OSCEOLA, Iowa — In an ordinary winter, the Oswald family’s High Point barn would be preparing for its February sale of Angus beef. But Tuesday morning, the barn hosted a different sort of cattle call.
Standing alongside former Texas Gov. Rick Perry and Iowa Congressman Steve King, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz sought the support of some 100 Iowans seated on hay bales and bleachers. And he joked that the location had much in common with the nation’s capital.
“There’s more than a little cow manure there,” Mr. Cruz said. “People shovel it quite a bit.”
Such appearances are taking place throughout Iowa before Monday night’s caucus, when Iowans will appear at nearly 1,700 precincts to back their champion … and get the 2016 presidential election underway.
The Oswald barn itself was one of seven stops for Mr. Cruz on Tuesday, and he was only one of nine candidates in Iowa. Marshalltown, Iowa (population just under 28,000), was set for visits from three: Republicans Donald Trump and Marco Rubio and Democrat Hillary Clinton. Pittsburgh would have to be visited by 32 presidential candidates to receive that much attention on a per-capita basis.
Meanwhile, escalating his off-and-on feud with the Fox News Channel and throwing the GOP campaign into turmoil, Mr. Trump on Tuesday bowed out of the final Republican presidential debate before the leadoff Iowa caucuses, saying Fox News moderator Megyn Kelly is “a lightweight.”
Read More
Even Iowans sometimes express bemusement over how much significance a state with 3.1 million people has.
“The Iowa caucus is an essentially meaningless event with tremendous political impact,” said Dennis Goldford, a political science professor at Des Moines’ Drake University. “It’s about as scientific as asking people around the dinner table who they support.”
Outsiders, meanwhile, grouse that Iowa is the worst possible place to launch an election season, and not just because of the weather.
The caucus process, which requires voters to appear in person on a wintry evening with no provision for absentee ballots, “makes voting needlessly difficult,” opined Ian Millhiser, a senior fellow at the liberal Center for American Progress on Monday. What’s more, Mr. Millhiser wrote, Iowa “contains no major cities and hardly any people of color.” Its population is more than 92 percent white, compared with a U.S. figure of 77 percent.
Yet Iowa also launched the presidency of the country’s first black president. Democratic voters, their ranks swelled by college students and other first-time caucus-goers, handed Barack Obama a 2008 victory that permanently dented Ms. Clinton’s seeming invincibility. The possibility of such surprises is why presidential contenders, and the reporters who trail them, spend January rambling through Iowa’s less-flat-than-advertised countryside, picking straw off their pants.
“People here have the luxury of being able to vote their heart,” said Kedron Bardwell, who chairs the political science department at Des Moines’ Simpson College.
Although it’s hard to imagine a ritual more nostalgic than Midwesterners convening to support a president in the dead of winter, taking the results seriously is a tradition younger than bell bottom pants. It wasn’t until 1976, when Jimmy Carter’s devotion to the state built media buzz for his ultimately successful presidential bid, that the caucus assumed its prominence.
Since then, Iowa’s function has mostly been to narrow the field by culling marginal candidates, hence an old political saw that “Iowa gives three tickets out.” With one exception, every president since 1972 has finished in the top three Iowa contenders.
But in a political process that seems increasingly scripted and market-tested, Iowa still offers the possibility of surprise. Mr. Goldford said the caucus “forces candidates to treat voters as human beings, rather than as props in photo ops. And it allows relatively unknown and underfunded candidates a chance to show up on the radar.”
Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum was polling in the single digits until days before he beat eventual nominee Mitt Romney in the 2012 caucus by 34 votes. Future presidents, meanwhile, have sometimes had a rockier path. George H.W. Bush won the caucus in 1980, when he lost the party’s nomination to Ronald Reagan, but finished third in Iowa in 1988, the year he was elected president.
And for all the money washing around politics now, “you can’t buy Iowa. Anyone has a shot at being president,” said Andy McGuire, who chairs the state’s Democratic Party.
Many of those attending Mr. Cruz’s event, however, were just hoping to confirm their decision to support him.
“I want him to reaffirm the things we’ve been hearing,” said Elizabeth Smith, 73, a “very conservative” voter from nearby Truro.
Although other candidates had wavered from a strict adherence to the Constitution, she said, “Cruz has not wobbled much.”
Such voters heard plenty to like Tuesday morning. There was applause and scattered“amens” when Mr. Cruz pledged to abolish the federal Department of Education, and initiate a federal investigation of Planned Parenthood.
But not everyone was swayed. Stephen Blobaum of West Des Moines asked Mr. Cruz about what he’d done to improve education and the lives of children. Mr. Cruz’s answer, which focused on his prosecution of child rapists and opposition to the federal Common Core curriculum, left him unsatisfied. “If there’s no federal oversight, what happens when states and local government fails children?” said Mr. Blobaum, a father of two. “And if we don’t have standards, how do we compete internationally?”
Mr. Blobaum said he was also considering Mr. Rubio, but that no matter whom he settled on, he’d take part in the caucus. He said Iowans had a special responsibility to do so.“One vote in the caucus,” he said, “is worth I don’t know how many votes in the general election.”
Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2533.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.