The U.S. Supreme Court will hear an appeal — sought by seven petitioners, including the Roman Catholic dioceses of Pittsburgh and Erie and Geneva College — challenging an Obamacare provision requiring that contraceptives be made available to women employees of their charitable agencies.
The decision, signed by Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. and issued Friday, means the case will be argued, probably in March, and most likely decided by June.
“We are very pleased that the Supreme Court has decided to take up what we believe is a fundamental issue of religious liberty,” said attorney John D. Goetz of the Jones Day law firm, which represents the Pittsburgh diocese. “And we are very heartened by the determination the diocese has shown. They’ve pursued this case for 3½ years, and they’ve shown a lot of faith and courage.”
“We are encouraged that the Supreme Court will hear our case and are hopeful that they will rule to protect not only our religious liberty but that of all Americans,” Pittsburgh Bishop David A. Zubik said in a statement released Friday evening.
White House press secretary Josh Earnest noted that seven appeals courts had sided with the government’s position, and he said the administration is confident the policy balances religious freedom and the needs of Americans to have access to birth control.
At issue is the Affordable Care Act’s requirement that most employers provide insurance coverage that includes provisions for contraceptives. The requirement doesn’t apply to core religious employers such as churches, but faith-based charities and schools are exempt only if they submit a written objection, after which the insurer directly provides the contraceptive coverage.
The Pittsburgh and Erie dioceses argue that even by submitting a written objection, the chain of events would make them complicit in a moral evil — facilitating the use of artificial birth control, some of which they argue can cause early-term abortions. Protestant groups such as Geneva College in Beaver Falls are focusing their objections on providing contraceptives they believe could cause abortions.
The U.S. District Court for Western Pennsylvania sided with the dioceses and Geneva in their initial lawsuits, but in February, a three-judge panel of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the ruling, saying the opt-out provision would not make the dioceses complicit in providing birth control.
Faced with an imminent enforcement of the law in April, the dioceses sought and received a temporary stay in May from Justice Alito, who hears such petitions from the 3rd Circuit.
“We are grateful that the U.S. Supreme Court has decided to hear our case and consider whether the mandate to facilitate insurance coverage for contraceptives, and other practices contrary to Catholic teaching, violates the Religious Freedom Restoration Act,” Bishop Zubik said. “That federal law, which was enacted in order to respect the teachings of all religious bodies and the practices of individual believers, goes to the very heart of our concerns. The insurance mandate, which is one small provision of the Affordable Care Act, would require us to facilitate access to contraceptives, sterilization and abortifacients contrary to our teachings.”
The case pits attorneys representing the diocese against Obama administration attorneys representing Secretary of Health and Human Services Sylvia Burwell. Other petitioners include Houston Baptist University in Texas; the Little Sisters of the Poor; Priests for Life; South Nazarene University in Oklahoma; and the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Washington.
The administration had wanted the Supreme Court to hear just one appeal, but the justices instead have consolidated the seven separate petitions, setting the stage for a precedent-setting ruling.
The Obama administration had tried to address faith-based objections by saying religious nonprofit organizations, such as Catholic Charities in Pittsburgh, could file paperwork that would result in the insurer covering the costs of contraceptives.
But Jones Day lawyer Mickey Pohl said earlier this year that even that action causes the services to be provided when they otherwise would not. “That’s where you become complicit,” he said.
Gregory Baylor, who represents Geneva College, made the same point: “Geneva can’t take the chance it will be complicit in even one death.”
The college, which belongs to the theologically conservative Reformed Presbyterian Church, objects to offering two forms of emergency contraception taken after sex and two forms of intrauterine devices, on the belief that these cause abortions, Mr. Baylor said. The Catholic dioceses also oppose offering coverage of sterilization and birth control pills, Mr. Pohl said.
Many people have dubbed the issue “Hobby Lobby II,” referring to the 2014 Supreme Court ruling exempting closely held corporations from aspects of the Affordable Care Act on the basis of religious objections. Unlike that case involving for-profit businesses, this one involves religiously affiliated nonprofit groups, which face a different set of rules.
Women’s groups urged the court to sustain the contraception requirement. “Women deserve insurance coverage of birth control no matter where they work or go to school,” Gretchen Borchelt, vice president of the National Women’s Law Center, said in a statement to The New York Times. “It’s unfair and harmful for some employers and schools to use their religious beliefs to deny women vital health care that also makes them more economically secure.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.