It was just after 2 p.m. on Monday, Sept. 17, 2017, and Chris Cartier was sitting at his computer at Quest Diagnostics, working.
Except his right hand wasn’t working well.
He got up to use the bathroom — and ran into the corner of one of the cubicles.
“It kind of stuck in my head for a second,” said Cartier, now 74, during a recent interview. “I’ve been there 12 years and I've never run into the corner before.”
Cartier was having a stroke. He drove himself to meet his wife, who quickly realized something was wrong, and the pair rushed through 5 p.m. traffic to the UPMC Passavant emergency room, which took about 25 minutes.
Every 40 seconds in the U.S., someone has a stroke, per the American Heart Association. Every 3 minutes and 11 seconds, someone dies from one.
Read More
Patients can lose up to 2 million brain cells every minute of a stroke; every hour without treatment, the brain ages 3 ½ years.
That’s why a swift response is imperative. It’s a truth that emergency medical personnel know well but can be tricky to spot — strokes present as a variety of symptoms, some with pain and some without, some instantaneous, others slow, including Cartier’s.
“The entire mission of stroke therapy is to restore the blood flow to the brain as soon as possible,” said Alhamza Al-Bayati, associate professor of neurology and neurosurgery at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine and a physician specializing in stroke. “A crew on the spot will not be able to tell the type of stroke,” he said, until they bring the patient to the hospital and do imaging.

‘You really have to make a decision’
Those having an ischemic stroke, where blood flow to certain areas of the brain is blocked due to a clot in a vessel or artery, can be given clot-busting drugs at the hospital. But these drugs have only been studied for use up to four hours — so patients who wait longer are not eligible and lose out on a treatment that could have restored function.
“These therapies are time-dependent,” said Christian Martin-Gill, professor of emergency medicine at Pitt, chief of the Division of Emergency Medical Services and an attending emergency physician at UPMC, specializing in stroke. “It’s very important that folks not only identify these symptoms but engage the health care system in a timely manner. A number of patients don’t get that medication because they don’t present to the hospital soon enough.”
Also, not all hospitals are designated stroke centers, so they are equipped with differing levels of treatment. A primary stroke center stocks clot-busting drugs, but someone having a hemorrhaging stroke, where blood leaks into the brain or surrounding tissues, needs care at a comprehensive stroke center.
“The important thing is that you understand the price of each decision,” said Lee Schwamm, associate dean for digital strategy and transformation for the Yale School of Medicine, senior vice president of Yale New Haven Health System, and a stroke expert. “The price of going to the nearest facility is, while you’ll get them there quickly, you may have just radically diminished chances of a good recovery if you can’t provide the services they need.”
Schwamm helped create the 2021 American Heart Association guidelines for stroke patients, which lays out the algorithm EMS can follow when evaluating someone for a stroke and deciding where to transport them.
These choices depend heavily on geography as well as how quickly the person or those surrounding them recognize the stroke.
For urban areas that may have five hospitals within a 30-minute drive, EMS should take a stroke patient to the center with the highest level of capability, per the guidelines: that is, a comprehensive stroke center, which can treat all types of strokes and has 24/7 neurology and surgery on-site. In rural communities, the longest time window for EMS is one hour — if EMS can get a stroke patient to a comprehensive center in one hour, they should. But if not, take them to a primary stroke center, said Schwamm.
“In rural settings, you really have to make a decision,” said Martin-Gill. “These are all things we talk about in this city all the time.” Gill also worked with Schwamm to write the 2021 guidelines.
‘A very patchwork response system’
These snap decisions are extra crucial for severe patients like Joe Brown.

The Homewood resident, 47 at the time, was working the night shift cleaning an office building on July 16, 2021 when he felt dizzy and collapsed around 11:30 p.m. Coworkers helped alert EMS, who took him to UPMC Mercy, but Brown doesn’t remember any of that. He only remembers waking up a few days later.
Brown had an ischemic stroke, caused by a blood clot in his chest that traveled to his brain, fragmented into three pieces and jammed major arteries in three different brain regions, including speech and motor regions. His right side is paralyzed, and he’s working to get his speech back. During a June 13 interview at his home, his wife Gwen helped speak for him.
Brown knows that if he hadn’t gotten to a hospital when he did, he would have died. But would he have more capabilities had he gotten there sooner?
That night, his wife found out about Brown’s condition when she called to say goodnight. Someone else answered his phone and said he had been taken to the hospital.
“I don’t know how long between the stroke and the hospital,” said Gwen Brown. “If it was faster, would he be in a different condition? I do wonder about that, and it comes to mind around the anniversary [of his stroke].”
Coordination between medical personnel also plays a role, and many units deal with short-staffing, burnout and trauma among emergency responders.
“We have a very patchwork response system,” said Schwamm. “We need so much better standardization and coordination of EMS. These time-critical situations are where you see the cost most vividly.”
Improvements are on the horizon. Local physicians are excited by the prospect of artificial intelligence speeding up the diagnostic process by surveying a patient’s medical records to help EMS decide on transport.
“We’re moving beyond the rigid time windows,” said Al-Bayati. “Artificial intelligence dramatically helps us as physicians or healthcare providers make our decision-making in a more efficient way.”
Schwamm said he thinks “we should be getting to a point where we’re not relying on stressed-out human beings. We need to provide better support for those treatment decisions at the point of care.”
As an option, he pointed to the mobile stroke unit, a specialized ambulance equipped with CT scanners and clot-busting drugs to deliver care immediately and help discern the type of stroke a person may be having. Cleveland Clinic has been using mobile stroke units for more than 10 years and found in further studies that it improved functional outcomes for stroke patients.
“Part of me was really hoping that by the time we got to now, we would have some better tools for pre-hospital stroke diagnosis,” said Schwamm.
‘We see patients who get symptoms and go to bed’
But the first step begins at home.
Public education about the signs of stroke jumpstart the algorithm and get a person to the right care as quickly as possible. Signs of stroke include vision changes, facial drooping or muscle weakness; especially on one side, slurred speech or inability to communicate and a sudden or severe headache.
Remember B-E F-A-S-T, the stroke acronym, which stands for Balance, Eyes, Face, Arms, Speech and Time — as in, time to call 9-1-1.
Judy Cartier, Chris Cartier’s wife, said a stroke never entered her mind as a possibility for her husband’s condition at the time.
“I didn’t have that awareness at that point,” she said. Chris Cartier also said if he knew more about the signs of a stroke, he might have noticed he couldn’t write and was losing his ability to communicate.
“Public understanding of the symptoms of stroke is still one of the biggest barriers,” said Schwamm. “A lot of times we see patients who get symptoms and go to bed. They just sleep it off. Most ischemic stroke is painless. More public education I think would go a long way.”
Cartier has made progress since his stroke nearly eight years ago. He walks with a cane and has seen improved mobility in his right side, though his right arm and hand are still working to come back. He can dress himself, brush his teeth, put cream cheese on a bagel, load the dishwasher and sort laundry.
Joe Brown and his wife are still working to improve Brown’s mobility, functionality, speech and memory.
“I can tell he’s getting better as we go along,” said Gwen Brown. “He’s remembering more things … He can dress himself if I lay the clothes out for him.”
Brown hopes one day to not need an aide, who helps the couple with tasks of the house and activities of daily living. He also wants an adaptive vehicle so he can drive, and a dog certified as an emotional support animal.
He’s more laid back now than he was before his stroke, said his wife. Things that used to bother him slide off his back now. When he asked how he feels about his recovery, he answered in his own words:
“I feel fine. We’re getting it together.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.