Plastics are ubiquitous. And a growing body of research, including a new study related to heart health, shows the toll of this prevalence.

An untold number of products, from cosmetics to toys, contain a plastics preservative broadly known as phthalates. Often called plasticizers, this group of chemicals is used in plastics production as a softener, such as in polyvinyl chloride, or PVC.

Phthalates were linked to 350,000 deaths, according to a study led by NYU researchers and published last month in the journal eLancet Biomedicine.

“Plastics contribute to heart disease through multiple mechanisms,” said Leonardo Trasande, senior author on the paper and a plastics expert.

Advertise with us

The report comes amid similar studies on micro- and nanoplastics’ ability to enter human tissue, and builds off first-of-its-kind research by the same team comparing phthalate exposures to national disease data.

Much of the research on phthalates has been focused on their impacts to reproductive health. Phthalates are endocrine disruptors: They mimic hormones in our body and disrupt normal hormone signaling, which can lead to inflammation, cancer, fertility problems and even changes to the way genes are expressed.

Researchers at NYU’s Grossman School of Medicine, however, wanted to learn more about how these chemicals impact heart health and whether they are linked to deaths from heart disease.

The April study pulls from previous research from the same group of scientists and creates a snapshot of a global population impacted negatively by phthalates.

“We had done a global mapping of distribution of phthalate exposures, and then we extrapolated deaths due to cardiovascular disease based on the exposure in every individual country that we modeled,” explained Trasande, also a professor at NYU. “The final step was linking that to data on the global burden of disease.”

Advertise with us

What they found was not surprising even to other researchers in the field, but highlights the burden of plastics and their potential impacts on heart health.

“You can ingest, you can inhale. They’re everywhere,” said Vasilus Vasiliou, department chair of the Yale University School of Public Health and a professor of environmental health sciences, who thought the study was well-executed.

(James Hilston / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Using 2008 data on phthalate exposures, which was based on concentrations of the plasticizer in the urine of study participants, as well as 2018 data on heart disease and death, the researchers estimated through statistical analysis that 350,000 global deaths were plastic-attributable in 2018, with certain phthalate chemicals contributing to 13.7% of those cardiovascular-related deaths.

They mostly looked at the chemical di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate, or DEHP, in addition to three other phthalate chemicals. DEHP, present in everyday items including tablecloths, furniture upholstery, rainwear and baby clothes, is known to carry developmental and reproductive health harms, with concerns for pregnant women and their babies, per the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The CDC and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services list DEHP as a probable human carcinogen.

The NYU researchers also pulled data from 200 countries to examine the distribution of death and posited that 41% of DEHP-associated deaths from heart disease were concentrated in the Middle East and South Asia, with East Asia and the Pacific also experiencing a notable number of deaths.

Advertise with us

“It’s shocking where the distribution was most substantial,” said Trasande. “It was not in the high-income countries.”

He expects this could be due to a lack of regulations or because of on-the-job exposure while working in manufacturing, production or waste.

“Plastics are used from cradle to grave in their own way,” he said.

DEP, DEHP’s cousin, was found in the baby mattresses of Canadian households, according to a separate paper published last month in the journal Environmental Science & Technology Letters, which measured the sleeping environments and the air of 21 households.

Those researchers also found 28 semi-volatile organic compounds from room air samplers installed in the children’s rooms.

Advertise with us

Jennifer Adibi, an epidemiologist in Pittsburgh specializing in phthalates and their biological role in reproductive health, called the NYU study “a creative approach to assess the potential global impacts on DEHP and heart disease.” It’s a "provocative finding” she hopes leads to more research.

Much of the existing research on phthalates and health is in the reproductive space, she said, so examining cardiovascular effects is relatively new.

Aaron Barchowsky, a cardiovascular toxicologist who studies arsenic exposure and heart disease, tended to agree.

“Cardiovascular disease is really at the low end of health risks for phthalates, versus we know a lot about endocrine disruption,” said Barchowsky, a professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Public Health.

Barchowsky took issue with the blanket “cardiovascular disease” metric, as opposed to drilling down to specific heart conditions.

Advertise with us

“They don't define the type of cardiovascular disease, and this is somewhat important in the toxicology field, because sometimes it's much better to look at a very specific disease rather than lumping them together,” he said.

Barchowsky would have liked to see biomonitoring data on heart health, like blood pressure readings, pulse and oxygen, while measuring specific phthalate concentrations.

“If you just look at total cardiovascular disease globally, that’s a huge number,” he said. “And you can have a small change in a huge number, and it looks like a big number.”

The NYU researchers also acknowledged in previous research that DEHP concentrations have been declining globally.

The Food and Drug Administration has placed regulations on DEHP, setting limits in 2011 on the allowable level of the compound in plastic water bottles and establishing guidelines in 2012 for DEHP limits in products regulated by the Center for Drug Evaluation, such as pharmaceuticals.

Advertise with us

These regulations, while beneficial to the consumer, left some researchers skeptical about the team’s choice to focus on DEHP in the analysis.

“Folks have recognized that DEHP is a problem and that's why there's kind of an industry ban on it,” said Barchowsky. “There are limitations for using it in products that would be exposed to children. So it's gone out of favor, but if you look at some of the cardiovascular risk data out there for phthalates, there may be other phthalates that are replacing DEHP.”

Because of these regulations, people in the U.S. are more educated about microplastics and the harm of plastics, said Vasiliou. Europe has even stronger regulations.

Vasiliou said he wants to see stricter regulations in manufacturing to protect workers from exposures and to increase public awareness.

Trasande also hopes for swifter regulations on phthalates and plastics in food packaging and other consumer products. On April 24, he sat on a panel with Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., with the Ocean Plastics Leadership Network, discussing toxic materials in food packaging.

Advertise with us

Trasande applauded Kennedy for his call for more research into toxic chemicals and said he was “gobsmacked” that medical schools only require one to three hours of environmental health curriculum.

As per the study, he said, “I would caution against delaying action just because more research may be needed.”