It’s not just about blood pressure and heart rate — a new study from the University of Pittsburgh links three social determinants of health to increased risk for teen prediabetes.

Looking specifically at food insecurity, household income and insurance (public vs. private), authors of the study — published in JAMA Network Open in June — call for an update of prediabetes and diabetes screening guidelines independent of race, in order to more comprehensively address the social factors that may be contributing to a person’s overall health.

Currently, the American Diabetes Association outlines four risk factors for adolescents, and only one risk factor needs to be met to justify a prediabetes screening: family history of diabetes, maternal history of diabetes during gestation, signs of insulin resistance, or being of Native American, Black, Asian, Pacific Islander or Latino descent.

That someone’s race alone can spur screening is a sticking point: Mary Ellen Vajravelu, senior author on the paper, and her team suggest a more holistic approach to understanding prediabetes risk.

Advertise with us

Prediabetes is a condition characterized by high A1C levels below the diabetes threshold, which puts people at risk for developing Type 2 diabetes, a condition that impacts 1.2 million Americans annually, per the American Diabetes Association. The rate of prediabetes has more than doubled over the past two decades, although a vast majority of people don’t know they have the reversible condition.

Researchers analyzed data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey from 2011 to 2018, representative of more than 10 million Americans aged 12 to 18.

“Many studies over the years demonstrate that diabetes affects people who are at social disadvantages,” said Vajravelu, an assistant professor of pediatrics at Pitt School of Medicine and a pediatric endocrinologist at UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh. “Our goal was to see whether these risk factors show up as early indicators of diabetes.”

Having a low household income was a high predictor of prediabetes, with prevalence of the condition 5.7% higher for those who reported low income. Prevalence was 5.3% higher if a family had public insurance versus private insurance, and 4.6% higher if the teen was food insecure. One-fifth of teens experienced all three indicators.

Different races were impacted differently, too. For instance, having public insurance was more likely to impact white and Asian youths compared to Black and Hispanic, whereas being from a low-income background affected Black and white youth disproportionately, compared to other races.

Advertise with us

“We could see that social risk factors had an impact, and we do know that these social factors are different across races because of historical racism,” said Vajravelu. “It points to the fact that we need something in place of race to guide our screening attempts. These social factors are important to think about when we’re deciding whether to screen.”

Margaret Larkins-Pettigrew, senior vice president and chief clinical diversity, equity and inclusion officer at Allegheny Health Network, praised the study’s statistical power, but she remained adamant that race still be a main consideration. She was not involved in the study.

“They did a really great job linking food insecurity with prediabetes,” she said. “We know we have a significant challenge. … But how we address these issues must include addressing race and ethnicity and the challenges that come with it.”

Black children are exposed to systemic racism as early as kindergarten, she said, and often have unique stress and trauma presentations because of issues like foster care and violence in the community.

“If we don’t pay attention to the fact that there are issues with race and ethnicity, we won’t be solving the problem at all,” said Larkins-Pettigrew. “Race does make a difference.”

Advertise with us

Michael Fang, assistant professor at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health specializing in diabetes screening and treatment, said the Pitt study was consistent with other research in the field, which supports the idea that social conditions early in life play a big role in shaping diabetes risk. He wasn’t surprised by the results.

“There is growing concern around the rising prevalence of Type 2 diabetes in young people,” said Fang, via email. “These data highlight that a lot of this early risk may be tied to adverse social conditions. This is a concern, but it also means that we may reduce this risk on a population level by thorough interventions and policies that reduce exposure to these conditions.”

Fang said the results suggest that race may not be a risk factor in itself, but rather a “surrogate for differences in social determinants of health.

“The [current] recommendation to screen ‘high-risk’ minority populations may need to be revisited,” he said.

Vajravelu recognized that the study only examined three out of many social determinants of health, and that effective behavioral change to reverse prediabetes may be complicated by the social factors that predispose youth in the first place.

Advertise with us

“The primary recommendation is a healthy lifestyle,” she said. “This can be especially hard to implement with a lack of resources and time. I think this is part of what we’re seeing with these results. It’s hard to reverse in some cases.”

Areas with food insecurity, for instance, are likely to be without ample green spaces or places to exercise, said Larkins-Pettigrew.

“They don’t even have the space to do what’s necessary to combat it,” she noted.

Vajravelu and her team are hoping to learn more about the link between social factors and diabetes with future studies. For one, it’s not clear whether the teens in the study who developed prediabetes went on to develop Type 2 diabetes.

“This is just one snapshot in time,” she said. “We also don’t know what other adverse childhood experiences these kids have had. I’m sure there are more.

Advertise with us

“We are looking into whether addressing social factors can have clinical outcomes for [these kids],” she added. “We are hoping to start that study sometime in the near future.”

Hanna Webster: hwebster@post-gazette.com.