This is the third installment in our Sort of Sober series, in which we look at legal mind- and body-altering substances.
For years, sobriety was viewed as an all-or-nothing concept — either you drank or abstained. But movements like "sober curious" and the "California sober" lifestyle are redefining this approach, blending moderation with wellness.

The sober curious phrase, coined by author Ruby Warrington and used in the title of her 2018 book, encourages exploring life without alcohol to embrace clarity, better sleep and emotional connection. It’s especially popular among younger generations and social media influencers. In contrast, the California sober notion, popularized by singer Demi Lovato’s 2021 song of the same name, refers to abstaining from alcohol and hard drugs while using cannabis in moderation.
Just as alcohol is substituted with the likes of kombucha and herbal teas, many people are similarly turning to cannabinoids — including delta-8 and delta-9 THC. Emerging as favorites in the sober-adjacent lifestyle, these cannabinoids promise relaxation without the hangover. However, they come with their own set of concerns.
According to the National Cancer Institute, a cannabinoid is a type of chemical in marijuana that causes drug-like effects all through the body, including the central nervous system and the immune system. The main active cannabinoid in marijuana is delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol (THC).
In Pennsylvania, products — commonly, gummies — containing less than .3% of delta-9 that are derived from hemp are legal to purchase at hemp shops, convenience stores and online vendors. Hemp shops and convenience stores may require buyers to be 21 or older before selling them. Products with delta-9 derived from marijuana are only available for purchase at medical cannabis dispensaries. Both hemp and cannabis are derived from the same plant.
Read More
A 2022 report by the University of Buffalo called delta-8 the “nicer younger sibling” of delta-9 THC, but local experts don’t agree. They say because of the legal haze in which delta-8 is manufactured and sold, the likelihood of impurities, contamination, unhealthy additives and untested potencies make ingesting delta-8 a risky move.
Delta-8 comes from the hemp plant and typically is synthesized from CBD oil in order to get higher concentrations. The federal 2018 Farm Bill, signed into law by then-President Donald Trump, legalized hemp and its derivatives containing less than 0.3% delta-9 THC. Therefore, many manufacturers, sellers and users of delta-8 maintain that although not specifically addressed in the bill, delta-8 is legal via the bill’s loophole that allows the sale of hemp-derived products in areas where recreational use of cannabis is prohibited, as well as where medicinal marijuana requires a doctor’s authorization. By late 2020, delta-8-THC exploded in popularity, the report said.
Delta differences?
Delta-8 and delta-9 THC are similar, but their molecular structures differ. Delta-8 has a double bond on the eighth carbon chain, while delta-9’s is on the ninth, a slight variation affecting potency and interactions with the brain’s receptors. Additionally, delta-9 can be derived from both cannabis and hemp plants. This origin ultimately determines resulting products’ legal status.
For example, in Pennsylvania, delta-9 products, like gummies, are legal to purchase by anyone if derived from a hemp plant containing no more than 0.3% delta-9 THC. However, marijuana-derived delta-9 products are only available to qualified patients under the Pennsylvania medical marijuana program.
One point that continues to confuse the legality of delta-9 THC is the 0.3% threshold. Federal law specifies that the original cannabis or hemp plant must contain less than 0.3% delta-9 THC by dry weight. However, some manufacturers — particularly unlicensed cannabis confectioners — misinterpret this to mean that the final product must contain less than 0.3% delta-9 THC by weight, which can lead to confusion and mislabeling.
“I just ran into a vendor who sells me my pork and beef products at a farmers market. He says he makes all his money selling THC products. And I said, ‘That's a federal crime,’” said Kent Vrana, emeritus chair of pharmacology at Penn State’s College of Medicine and director of PSU’s Medical Marijuana Academic Clinical Research Center. The vendor disagreed, telling Vrana that if it’s “in a product that's less than 0.3%, then it's legal."
“And so, he's selling these 2-ounce chocolate bars that have, I don't know, 10 or 20 milligrams of THC, which is a lot.” Vrana said. “It's a misinterpretation of the law.”
Conflicting federal and state laws also create confusion about whether delta-8 products are legal, illegal or somewhere in between.
In Pennsylvania, the legal status of delta-8 THC is contentious. Officially, the state's Controlled Substance, Drug, Device and Cosmetic Act (Act 64) classifies delta-8 as a Schedule I controlled substance, making it illegal. This is bolstered by recent enforcement actions, such as raids by state police and the Lancaster County District Attorney’s Office, which seized thousands of delta-8 THC products from stores in June 2023, citing their sale and possession as unlawful.
In October, Westmoreland County detectives and local police seized delta products from vape stores in Hempfield Township, Delmont, Latrobe and Lower Burrell, after multiple students from local school districts were found with vape cartridges.
However, debate arises from the federal 2018 Farm Bill, which legalized hemp and its derivatives containing less than 0.3% delta-9 THC. While all synthetic THCs are considered to be Schedule I drugs under the bill, some argue it still creates a loophole that means delta-8 can be manufactured and sold under the same type of restrictions as hemp-derived CBD oil. This conflicting interpretation of state and federal laws has created confusion.
Delta-8 is often synthesized from hemp-derived CBD — called cannabidiol — using chemical processes that can involve harmful solvents, leaving behind unwanted contaminants, according to the Food and Drug Administration, which has issued warnings, noting the lack of regulation and the potential for dangerous by-products in delta-8 products. Reports of adverse effects, including cases of unintentional exposure — especially in children — have sparked alarm.
According to a 2022 article published in the National Institutes of Health’s National Library of Medicine, “Closing the Loophole on Hemp-Derived Cannabis Products,” there is no established minimum purchasing age for hemp-derived cannabis products. In addition, there are no requirements for hemp-derived products to include warning labels for the presence of THC, or dosage instructions. Delta-8 products, the article states, are often available as chocolates, gummies, cookies and brownies, with bright and colorful packaging, all of which are particularly attractive to children and teens. Additionally, delta-8 vape cartridges come in a wide range of sweet and fruity flavors, also appealing to young people.
After starting to track delta-8 exposures in April 2022, the Pittsburgh Poison Center has recorded 24, 40 and 30 exposures in 2022, 2023 and 2024, respectively. Many of those cases involved children 17 and younger, with 15 such cases reported in 2022 and 18 in both 2023 and 2024. Seventeen total cases over those years required hospitalization.
A Poison Center spokesperson urged people to call 800-222-1222 for immediate 24-hour assistance from nationally certified toxicology experts if they have concerns over exposure — accidental or otherwise — to delta-8 or other substances.
The FDA has reported safety concerns with delta-8 THC products, receiving 104 adverse event reports between December 2020 and February 2022. Poison control centers across the U.S. recorded 2,362 delta-8 THC exposure cases between January 2021 and February 2022. Per that data:
- 58% involved adults, 41% involved children under 18.
- 40% were unintentional exposures, with 82% of these affecting children.
- 70% required medical evaluation, and 8% of cases led to critical care admission.
- One pediatric case resulted in death.
In October 2022, a Virginia mother was charged with felony murder and child neglect in the death of her 4-year-old son, who ate a large amount of delta-8 THC gummies and died two days later, according to The Associated Press. She later pled guilty to involuntary manslaughter and was sentenced to 10 years in prison.
The safety debate
Aside from the legality of the products, the ingredients and the potency of the THC, especially in the unregulated delta-8, should also trigger concerns, Vrana explained. One important distinction to consider is that “[cannabis sativa] only makes delta-9. So where does delta-8 come from?”
“After the Farm Bill of 2018, you recall all the CBD oils that started showing up everywhere? … And it turns out, if you boil [CBD] in an organic solvent and acid, it turns into delta-8,” Vrana said. “So the take-home message … is that delta-8 THC is synthetic and the reaction is so easy you can do it in your kitchen. So who knows what's in that stuff?”
The FDA has echoed many of the same concerns as Vrana, warning that:
- Delta-8 THC products have not been evaluated or approved by the FDA for safe use and may be marketed in ways that put the public health at risk.
- Delta-8 THC has psychoactive and intoxicating effects. The FDA is also concerned that delta-8 THC products likely expose consumers to much higher levels of the substance than are naturally occurring in hemp cannabis raw extracts.
- Delta-8 THC products often involve use of potentially harmful chemicals to create the concentrations of delta-8 THC claimed in the marketplace.
- Manufacturing of delta-8 THC products may occur in uncontrolled or unsanitary settings, which may lead to the presence of unsafe contaminants or other potentially harmful substances
- Delta-8 THC products should be kept out of the reach of children and pets.
Vrana and members of his research team purchased hemp flower that shop employees said were spritzed with delta-8. The store marketed it as delta-8 marijuana. The store marketed it as delta-8 marijuana.
“In fact, they're sprinkling something on there that you have no idea what's in it because you don't know who made it.”
When purchasing something from a medical dispensary, the plant used to make the product plus the product itself would have been tested for pesticides, heavy metals and mold, and that it has the correct concentration as marked on the product label, he said.
His team had the product tested and found “the stuff we bought from a vape shop had half as much delta-8 as [the label] said. Luckily, it had no pesticides or heavy metal, but it had 10 times the concentration of delta-9 that's legal in the state, but no one's regulating it. No one's testing it to find out. ... You can't trust this. It’s an unregulated Wild West. You don't know what's in this stuff.”
Roisin Sabol, a clinical pharmacist specializing in treatment of substance use disorders at UPMC’s Western Psychiatric Hospital, agreed that plenty of makers of delta-8 products are exploiting the loopholes.
The process, she said, “is something that can really vary among different manufacturers. It's not something that is regulated on the national basis, and essentially can lead to consumers being exposed to unpredictable levels of delta-8 and also much higher levels than they might be expecting based on historical trends and potency of the delta-8 or delta-9 products.”
Citing reports made to poison control centers and hospitals, Sabol said delta-8 users have reported experiences of drowsiness, slurred speech, stomach upset, vomiting and even hallucinations.
“A lot of that could be attributed to not definitely knowing the psychoactive components or potency of the delta-8. Because they’re so accessible, it can create some confusion for consumers: ‘But I can get it at almost any store I can walk into, how dangerous could it be?’ The fact that they are widely available does not necessarily speak to any level of safety or regulation,” Sabol said. “A lot of these substances are listed as ‘chemicals of concern’ ... but there’s not an easy, simple kind of way to address that they’re not currently federally controlled substances.”
This ambiguity around legality and ingredients hasn't stopped some individuals from turning to delta-8 and -9 products as part of their journey to reduce or quit using more harmful substances, said Jennifer Herbert, director of outpatient services at the Monroeville location of Recovery Centers of America.
Harm reduction has become an increasingly prominent approach in addiction medicine, focusing on minimizing the negative consequences of substance use rather than enforcing complete abstinence. This shift reflects a growing recognition that meeting individuals where they are — through strategies like medication-assisted treatment, needle exchange programs or substituting less harmful substances — can improve outcomes and support long-term recovery.
Herbert agrees that proper regulation and labeling is important, so that people know what they’re ingesting and possible side effects.
“[Delta-8] interferes with your ability to perceive things as they are. If you are somebody who has anxiety to be in a space where your perception is impaired, it could actually increase anxiety and not decrease it,” she said. “We know that people will get what they want, no matter what, but right now, we're making it very easy. And I also think regulations on how we're marketing them would be very helpful.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.