Overdose deaths among Black and white people in Allegheny County were fairly equal from 2008 to 2017. But then, in 2018, overdoses in the Black community skyrocketed.

It was right around the time fentanyl began to establish its presence in the illicit drug supply. By 2023, the overdose death rate for Black residents was more than triple that of whites, despite representing 13.5% of the population — compared to whites’ 79.1% — per the Census Bureau. 

The county said it has been addressing such racial disparities by reaching out to impacted communities, conducting provider trainings and building trust. As 2024 comes to a close, health officials continue to learn more about what works to bring those numbers down and assessing what still needs to be done.

They plan to take these strategies into the new year.

Advertise with us

“This is all so deeply rooted and not easily explained or understood,” said Erin Dalton, director of Allegheny County Department of Human Services.

In addition to learnings from increased outreach, DHS’ Bureau of Drug and Alcohol Services has in the past year been combing through overdose data to discover what might be causing this disparity — and how best to combat it.

“This year has been a lot of us looking at the data and recognizing there are some issues that are deep-rooted,” said Maisha Howze, assistant deputy director of the Bureau of Drug and Alcohol Services. “It’s historical, and it’s been happening for many years.”

Howze said the team has recently begun to implement and apply what it’s learned from investigating the data. In June 2023, DHS and the Allegheny County Health Department created a campaign focused on reaching Black families, called Connect, Protect and Recover, which contracts with local providers to bolster education about the drug supply and available resources.

Among the providers is Pathway to Care and Recovery, a recovery support organization located Downtown. The facility is open 24/7 and staffs a nurse and four certified recovery specialists — who have lived experience with drug and/or alcohol use — as well as 14 beds clients can use for up to 72 hours while awaiting treatment. 

Advertise with us

These expansive conditions and available services make it an ideal choice for DHS support: It’s one of the only substance use crisis support organizations in the region and is located in a hotspot area. After four-plus years in operation, Pathway — with a model that includes ongoing community outreach to individuals and families, care offered free of charge and direct referral to additional medical services — has reached thousands of people who otherwise may have been missed.

Between August and November of this year, Pathway to Care and Recovery reached at least a portion of the Black community, especially when looking at race-based percentages: Documents from the organization show they helped 291 Black and 306 white clients.

The team has upped its community outreach efforts since Pathway’s opening in November 2020, joining the Health Department and DHS at community events and establishing relationships with nearby public libraries, hospitals and other harm reduction organizations, such as Resolve Crisis Services and Prevention Point Pittsburgh. Funded by DHS and UPMC’s Community Care Behavioral Health, all services at Pathway are completely free to the client.

“Part of the campaign is to make people aware that you don’t need insurance to use our services,” said Linda Hoover, a vice president at Pathway.

Melissa Breckenridge, Pathway’s director, said about half of their clients in a given month are repeat customers — showing that the team has established trust within the community, an important tenet of recovery.

Advertise with us

“That says to me they feel safe coming back here, should they need services again,” she said. “We just want to help as many people as we can.”

Since opening, Pathway has seen more than 7,000 patients, an average of about 163 individuals a month, according to internal documents made available to the Post-Gazette. Breckenridge said the organization is the only 24/7 substance use crisis center in the region.

The team wants to continue to grow and hopes to get each of its staff enrolled in cultural sensitivity training.

This type of training can help providers and professional caregivers to understand cultural differences and contributing factors to racial gaps in overdose deaths, and may help explain why people sometimes refuse care.

From the moment a potential patient enters a facility, “they will understand whether they’re accepted or not,” said Howze. “So we’re helping our providers to go through training about how to engage those populations. You have to understand culture and the cultural differences to be able to effectively support this population.”

Advertise with us

It’s about getting to the heart of the person sitting across from you, she said.

“It’s not your typical cultural diversity, equity and inclusion and belonging training. There’s more intentionality behind it, and forcing those who are charged to serve some of our most vulnerable citizens in this county, with taking a look at themselves as well, and understanding their ability to really serve that population effectively.”

Evidence shows that Black people are prescribed medications for opioid use disorder — such as craving- and withdrawal-curbing methadone and buprenorphine — less often than whites. This could be one reason why overdose rates are higher in this population.

“There are definitely pretty big differences in access to treatment for opioid use disorder,” said Travis Donahoe, assistant professor in the health policy and management department at the University of Pittsburgh School of Public Health, specializing in the opioid crisis.

Donahoe also highlighted that Black people are statistically more likely to be involved in the criminal justice system, leaving them vulnerable to overdosing after release, or at risk of being denied medication for opioid use disorder while in jail.

Advertise with us

Between Jan. 1 and Dec. 10, 65% of inmates at Allegheny County Jail were Black, with the jail housing 1,871 total inmates on Dec. 10.

There could also be differences in the type of substances groups use.

For instance, both Erin Dalton and Travis Donahoe mentioned that fentanyl is increasingly being found in stimulants and other nonopioid substances. Overdose deaths involving cocaine have nearly tripled since 2012, according to data from the Allegheny County Overdose Dashboard.

“We see a difference by race in people dying with both stimulants and opioids in their system,” said Dalton. “Because the illegal drug supply is pretty contaminated, people might not actually consider themselves users of multiple substances.”

That means they may not have naloxone, the generic name for Narcan, on-hand, said Donahoe.

Advertise with us

“We’re seeing it have a much bigger impact on the Black versus the white population,” he said. “It’s hard to say why. It could be the case that people are not intending to use opioids, or don’t know they’re using opioids.”

This makes outreach and strong provider-patient interactions all the more crucial to closing the gap.

In its four-plus years, Downtown's Pathway to Care has seen more than 7,000 clients. (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

DHS and those involved with Connect, Protect and Recover hope to deepen their connections with providers in the coming year to address this, as well as support further provider education to reduce stigma, which may be implicit.

“We can’t have this conversation without saying there are some things historically where, as a group, we’ve not been treated well in the health system,” said Howze. “We need our providers to understand that that person may not just be being difficult, but in their fear and their mistrust, it may come off that way.”

DHS said it’s also working to contract with an organization that supports veterans with substance use disorders, and DHS encourages providers or organizations who think they fill a gap to reach out for support.

Advertise with us

Millions of opioid settlement funds to the county could help fund these efforts. Allegheny County received $6 million in opioid settlement funds in 2023 and has until June 2025 to spend it. So far, about 79% of that money has been contracted out, according to the opioid settlement dashboard. It has been spent on increasing access to housing and treatment for opioid use disorder, as well as for harm reduction services for incarcerated individuals.

With the coming year will be a year of continued implementation — health officials will just have to see what sticks.

“We recognize it is a concern, and if we don’t approach it intentionally and head on, we’ll lose that, and it’ll be just another initiative,” said Howze. “We need it to become a part of the culture within our substance use community.”