from (people commenting on the plan while it was drafted) because it provides clarity and certainty for all parties whose rights and duties are affected by the accommodation, including the objecting employers.”
The court, he said, “should definitively resolve the issue rather than allowing the current uncertainty to continue.”
Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.