Pittsburgh Catholic Bishop David A. Zubik said his first trip to the U.S. Supreme Court on Wednesday contained a couple of surprises: How small the crowded courtroom was and the intensity of the justices’ questions.

He was not, however, surprised by how serious the justices were as they listened to arguments in the Diocese of Pittsburgh’s lawsuit challenging the contraception provision of the federal government’s Affordable Care Act.

“When some of the justices posed their questions, they really needed clarification in their own minds, and if they didn’t feel that they received it the first time around, they kept on hitting at it,” the bishop said in remarks upon his return from Washington, D.C., at Pittsburgh International Airport. “They would say, ‘I still don’t see what you mean,’ and they would ask for further clarifications, which I felt was a plus sign. They came in with a willingness to really listen to what the arguments were.”

The issue, Bishop Zubik said, is religious freedom and the First Amendment to the Constitution.

Advertise with us

“This is a complex case, and an awful lot of people want to make it simple,” he said. “It isn’t just about contraception. That’s the secondary element. The primary aspect of the case is the issue of religious freedom. The concern is that it appears that the government is beginning to say, ‘We’ll determine what religion is. Religion is anything you do by way of worship within the four walls of a mosque or a synagogue or a temple or a church. Once you step outside that, then we’ll make the decision about whether that’s religion or not.’ And I think that’s the concern.”

Bishop Zubik said he could not predict how the eight justices would rule, but added, “I don’t think it’s going to be a slam-dunk decision for either side.”

Attorneys for the diocese advised the bishop that there are a number of possible outcomes.

“The expectation is that, given the import of the case, their decision probably will not be announced until near the end of the session,” he said. ”Our legal team said it could be referred back to the lower courts. Or they could hold it over and hear it again next year when they have nine justices. But that, too, is speculation.”

He said he took some comfort in learning that the justices are expected to convene by themselves to discuss the matter on the morning of Good Friday.

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com and 412-263-1456.