Pennsylvanians, more so than their counterparts country-wide, like their tobacco.

Fourteen out of every 100 adults in the commonwealth smoke cigarettes, according to 2021 data from the Pennsylvania Department of Health. That’s significantly higher than the national average, which was 11.5% of adults for the same year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports.

The numbers escalate in Western Pennsylvania, with smokers representing 21% of adults in Armstrong County, 20% in Washington, 17% in Allegheny and Westmoreland, and 16% in Beaver and Butler, per 2018-2020 data from the state Department of Health.

These staggering statistics may make any product that advertises itself as a way for smokers to quit look like a good thing. Nicotine pouches — the newest offering on the tobacco market — claim to do just that. Whether or not these products truly are a viable method for smokers to kick their habits is central to a recently published study from the Center for Tobacco Research at The Ohio State University’s Comprehensive Cancer Center

Advertise with us

The short answer, from lead author Brittney Keller-Hamilton, an assistant professor at OSU’s College of Medicine: “If you don't already use them, if you don't use other forms of tobacco, you certainly shouldn't try them out.”

Published in the journal Addiction in November, the paper shows nicotine pouches don’t relieve tobacco cravings in the same way that cigarettes do.

The pouches are small, microfiber packs filled with nicotine, plus flavors and other chemicals. They are placed in the mouth but, unlike other so-called smokeless tobacco products such as chewing tobacco and moist snuff, they do not contain whole tobacco leaf. This reduces their likelihood of causing cancer; however, nicotine itself is still associated with a slew of health risks, including increased blood pressure, heart attack and addiction.

And there’s the possibility that this new delivery system contributes to a new generation picking up the habit.

Brittney Lee Keller-Hamilton, lead author on the study, is an epidemiologist and assistant professor in the Medical Oncology division at The Ohio State University. Tap or click for larger image.

“It does make me nervous that these are going to be poised to appeal to young people,” said Keller-Hamilton.

Advertise with us

In the CDC’s 2023 National Youth Tobacco Survey, 1.5% of middle and high school students reported nicotine pouch use, behind e-cigarettes (7.7%), cigarettes (1.6%) and cigars (1.6%).

To see if nicotine pouches were really an effective tool to quit smoking, Keller-Hamilton studied smokers from Appalachian regions, where high smoking rates breed increased cases of tobacco-associated diseases such as cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and emphysema. Participants visited the lab three times, abstaining from cigarettes before each session to ensure no nicotine was in their system. Over the course of those visits, they smoked a cigarette, used a weak nicotine pouch (3 milligrams) or used a strong nicotine pouch (6 milligrams).

As the participants, all Ohio residents, smoked or used a pouch, researchers repeatedly drew their blood to check for nicotine levels, and they administered questionnaires to quantify cravings and withdrawal.

A clear pattern emerged in the data: While smoking cigarettes led to a rapid, large spike in blood nicotine levels, nicotine pouches elicited only a gradual, sustained rise that never reached the intensity of cigarettes. Likewise, participants reported quick craving relief when smoking, but slower relief when using nicotine pouches.

These results suggest that nicotine pouches may not be well attuned to curbing the cravings that make it so difficult for smokers to quit.

Advertise with us

Keller-Hamilton noted that if the pouches are really meant to be a tool to stop smoking, they should ideally deliver nicotine in a manner more similar to cigarettes.

Her work points to a broader challenge that tobacco harm reduction researchers face: How to make alternative nicotine options, such as nicotine pouches and e-cigarettes, appealing and accessible to smokers who are trying to quit without attracting adolescents. Flavors, ease of use and decreased carcinogenic risk can all be attractive features for smokers attempting to quit, but they may also attract young people to a newfound nicotine addiction.

“The biggest downside right now is these products just have not been studied much yet,” says Keller-Hamilton. She hopes this research will pave the way for future work that can further explore how helpful nicotine pouches might be.

“This research is a really good first step,” she said.

Keller-Hamilton also warns non-tobacco users not to be allured by nicotine pouches’ promise of a safer tobacco.

Advertise with us

“They seem to be much less harmful than cigarettes and smokeless tobacco, but we don’t know much about them yet.”

If you are looking for help to quit smoking, state resources are available by calling 1-800-784-8669 or visiting https://pa.quitlogix.org/en-us/.

Marilyn Perkins (marilynperkins7@gmail.com) is a freelance science writer based in Los Angeles.