MARSHALLTOWN, Iowa — This year’s presidential race has already pushed the “Iowa nice” boundaries that once governed politics in the caucuses, but the Trump-Fox-Cruz social media smackdown made it clear it’s off the rails.

The two front-runners in the Republican caucuses here, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz and businessman Donald Trump, are running as political outsiders. But with Mr. Trump again shaking up a race with polls swinging widely between them, they’re also increasingly on the outs with each other in a place where neighborliness that transcends even sharp political disagreements is a hallmark.

Mr. Trump said Tuesday evening that he was dropping out of a Thursday evening debate in Des Moines because broadcaster Fox News was “playing games” by having Megyn Kelly moderate. He called Ms. Kelly, who sharply questioned Mr. Trump about sexism during a debate last year, a “third-rate reporter,” and said he’d hold a fundraiser for wounded veterans rather than attend.

The move is bound to displease some Iowans. “I’m going to the debate and want to see him,” said Paul Waddell, an undecided Des Moines Republican. “He doesn’t give us the individual attention you get from other candidates.”

Advertise with us

Indeed, Mr. Trump has preferred the kind of staged political rallies more common in a general election. A Tuesday evening event in Marshalltown filled a large high school gym with a couple of thousand people, who were treated to a Van Halen look-alike band in the parking lot, playing its own version of “Jump.” (“Might as well Trump!”)

“The way he’s running the campaign is nothing close to the ground game we’re used to seeing here,” said Tim Hagle, a political science professor at the University of Iowa. “It just throws a question mark over everything.”

Mr. Trump’s debate boycott is a case in point, Mr. Hagle said. On one hand, “people in Iowa have been watching debates [held elsewhere], but the fact that he isn’t there when Iowa gets to shine isn’t good.” Then again, “many Trump supporters are going to be first-time caucus-goers, and you have to get them excited. Maybe this does that: There’s Trump, putting his thumb in the eye of the media.”

But Mr. Trump’s chief rival wasted no time in calling him out. In an email to supporters, Mr. Cruz asked, "[I]f you can’t face Megyn Kelly, how can you stand up to ISIS?” He proposed a debate “mano-a-mano, me and Donald, with no moderators,” as his campaign began pushing the hashtag #DonaldDuck on Twitter.

Mr. Trump told his Marshalltown audience that Mr. Cruz is a “nasty” person who “isn't endorsed ... by one United States senator, and he works with them every day.”

Advertise with us

For an outsider, that may sound like a strange line of attack. But although Mr. Trump has upended the rulebook on campaigning itself, there are Iowa traditions even he has left untouched. “I’m totally pro-ethanol, which Ted Cruz is not,” he told the crowd, referring to the federal Renewable Fuel Standard. The program mandates that the corn-based alternative fuel be mixed with gasoline, and thus subsidizes markets for Iowa farmers.

Mr. Cruz’s opposition to ethanol earned a sharp rebuke from Gov. Terry Branstad, a Republican who took the unusual step of telling Iowans it would be “a big mistake” to support Mr. Cruz in next week’s caucuses. But some conservatives laud Mr. Cruz’s willingness to defy others on principle.

“I’m not against ethanol, but if it can’t make it on its own, it’s not worth doing,” said Steve Baker, 47, a plant manager who attended a Cruz event Tuesday in Osceola. Mr. Trump “isn’t all bad, but he’s not telling the truth by making Cruz out to be anti-farmer.”

“The conservative fear is that [Mr. Trump] will make deals — on [abortion], on the Constitution, on everything,” said Bob Vander Plaats, a prominent Iowa evangelical who is backing Mr. Cruz.

There are few such doubts about Mr. Cruz, who played a key part in fomenting the 2013 government shutdown. On the campaign trail too, he seems even less interested than Mr. Trump in making political accommodation.

Advertise with us

As he has done previously, on Tuesday night, Mr. Trump praised Ronald Reagan’s willingness to work alongside former Democratic House Speaker “Tip” O’Neill. By contrast, earlier that day Mr. Cruz said Mr. Reagan had outmaneuvered Mr. O’Neill by appealing directly to the public with his conservative views. He also lauded Mr. Reagan for running against Gerald Ford in the 1976 primary against the wishes of some party leaders. “Washington despised Ronald Reagan,” he said. “If you see a candidate embraced by Washington, run and hide.”

And unlike the campaign style of Donald Trump, Mr. Cruz’s Iowa approach has been very traditional, relying heavily on the kind of rural bus stop campaigning for which Iowa is famous.

“Cruz is the only Republican really doing that this year, and it’s a smart way to campaign,” said Pat Rynard, a veteran politico who runs the politics blog Iowa Starting Line. “Especially in rural counties, it’s a big event when somebody like that comes through.”

More moderate candidates such as former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, meanwhile, have paid far less attention to the state. “It’s like they’ve got it in their minds that only a social conservative can win in Iowa, so they may as well not try,” Mr. Rynard said. That leaves voters weighing candidates not just on the basis of what they say, but how they say it.

Marshalltown resident Linda Lamport said she was weighing a choice between Mr. Trump and the legendarily soft-spoken Ben Carson. Issues such as immigration were important to her, she said, and Mr. Trump “does have energy.” Although he and Mr. Carson are “saying the same thing,” she said, “one says it louder than the other.”

Advertise with us

Monday’s caucuses could depend on how she and other voters interpret his silence Thursday night.

“I think it’s stupid of him not to go,” Mr. Waddell said. “But he’s done so many weird things that have actually worked out. Maybe he has a plan.”

Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.